3 ms·
How many complaints should it take? What number represents a quorum on HN? If a complaint is sufficiently strong, reasoned, and evidenced, then just one is enou
by onion2k 14y ago
How many complaints should it take? What number represents a quorum on HN? If a complaint is sufficiently strong, reasoned, and evidenced, then just one is enough. One person with an exceptional reason for a story to be removed should be enough to remove it.
Your point should really that the complaints aren't justified properly rather than there aren't a sufficient number of them.
- mike_tan 14y agoThe point is, it seems to only take one person to vehemently object. > complaints aren't justified properly rather than there aren't a sufficient number of them it's not that they aren't "justified properly", it's that they aren't justified at all. From my submission: "I hate to be that guy who posts this sort of comment. Especially on HN. But still: Someone has to say it. Pointless hipster-TLD is pointless. Utterly pointless." Is it pointless? Tell that to codepen.io, or card.io (who got acquired by Paypal). "But still: Someone has to say it." Did someone have to say it? Saying something is pointless over and over doesn't make it pointless. That seems to be the basis of the argument.
- ColinWright 14y agoIf no one agreed with them then theirs would be the only flag and there would be no effect. If several people agreed then there would be several flags, and that's what appears to happen. Largely speaking, and with few exceptions, this is a community moderated forum. Enough of the community decided that the submission wasn't sufficiently on-topic. If you feel strongly that the data you presented is on topic then perhaps you would fare better not simply to post a bare list, but write a blog post about why short names like this are of value to startups, and how having a short domain name can radically improve your chances, and how you wrote a script to create the list, and now you're sharing it because you believe it to be of value. You claim the protester gave no reasons for claiming it's pointless, but equally, you gave no reasons for why it is of value. And just in case I need to say it again, I'm merely providing my analysis of this situation through my model of how the community works. I personally am passing no judgment on how HN works, nor on the community's interests and/or actions.
- mike_tan 14y ago>If no one agreed with them then theirs would be the only flag and there would be no effect. If several people agreed then there would be several flags, and that's what appears to happen. Or a moderator. Or something else that's nixing submissions. >If you feel strongly that the data you presented is on topic then perhaps you would fare better not simply to post a bare list, but write a blog post about why short names like this are of value to startups, and how having a short domain name can radically improve your chances, and how you wrote a script to create the list, and now you're sharing it because you believe it to be of value. Actionable data isn't useful? From the comments: "Amazed how many good names are still available. Looking to do a real-estate startup? How about: crib.io (available)" "I was amazed that nag.io was still available. I snatched it!"
- ColinWright 14y agoLet me ask you this: What good is it doing you to argue with me that this submission was of value, and shouldn't've been flagged?
- mike_tan 14y agoI would hope -- but this isn't going to happen, by the looks of it -- that people would see the discussion and then not call out posts as being "pointless" or hype, or like Reddit, or link-bait, just because it's not to their particular liking. There shouldn't be a lexical kill switch for submissions. Or if it's moderators, they should re-think censorship as a reasonable action for posts that may not be to their taste.
- ColinWright 14y agoLet me summarise what I think you're saying: * You saw value in it. * A few others clearly saw value in it. * Still others saw it as having negative value. * The ones who thought it had negative value flagged it. * They should not have done so. * Something should be done. Are you going to suggest what should be done?