3 ms·
If you just want to start a company, take a Thiel fellowship. If you want to be Peter Thiel, take that Stanford acceptance and go work on Wall Street. To be fa
by mindcrime 14y ago
If you just want to start a company, take a Thiel fellowship. If you want to be Peter Thiel, take that Stanford acceptance and go work on Wall Street.
To be fair, one has to ask "Was there a Peter Thiel-like character offering anything like a Thiel Fellowship when Peter Thiel was starting out?"
Accusing him of hypocrisy seems wrong to me. For starters, because people should be allowed to learn, grow, and change their opinions over time. And also because we have, to the best of my knowledge, no particular reason to think that Thiel had the opportunity to those this (Thiel Fellowship) type of path as a youngster.
Anyway, it's a bit early, isn't it, to pre-suppose that some Thiel Fellowship recipients won't turn out just as well as Peter Thiel himself?
- rayiner 14y agoHow would someone who achieved success by leveraging capital and connections he got on Wall Street have been equally successful pursuing a path that would have barred him admission to that particular club? There is no other industry more steeped in credentialing than his own. My point isn't that what Thiel did is the only way to success, or even really that Thiel is being a hypocrite (to be fair, I find nothing wrong with hypocrisy). What rubs me the wrong way is how his message relates to the power dynamic in Silicon Valley. If you've got Thiel fellow credentials, statistically your winning bet in Silicon Valley is not starting a company, but going to work at a venture capital firm, which is usually the result of careful path-following.
- mindcrime 14y agoHow would someone who achieved success by leveraging capital and connections he got on Wall Street have been equally successful pursuing a path that would have barred him admission to that particular club? Who knows? The only possible answer to that would be utter and sheer speculation, and fairly pointless as far as I can see. But I don't see any particular reason to assume that he couldn't have been equally successful had he chosen a different route. My point isn't that what Thiel did is the only way to success, or even really that Thiel is being a hypocrite (to be fair, I find nothing wrong with hypocrisy). My point is that Thiel is a bad messenger for the message he's conveying. A guy whose success is the product of careful path-following, and a guy who works in an industry that still clings rigidly to its credentialing tradition. Ok, fair enough. Not sure I agree that he's a bad messenger, but I get what you're saying. Let me ask you this though: What - if anything - could Thiel do now (or around the time he launched the Thiel Fellowship initiative) that would make him a good messenger in your view?
- rayiner 14y ago> But I don't see any particular reason to assume that he couldn't have been equally successful had he chosen a different route. It's sheer speculation to wonder what different thing Thiel could have done to become successful. And that gets into the "would Jobs have been as successful if he had never founded Apple?" thing, which is naval gazing. But it's less of a shot in the dark to speculate that Thiel probably couldn't have successfully co-founded PayPal (a financial services company), without a college degree and Wall Street background. You can look at many entrepreneurs and say that they could've still founded their company if someone had given them $100k cash at age 18. I don't think Thiel is one of those people. > What - if anything - could Thiel do now (or around the time he launched the Thiel Fellowship initiative) that would make him a good messenger in your view? Hire people without college degrees to work at Clarium Capital.
- mindcrime 14y agoHire people without college degrees to work at Clarium Capital. Now that I can agree with you on. That would be a good message for him to send, given his current status.
- aswanson 14y agoNah, too risky at this point. If Clarium was still putting up numbers, maybe. But I doubt Calpers or any big institution is going to throw more money at a struggling outfit hiring high school kids to head the fund.
- foobarqux 14y agoDo you have any info about recent rates of return or AUM?
- aswanson 14y agoThe last public data I have on the fund was a 23 percent loss in 2010 with AUM dropping under 1 billion. My comment wasn't intended as a knock on Clarium or Thiel; I admire a lot of the man's thought process. It's just that institutional investors are extremely conservative and Ivy League/credential biased. So even highly successful funds would have a PR problem with actively seeking non-credentialed youth.