4 ms·
> So you acknowledge that the government can not rule over non-consenting armed population Unarmed non-consenting populations can and have brought down governm
by SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago
> So you acknowledge that the government can not rule over non-consenting armed population
Unarmed non-consenting populations can and have brought down governments. e.g. in Egypt and in the Czech republic. But if the government is determined not to let go at any cost at all, side-arms won't help you against a decent army. Protesters with guns is nothing more than a good excuse to send in the tanks/drone strikes/etc.
So the presence or absence of civilian guns are not the issue that you make them out to be.
- smsm42 14y ago>>> Unarmed non-consenting populations can and have brought down governments. e.g. in Egypt In Egypt, the power was actually taken by the military after Mubarak has resigned. If the military had supported Mubarak, you can look in Libya and Syria how it would play out. >>> side-arms won't help you against a decent army Depends what you mean by "help". You can destroy a city with a bomber, but you can not actually govern the city with a bomber. >>>> So the presence or absence of civilian guns are not the issue that you make them out to be. It is. If the population is disarmed, the only force who decides if the government is to survive or not is the military. It's good if the military is on your side, if it's not you're in for a long and unpleasant ride.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> It is. If the population is disarmed, the only force who decides if the government is to survive or not is the military. What I and others are saying above is that with handguns in the population, the situation is much the same.
- smsm42 14y agoThe modern experience teaches us that it is very hard to subdue and keep under control a noncompliant and armed population, even if the army has vastly more powerful arms.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoWhich modern experience would that be? Citation needed.