2 ms·
35 USC 101 read that way long before State Street Bank & Trust v. Signature Financial Group in 1998 got business process patents going. And we have over a cent
by btilly 14y ago
35 USC 101 read that way long before State Street Bank & Trust v. Signature Financial Group in 1998 got business process patents going. And we have over a century of jurisprudence prior to that on the proper meaning of the word "process" which did not point towards business methods being patentable processes.
Furthermore my understanding is that the Supreme Court has punted on this issue. But since the ruling precedent is from United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, the window is open for the Supreme Court at some point to disagree with business method patents. (Though Bilski showed no evidence that they are eager to tackle that issue.)
- rayiner 14y ago> 35 USC 101 read that way long before State Street Bank & Trust v. Signature Financial Group in 1998 got business process patents going 35 USC 101 was always read very broadly--it's just been relatively recently (for obvious reasons), that business method patents have become relevant.
- btilly 14y ago35 USC 101 was always read very broadly... It could always have been read broadly, but was it in practice? Wikipedia brought up the 1908 Hotel Security Checking Co. v. Lorraine Co and the 1950 Joseph E. Seagram & Sons v. Marzell as examples of cases where courts rejected patents on business methods. Furthermore the USPTO for many years would not accept such patent applications. Not out of capriciousness, but because they really thought that such patents would not pass legal muster. These stand as examples showing that 35 USC 101 was not always read as broadly as it is being read today.