4 ms·
> This thing is un-concealable and unusable as a real-life weapon in any public safety scenario True. My worry is that this is just the v0.1 and it is the sha
by SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago
> This thing is un-concealable and unusable as a real-life weapon in any public safety scenario
True. My worry is that this is just the v0.1 and it is the shape of things to come. Desktop CNC milling machines are also getting better rapidly and can make metal parts. ( http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/otherfab/the-othermill-custom-circuits-at-your-fingertips http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/otherfab/the-othermill-c... ).
Designing this gun was clearly an asshole move, but how do you prohibit it now? Cory Doctrow said something along the lines of DRM is "allowing a general-purpose computer to run any program except for the ones that I don't like". (http://boingboing.net/2012/08/23/civilwar.html http://boingboing.net/2012/08/23/civilwar.html )
A 3d printer or cnc mill that can make anything "except for the shapes that I don't like" is equally laughable.
- stfu 14y agoDesigning this gun was clearly an asshole move I, for one, welcome any asshole moves that make governments afraid of their citizens. DefDist's Bitcoin: 1Gb5GNxrVGMT8e9uoJ8CmamrdVz9o8fAEa ( http://defdist.org/bitcoin/ http://defdist.org/bitcoin/ )
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoA typically and uniquely American response. The main problem that you have now is that your citizens are afraid of each other's sidearms. The government, not so much.
- rollo_tommasi 14y agoThis is so silly. If the country ever comes to the point where only you and your 3D printed gun stand between freedom and the government's tyranny, you'll just be obliterated by a Predator drone. Advances in and proliferation of 3D guns will only endanger innocent citizens. Thinking that it's any kind of check on government power is a childish fantasy.
- hga 14y agoYou really ought to read about the namesake of this gun: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FP-45_Liberator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FP-45_Liberator If it comes to that, it's merely a tool to get better guns.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoInteresting link, thanks. "General Eisenhower's staff never saw the practicality". And I don't either.
- hga 14y agoPerhaps all of the above are lacking in imagination---and/or the staffs didn't want masses of soon to be liberated people to be armed. Since mass distribution would have consumed precious air transport/bomber resources, we don't know if their tradeoff was correct. The one thing we can say is that the proposition was not put to the test.
- smsm42 14y agoThis stupid argument is reiterated again and again and doesn't become less stupid. There are about 100 millions of gun owners in the country. Do you think any government can wage war with 100 million armed citizens, drones or not? Do you read newspapers, do you know how successful the war in any territory where the population is hostile, noncooperative and armed? Do you think US tried to find local allies in Afganistan and Iraq because they didn't think of using drones? Drones aren't some magic wand that makes you invincible, and no government can remain in place if 100 million armed people want it out, drones or not.
- rollo_tommasi 14y agoBuddy, if it ever comes to pass that fully 1/3 of the population rises up in armed rebellion against the government, equipped with the kind of military-grade weaponry and foreign backing that sustained the Afghan/Iraqi insurgencies, then the USA has become a dystopian warlord state and freedom and democracy are dead letters for the next dozen generations. Get real. These kinds of justifications are just completely absurd fantasies, for people who want to picture themselves as the heroes of another "Red Dawn" remake.
- rbanffy 14y ago> My worry is that this is just the v0.1 and it is the shape of things to come I don't see how 3D printers will be able to make undetectable bullets. There are not many ways to do a bullet that doesn't involve metals. Maybe a two-stage self-propelled plastic bullet could do the trick.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> I don't see how 3D printers will be able to make undetectable bullets They can't, and I didn't think that was implied. I think it was assumed that bullets would come from the usual sources. Still, a CNC mill could probably fashion bullets (not undetectable ones) and their casings from metal. Explosives required are still a problem, so you'd probably be better off not doing this.