4 ms·
Your odds never change, this is not how maths work. It's always 1/6, just like the odds of getting heads/tails in a coin flip is ALWAYS 1/2 no matter how many t
by gambiting 14y ago
Your odds never change, this is not how maths work. It's always 1/6, just like the odds of getting heads/tails in a coin flip is ALWAYS 1/2 no matter how many times you flipped already. Odds of receiving a certain outcome X number of times in a row can change,but the odds of a single event never,never,never do. Even if you flip a coin 10000 and got tails 10000 times, your 10001 flip also has a 50/50 chance of being heads or tails.
- jergason 14y agoThat is true with coin flips because the probability of a next coin toss coming up heads or tails is independent[0] of any previous coin tosses. Assuming you aren't spinning between turns, the probabilities are not independent anymore. 0: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independence_(probability_theory) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independence_(probability_theor...
- emidln 14y agoThat's not how maths work. You're describing something that works for non-dependent events. Flipping a coin 50 times previously has no bearing on how it will flip the 51st time. The events are said to be independent. In a six round revolver loaded with a single bullet and then randomized, pulling the trigger advances the next round. The first pull has a 1/6 (or 1/600, whatever) chance of firing. You will fire (assuming no mechanical malfunction and no randomization of the round after each pull) in those first 6 shots with a probability of 1.
- gambiting 14y agoSorry, I honestly thought that you would spin before every try, in which case, every test would have the same 1/6 probability of firing.
- avalaunch 14y agoWhich just means you didn't read the comment to which you were replying...
- gambiting 14y agoI did, but because I didn't know that in Russian Roulette you are not supposed to spin before each try, I assumed that the guy I was replying to was wrong.
- matthuggins 14y agoSimple misunderstanding that I made as well until I read your comment chain.
- damoncali 14y agoIm not sure you understand how a revolver works.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- firefoxman1 14y agoThis is hacker news, chances are 1/6 he knows what a revolver is.
- ewang1 14y agoActually, it's 1/2 chance since it's either "yes" or "no".
- StevenXC 14y agoAhh, the freshman probability theorem. AKA the Lotto player's defense.
- oneeyedpigeon 14y agoSo the chance that I'm God is 1/2? Cool.
- evanmoran 14y agoRevolver is a 1 in 6, but I say much higher he knows what a Desert Eagle or AWP is =). #CSDoesntStandForComputerScience
- hfsktr 14y agoI believe he meant that he first person has 1/6 (at least or most...idk) but assuming the next person goes there is one less chamber each time. 1/5, 1/4, etc. until you get to 1/1 at least. There would have to be some change between rounds to change that part.
- gambiting 14y agoSorry, I honestly thought that you would spin before every try, in which case, every test would have the same 1/6 probability of firing.
- sjwright 14y ago> until you get to 1/1 at least Possibly even more!
- tomjen3 14y agoActually the chance of the 6th person getting the bullet is initially no greater than the chance that the nth person gets the bullet, since you have to take into account that the gun fires before the first person gets the gun, which happens to be 5/6.
- Aaronneyer 14y agoHe's saying that when it is first spun, the odds are low because of the weighting explained earlier. After that it is not re-spun and is instead advanced to the next bullet, which does change it, because you now are limiting the number of total possible places for the bullet.
- TheSilentMan 14y agoIf you're not re-spinning between turns you're not doing independent trials like flipping a coin repeatedly.
- gambiting 14y agoSorry, I honestly thought that you would spin before every try, in which case, every test would have the same 1/6 probability of firing.
- asafira 14y agoOuch, looks like you are taking a lot of slack for this --- don't worry, I didn't realize the protocol for Russian Roulette was not to spin again after the first attempt, either. You're right if they spun it again afterwards, they are right if you just continue through the 6 bullet slots in the revolver.