3 ms·
A bunch of people here seem to misunderstand this as less powerful than being able to just modify the software (largely trivial on both iOS and Android) to not
by saurik 14y ago
A bunch of people here seem to misunderstand this as less powerful than being able to just modify the software (largely trivial on both iOS and Android) to not delete the images in the first place, or to save them while viewing them: that requires forethought to have made that modification ahead of time. The people who talk about "forensics" are interested in situations like "cell phone belonging to victim found at the murder scene: checking the system logs, the most recent application to have been used was SnapChat; if we knew what they had just received, we might have a clue (or just a naked picture of someone close to the victim)".
Honestly, what they are doing is probably about as "lame" as "undelete a file", possibly with the at-most complexity of "undo some simple encoding" or "undelete a file that was stored as a row in an SQLite database that has yet to be vacuumed". So, this isn't technologically "wow" (one of the threads here is "how is this 'special'?"), but this also really isn't "engh, I can root it and scrape the framebuffer". It isn't even a company bragging that they beat SnapChat, so the "it's lame tech" part doesn't even matter: it is a company advertising a product/service for police departments to undelete self-destructing messages from a program that is very very popular.
I thereby feel a more interesting conversation to be having on HN about this article isn't "lame, we knew SnapChat was insecure" or "lame, I could have done that" or "lame, there are easier ways to do that": it would be something closer to "damn, that was easy, we all knew it could be done, I could have even done it, and apparently it is worth $300 a pop to do this for forensics purposes? what other business opportunities are low-hanging fruit I'm missing out on by dismissing them as 'lame'?". (Yes: I know that "lame" wasn't a quote from any of the responses; I am summing up the sentiment. It isn't just HN either, but the other places I've seen this discussed don't have the business focus.)
- A1kmm 14y agoI think that given Snapchat's advertising ('the snap disappears') they should really be doing more on the client to make sure third parties don't get access to the picture, for example, by not storing it on the device at all.