3 ms·
I think it's a little unfair to imply the academic publishing model had anything to do with the Reinhart-Rogoff debacle. Their paper was supported by the non-pr
by notahacker 14y ago
I think it's a little unfair to imply the academic publishing model had anything to do with the Reinhart-Rogoff debacle. Their paper was supported by the non-profit NBER who publish it in open access form (the AER version is downloadable from Rogoff's website too) and was never peer-reviewed. The authors shared the dataset with the first person to question the results.
If anything it's a reminder that people are cautious about challenging empirical work by academics of sufficient standing even if it's universally available, has significant, controversial implications and is widely cited by high-profile nonacademics. Open access alone doesn't seem to affect that.
- emiliobumachar 14y agoIf one did not need to ask the authors for the dataset, implicitly challenging their work, but could instead just download it from a public website linked to in the paper from day one...
- jacoblyles 14y agoI agree with you. But there are a lot of professors that won't share data when asked, so they deserve credit for that.
- emiliobumachar 14y agoIndeed. Also, not publishing the bulk of data is, unfortunately, standard procedure, not something those particular authors made up.
- Brashman 14y agoThe open data issue and the paywall issue are separate issues. Even if the publishers opened up the papers for public access, people would still not have had access to the R&R dataset.