7 ms·
Without any disrespect to the pilot, if they're close, why don't they get a slightly faster person to pilot it? Their elite racing cyclist (according to the bi
by davidw 14y ago
Without any disrespect to the pilot, if they're close, why don't they get a slightly faster person to pilot it?
Their elite racing cyclist (according to the bio page) is this guy: https://www.usacycling.org/results/?compid=286471 https://www.usacycling.org/results/?compid=286471
Not bad at all: it takes a lot of time and dedication to race at that level and also having a life outside racing. However, you could probably improve on his strength to weight ratio by getting a professional cyclist. For instance, in this hill climb time-trial, he came in over a half a minute down from the guy who won his category, in a race of under 5 minutes:
https://www.usacycling.org/results/?permit=2012-2687 https://www.usacycling.org/results/?permit=2012-2687
That kind of event is fairly similar to the kind of effort getting the helicopter off the ground entails: a short effort where, due to the climbing, weight is against you.
These guys, for instance, got a cyclist who had been in the olympics:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MIT_Daedalus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MIT_Daedalus
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- gilrain 14y agoThe team is likely made up of humans who may have formed emotional attachment to the project and wish to complete it alongside their long-time teammates.
- davidw 14y agoCould be. But it's primarily an engineering challenge: I'd see that as the big success, not whether they have one guy who's a bit faster than another, who happens to take it over the line.
- smackfu 14y agoNot to mention the assumption that this is not the best cyclist who: * will work for free * is local * is reliable and not an asshole * would rather do this than actually cycling This is a long-term challenge, where they have been getting progressively better for months and years. It's not like they just built the machine and then need a pilot for a day.
- davidw 14y agoMy guess is that the "limiting factor" is finding someone associated with the engineering program at that university. They could probably find a local racer that met the above qualifications without too much trouble.
- HyprMusic 14y agoThe helicopter requires pedalling with both hands and feet. Upper body strength is not something that goes hand-in-hand with cycling, due to the extra weight.
- davidw 14y agoWell, they do seem to have picked cyclists as test pilots. It may be, too, that the hand pedals are more of a distraction. It's something that has been tried with bicycles, and in general doesn't work out very well. Granted, in part this may be because you also have to steer a bike, whereas for a short effort like this, that's not so important. There's something to be said in any case for an otherwise rigid frame that you can hold onto with your hands, and really just sink all the leg power you can into it, kind of like standing up on a bicycle as you go uphill: you actually do pull on the bars.
- maxerickson 14y agoThey did a little bit of testing: http://www.agrc.umd.edu/gamera/gamera2/gamera2-human-power.html http://www.agrc.umd.edu/gamera/gamera2/gamera2-human-power.h... Page also mentions that their pilots weigh less than 145 pounds. I bet it matters a lot and wonder where the pros you are citing come in.
- davidw 14y agoGreat link; it's interesting to see that indeed, they do get a lot more out of the hand cranks. > I bet it matters a lot and wonder where the pros you are citing come in. Where they come in is that a small climber has an excellent power to weight ratio. This guy weighs 48 kg, for instance: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Rujano http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Rujano
- stouset 14y agoPower to weight ratio varies over time as well. Smaller guys are great at climbing long distances, because they can maintain a higher power-to-weight ratio for an hour or longer. Bigger guys tend to be sprinters (Chris Hoy is 205lbs) because their peak power can be much, much higher and compensate for the extra weight. For a one-minute effort, I'd suspect that a somewhat heavier sprinter profile would be an advantage over a lightweight climber profile. Even moreso because the weight of the craft will be a smaller percentage of their overall weight. A 150lb cyclist capable of outputting 10W/kg for a minute will have an effective 6.6W/kg on a 75lb craft. A 180lb cyclist capable of the same 10W/kg would have an effective 7.0W/kg on the same craft. And a 180lb cyclist capable of 11W/kg would manage an effective 7.7W/kg.
- smackfu 14y agoEngineers would rather improve their tech than improve the human.
- solistice 14y agoWrong. I'd love to improve the human, but the tech will have to be improved.
- curveship 14y agoFrom the link maxericson provided[1], we can get numbers for their pilot with and without hand cranks, and from Andy Coggan's power profiling spreadsheet[2], we can compare those to documented numbers for competitive cyclists: UMD pilot, no hand cranks: ~6.5 w/kg for 60 seconds UMD pilot, with hand cranks: ~8 w/kg "Untrained" cyclist: ~6 w/kg "Good" cyclist (average amateur racer): ~8.2 w/kg "Exceptional" cyclist (domestic pro): ~10.35 w/kg "World class" cyclist: 11.5 w/kg Of course, this isn't quite apples-to-apples, given the different seating posture. I would suspect that the prone position loses them some power (from experience, there's a lot of body emglish that goes on in an all out 1' effort on a bicycle), some of which (and maybe more, hard to say) may be brought back by the hand cranks. I suspect that their reason for not hiring the cycling talent is that, for UMD, this is ultimately an educational endevour. The point isn't just to claim the prize, but to have students do it. 1 - http://www.agrc.umd.edu/gamera/gamera2/gamera2-human-power.html http://www.agrc.umd.edu/gamera/gamera2/gamera2-human-power.h... 2 - http://home.trainingpeaks.com/media/69406/powerprofiling_v4.xls http://home.trainingpeaks.com/media/69406/powerprofiling_v4.... . This is the standard reference for bike racers, and comes from Coggan's records of hundreds of cyclists. edit: formatting