4 ms·
(ok, rant ahead) I think mathematicians have a weird way of thinking about problems. First-order logic for example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-order_l
by raverbashing 14y ago
(ok, rant ahead)
I think mathematicians have a weird way of thinking about problems.
First-order logic for example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-order_logic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-order_logic
It's quirky to think, for example, on the natural numbers that 'exists an operation + and a null element under that operation 0'
This is "very understandable" by humans, but very difficult to compute.
As such as this conjecture is stated in a way that looks qualitative (but has a good definition), still, usually it seems that proofs are even harder for theorems defined like that
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abc_conjecture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abc_conjecture
- claudius 14y agoIf you want general results, you need to abstract away from standard preschool algebra and build up models that then let you get said general results. That might appear ‘weird’, but I don’t see how else you could get even to calculus, not to mention, for example, the algebra driving a sensible description of quantum mechanics or differential geometry. You called it a rant, but could you maybe still make a suggestion on how to better think about problems?
- raverbashing 14y ago" you need to abstract away from standard preschool algebra and build up models that then let you get said general results" Yes, of course. " but could you maybe still make a suggestion on how to better think about problems?" And that's what I meant. Thinking about problems in a different way (but still provable, and still working in a similar way) For example, for Peano arithmetic you have that equality is symmetric (and transitive) Now, there are several ways to explain that, and it's usually explained more or less by "for all X and all Y, if X = Y then Y = X" Now, it would maybe be interesting to have a 'different explanation' that is as powerful as first order logic but works differently (and maybe easier to compute) For example, it may be possible to write Peano arithmetic as a grammar (so zero would be ' ', one would be I, two would be II, etc)
- claudius 14y agoAnd after you spent ten years reformulating basic maths in your fancy new logic, people will look at your papers and won’t understand a word, which appears to be more or less what happened to our poor protagonist in the OP. Furthermore, I have to admit I don’t see the immediate advantage such a reconstruction would bring with it.
- raverbashing 14y agoWell, the OPs reinvention looks like something more high level Well, there may not be immediate advantages, but in math you never know. There are several hard problems in one domain that are trivial in another domain, for example. An example from physics: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamiltonian_mechanics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamiltonian_mechanics
- claudius 14y ago> There are several hard problems in one domain that are trivial in another domain, for example. Certainly, and this is pretty much what OP did, invent a new domain to solve a problem – Hamilton aka Lord Kelvin merely reformulated the problem slightly, and while I personally love Hamiltonian mechanics, I don’t think it is comparable to ‘inter-universal geometry’ or replacing first order logic with something else. So, yes, a different field may provide a different perspective and hence easier solution, but if you want to replace first order logic, you’re not looking at a different/new field in maths, you’re looking at rebuilding maths.
- andreasvc 14y agoYour suggestion reminds me of typographical number theory (TNT), in Hofstadter's Goedel Escher Bach. TNT is introduced for didactic purposes, I don't see the point of using it for actual mathematics.
- rickhanlonii 14y agoThat's what I thought when I read his comment. Hofstadter emphasizes how unmanageable such a system becomes quite quickly. For example, here's what a proof that addition is commutative looks like in TNT: http://imgur.com/a/O63Ij http://imgur.com/a/O63Ij
- shocks 14y agoFirst-order Logic is a fascinatingly deep and interesting topic. The level of abstraction is a requirement - it makes it far easier to work with, prove, and understand. Source: 4th year mathematics student.