3 ms·
The difference is quite simple. Not quite so simple. Banks are not like regular companies. Especially those in question. In a way, they are part of the public
by noonespecial 18y ago
The difference is quite simple.
Not quite so simple. Banks are not like regular companies. Especially those in question. In a way, they are part of the public infrastructure. These banks wove an intricate web reaching into nearly every financial nook of the economy, from old ladies pensions to hospitals operating capital. The leaders of these banks manipulated the ratings systems, hid risk from investors (the public kind), and invented assets with bogus bookkeeping schemes. They stole billions from the public all while paying themselves 100's of millions in bonuses.
In short, bank leaders stole real money from real people using actual fraud. Lots. From lots.
The pirate bay: helped people connect with each other and then maybe trade copyrighted files that might have led to the loss of potential sales of zero marginal cost goods.
The bankers: Literally stalled human progress. The "pirates": Umm... Maybe "Thundercats The Movie" will have a smaller production budget? Even the comparison is obscene.
- jibiki 18y agoHaque doesn't accuse the bankers of fraud, just of "economically damaging actions." Reading that as "massive fraud" makes the article's point much clearer. (It's probably impossible to criminalize "economically damaging actions" in general.)
- noonespecial 18y ago(It's probably impossible to criminalize "economically damaging actions" in general.) That might be an extremely succinct way of expressing that point. The trackers didn't host any actual copyright infringing content. They did however engage in behavior that was likely "economically damaging" is some sense of the term. They still got jail time.
- lucumo 18y agoIt was also likely to result in illegal actions, which cannot be said for the bankers. Now, it's possible to argue about whether or not either should be illegal, but such is not the territory of courts, it is the territory of politicians.