3 ms·
>Go read the actual study then rather than the article, and find out how she justified her decisions. If you've got $11.95 to spare, I'll take you up on that.
by mtowle 13y ago
>Go read the actual study then rather than the article, and find out how she justified her decisions.
If you've got $11.95 to spare, I'll take you up on that. Unfortunately all that's available is the abstract. But if you want me to analyze that, I will. 232 words, not counting the copyright. 122 unique. 'Tiger' occurs 7 times -- 4th behind 'parenting' (15), 'the' (12), and 'and' (9). My analysis concludes that Kim doesn't just have something she wants to say, she has something she wants the public to hear. I.e., right or wrong, Kim has an agenda.
>Most likely, she based them on definitions that were defined and validated by multiple previous studies before her
I don't see how; she openly states in the quoted section of the parent comment that her delineation of categories was aimed at challenging the standard in the field.
>a whole load of very critical people have to agree with your judgement before something gets published.
In this case, it was the fine people over at the AAJP. The Asian American Journal of Psychology. Most def not a journal oriented toward "their version" of the truth, I'm sure.
- gertef 13y agoWhat is "their" version?
- mtowle 13y agoI don't know, what's "Asian American Psychology"? Must be new. They didn't have it when I was in school.
- WalterSear 13y agoFind out here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5684360 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5684360
- gwern 13y ago> If you've got $11.95 to spare, I'll take you up on that. Unfortunately all that's available is the abstract. Here you go! http://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/85192141/2013-kim.pdf http://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/85192141/2013-kim.pdf By the way, there are many resources available for getting academic papers; you didn't mention Google Scholar, which is a great resource, but that wouldn't have helped here, but fortunately there are Russian sites and there are a number of groups dedicated to jailbreaking papers on request such as Reddit's /r/scholar or Wikipedia's Resource Request.