3 ms·
I love mathematicians. They give a complicated function, explaining how they derived each term, and then consider the problem solved, without bothering to give
by StavrosK 14y ago
I love mathematicians. They give a complicated function, explaining how they derived each term, and then consider the problem solved, without bothering to give a number.
It's correct, of course, as the problem is solved, but most people would attempt a ballpark approximation in the end!
- cschmidt 14y agoThat is kind of like how you can take a class in number theory, and not actually use any concrete numbers (like 7, say).
- crntaylor 14y agoThere's an excellent quotation attributed to Alexandre Grothendieck, one of the greatest mathematicians alive. At a seminar he was giving on analytic number theory, someone suggested that they should consider a particular prime number. "You mean an actual number?" Grothendieck asked. The other person replied, yes, an actual prime number. Grothendieck replied "All right, take 57."
- JonnieCache 14y agoIs there a significance to 57 there?
- thecoffman 14y ago57 isn't a prime number. 3 * 19 = 57
- lkozma 14y agoYes, it isn't prime, that's the joke (I guess).
- Someone 14y agoYes, but not in the sense that Grothendieck made a joke by saying '57', but in the sense that Grothendieck, who knows quite a bit about prime numbers, said '57' without realizing that it is composite.
- lkozma 14y agoYes, I understood it in this sense too :) Quite a character, Grothendieck.
- darkhorn 14y agoYes but I'm sure you can get better answers from statisticians. (from people who know better about probabilities)
- crntaylor 14y agoHah. It's a common trait among mathematicians. I had a stab at an answer myself[0], and gave a ballpark answer (once every 1.62 years). [0] http://math.stackexchange.com/a/387581/4873 http://math.stackexchange.com/a/387581/4873
- mturmon 14y agoFrom Davis and Hersh's excellent book "The Mathematical Experience": Professor John Wermer tells the story of how, when he was an undergraduate, he took a course in projective geometry from Oscar Zariski, one of the foremost figures in the field of algebraic geometry. Zariski's course was exceedingly general and Wermer, as a young student, was occasionally in need of clarification. "What would you get," he asked his teacher, "if you specialized the field F to the complex numbers?" Zariski answered, "Yes, just take F as the complex numbers."
- StavrosK 14y agoCan I get a joke explanation at aisle 2? :p
- mturmon 14y agoThe student doesn't understand the general result, so asks for an explanation in a simple special case. The teacher fully understands the general result, and sees through to the special case like light goes through glass. So he just says yes, that's the special case, and sees no need to elaborate, because establishing the correspondence of the general to the specific is too obvious to bother putting in to words.
- StavrosK 14y agoAh, I see, thank you for the explanation.