3 ms·
I hate to be that guy who posts this sort of comment. Especially on HN. But still: Someone has to say it. Pointless hipster-TLD is pointless. Utterly pointless
by josteink 14y ago
I hate to be that guy who posts this sort of comment. Especially on HN. But still: Someone has to say it.
Pointless hipster-TLD is pointless. Utterly pointless.
- rdl 14y agoVery short names are useful for link shortening. There are good reasons to pick names out of the "gTLDified" ccTLDs for that. IO isn't even a real country, so it's a better choice for ccTLD abuse than something totally stupid like LY.
- josteink 14y agoSo it's less stupid than something utterly stupid. Great. And then people choose to base the core identity of their company/service on that. Needless to say, I wish them greatness.
- rdl 14y agoI think it's totally responsible to have a shortener in a gccTLD as an adjunct to your main brand. e.g. quora.com has qr.ae as a link shortener. I'm sort of against the whole concept of link shorteners, too, but if they're run by the site themselves, long-lived, and otherwise don't break the expectations of URLs/URIs, then they might make sense for mobile and type-in use.
- shadowfiend 14y agoBecause you don't like it or…? What decides the “pointfulness” of a name? Is a name better or worse because of the TLD someone chooses to put it on? Is booking.com better than booking.io for a reason other than you've decided you don't like .io? Let me rephrase: do you have any reasoned argument anywhere for why the .io TLD is in any way bad or pointless? Because it certainly hasn't manifested itself in the comments to this post. Vitriol seems to be the only thing that's been presented so far.
- naich 14y agoI bet you wouldn't say no to eie.io