5 ms·
The DMCA takedown procedure still gives too much power to the accuser, without sufficient penalties for improper notices. Since it implements a "guilty until pr
by wtallis 14y ago
The DMCA takedown procedure still gives too much power to the accuser, without sufficient penalties for improper notices. Since it implements a "guilty until proven innocent" system, there needs to be strong deterrent for false notices. Things especially need to be clarified for the case of computer-generated takedown notices - there needs to be a real person who is at real risk of disbarment or perjury charges when those notices are false positives, especially since the penalties for a false counter-notice are that harsh.
- dragonwriter 14y ago> The DMCA takedown procedure still gives too much power to the accuser, without sufficient penalties for improper notices. Since it implements a "guilty until proven innocent" system The takedown procedure is not, stricly speaking, "a guilty until proven innocent" system. Its a system that provides immunity from liability for illegally distributing copyright protected content provided that it was originally submitted by someone other than the distributor, and the distributor stopped when notified by the owner of the copyright. (It, likewise, provides immunity to the distributor for claims by the submitter for stopping distribution provided that the distributor restores the distribution once the submitter provides a counternotice.) But the takedown procedure itself doesn't create new penalties or presumptions of guilt, it just provides conditional protections from any existing penalties for certain acts provided that those acts are discontinued on specified forms of notice.
- yew 14y agoThe issue is that liability is in practice equivalent to a large monetary penalty because of the ease of rapid and continuous litigation. So in practice the DMCA takedown procedure provides a method of immediately (and sometimes permanently) removing content (not necessarily infringing) from any major provider. As an example, the method of removing allegedly infringing content from YouTube is not a DMCA takedown but it is a result of that mechanism.
- dragonwriter 14y ago> So in practice the DMCA takedown procedure provides a method of immediately (and often permanently) removing content (not necessarily infringing) from any major provider. I don't think the DMCA takedown procedure is much involved. The actual problem that causes that is the resource imbalance between content owners and individual users. Without the DMCA takedown procedure and its associated liability shields, instead you'd have content owners sending threats to sue to the content hosts, who would have to choose whether they'd like to fight the content owner or keep the affected client. With the DMCA takedown procedure, really, its exactly the same thing, except that the host has more security that they will have no liability to the purported content owner for any past distribution if they comply with the request. We know this to be true, becuase this was the situation that was occurring before the DMCA which led to the pressure from content hosts that resulted in the inclusion of the safe harbor provisions that include the "takedown procedure" and the related counter-notice restoration procedure.
- yew 14y agoThe DMCA takedown procedure (including that safe-harbor provision) provides a special incentive towards compliance with 'content owners' (who may or may not actually own the content in question), apart from but dependent on litigation. The situation before the DMCA was preferable because it involved only the general legal system rather than a badly-designed special case. It's not merely the result of a resource imbalance but of a fundamental misapprehension of the nature of content ownership - the set of 'content owners' recognized in practice by the DMCA is not the entire set of owners of content.
- dragonwriter 14y ago> The DMCA takedown procedure (including that safe-harbor provision) provides a special incentive towards compliance with 'content owners' (who may or may not actually own the content in question), apart from but dependent on litigation. It provides an equally special incentive to comply with users; the safe harbor has two sides. The difference in effect is the same as the difference in effect in threat of litigation absent the safe-harbor: the difference in resources on the two sides and the significance of the liability the host might face from either side. > The situation before the DMCA was preferable If you didn't want to have big businesses freely hosting user-submitted content, maybe. Content owners weren't the backers for the safe harbor (they wanted the freedom to sue first and get money), content hosts were. It doesn't create additional incentives for content hosts to comply with content owners (real or purported), it removes pre-existing opportunities for content owners (again, real or purported) to extort content hosts.
- wtallis 14y agoThe takedown procedure as it currently exists enables a third party to exercise power just shy of an injunction to take your website offline, without having to present any evidence or appear in court. Yes, your hosting provider has the theoretical option of assuming a ton of risk by not taking down the content, but they're basically being blackmailed by your accuser. And all this applies even if your website is completely innocent except for having some similar keywords to an infringement. And if you fight back by issuing a counter-notice, you're held to a higher standard than your accuser. It's absolutely a "shoot-first, ask questions later" system that is strongly biased in favor of the accuser. It's okay to provide a quick way to take down infringing content, but it has to come with strong penalties and reparations for cases where the accuser abuses the power. I'm not at all arguing in favor of eliminating the safe-harbor provisions - I just want the penalties for a false notice to be at least as harsh as the penalties for a false counter-notice.
- dragonwriter 14y ago> The takedown procedure as it currently exists enables a third party to exercise power just shy of an injunction to take your website offline, without having to present any evidence or appear in court. Yes, your hosting provider has the theoretical option of assuming a ton of risk by not taking down the content Without the DMCA safe harbor, the content host would be in a very similar position when presented with a demand to remove the content from a content holder. The only difference the safe harbor provides is that the content holder can't be sued for content they accept and distribute but don't exercise editorial control over unless the content owner gives a takedown notice and the content host ignores it, so that, as a consequence, content owners can't skip the whole demand step and just start filing low-chance-of-success, high-reward lawsuits against deep-pocket defendants. > I'm not at all arguing in favor of eliminating the safe-harbor provisions - I just want the penalties for a false notice to be at least as harsh as the penalties for a false counter-notice. > I just want the penalties for a false notice to be at least as harsh as the penalties for a false counter-notice. The penalties for both are the same, and are specified in the same paragraph without distinction, at 17 USC 512(f): Any person who knowingly materially misrepresents under this section- (1) that material or activity is infringing, or (2) that material or activity was removed or disabled by mistake or misidentification, shall be liable for any damages, including costs and attorneys’ fees, incurred by the alleged infringer, by any copyright owner or copyright owner’s authorized licensee, or by a service provider, who is injured by such misrepresentation, as the result of the service provider relying upon such misrepresentation in removing or disabling access to the material or activity claimed to be infringing, or in replacing the removed material or ceasing to disable access to it.
- knome 14y agoCan a legitimate copyright holder file a preemptive counter-claim, such that any attempt to remove their work _must_ be forced through a court order to restrain infringement? It would seem that such a tactic would be less than tenable for illegitimate uploaders, while allowing legitimate holders to avoid the onerous downtimes that can be brought on by a false claim.
- wtallis 14y agoThe DMCA Safe Harbor provision only protects a hosting provider who "responds expeditiously to remove, or disable access to, the material that is claimed to be infringing". I don't think there's much leeway for the hosting provider to give you a chance to file counter-notice before they take it down. So you're left with trying to convince the hosting provider to forgo Safe Harbor protections, which means they would have to be really confident that you could win easily, quickly, and cheaply. You can try to preempt things by hosting everything yourself, but they can always go after your ISP. Unless you own the whole internet[1], there's somebody who's not you who can be blackmailed into disabling access to your content. ([1] or otherwise render the rest of the internet ineligible for safe harbor, such as by making them financially benefit in a way directly attributable to whatever activity may be alleged to be infringing.)
- rhizome 14y agoYes, if that copyright holder hosts their own material themselves, making them uploader, content provider and hosting provider all.