6 ms·
It's almost like kids benefit from running around outside with other kids, rather than being forced to be mini adults. Or something.
by jjtheblunt 14y ago
It's almost like kids benefit from running around outside with other kids, rather than being forced to be mini adults. Or something.
- rayiner 14y agoOn the contrary, the chart in the article shows that "permissive" parenting produced lower achievement than "authoritative" parenting. The distinction in the article isn't about letting kids "be kids" but whether parents are responsive/warm versus cold.
- sebcat 14y agoNo, it showed higher achievement and lower rate of depression among the "permissive" group.
- nostrademons 14y agoYou're confusing "authoritative" and "authoritarian". Authoritative > permissive > authoritarian.
- jlgreco 14y agoThen so is rayiner, as far as I can tell. Not allowing your children to run around with other children outside is authoritarian, not authoritative.
- rayiner 14y agoI wasn't talking about the "running around" I was talking about the "being kids" rather than "mini adults." As used in the article, the distinction between "authoritarian" and "authoritative" is a cold versus warm distinction, not a "directed" versus "undirected" distinction.
- jlgreco 14y agoIsn't not allowing your children to run around with other kids a specific case of not allowing your children to "be kids" but rather requiring them to be "mini adults"?
- rayiner 14y agoSo what you said is that if you don't let your kids run around, that's authoritarian parenting, not authoritative parenting. Which I'll concede is true. I will also concede as true that not letting your kids run around is a specific case of not letting them "be kids" but requiring them to be "mini adults." However, that does not mean that requiring your kids to be "mini adults" is a sign of authoritarian parenting rather than authoritative parenting, for the obvious reason that you can require your children to generally act like "mini adults" while also letting them play once in awhile.
- taeric 14y agoI think the point was that that was still below the middle line.
- nostrademons 14y ago"Authoritative" parenting means letting kids explore the world and their own interests while still setting strict limits that are necessary for the health & well-being of the kid. An authoritative parent wouldn't prevent their kid from running around outside with other kids, they'd let the kid run around outside "but stay away from the railroad tracks, and don't get drunk or do drugs, and be home by 11".
- rayiner 14y agoThat's not really how it's defined in the article. It's more "this is what you're going to do, but I'm willing to negotiate the details."
- nostrademons 14y agoThere's a bunch of background in the psych literature beyond just this article. Here's one summary of authoritative parenting: http://psychology.about.com/od/childcare/f/authoritative-parenting.htm http://psychology.about.com/od/childcare/f/authoritative-par... If you've ever had a good boss, there's a good analogy there. A good boss doesn't micro-manage or tell you what to do: she lets you arrange your time as necessary to accomplish your objectives and exercise a lot of discretion about your day-to-day work. However, she doesn't let you just spin your wheels and not accomplish anything either. She provides just enough guidance to ensure that you're still moving forwards without dictating how you move forwards. A good parent is very similar. He provides structure and direction, but lets the child discover his/her own interests and pursue them. It's only when the kid is at risk of stepping seriously off the rails that the parent steps in.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- TheLegace 14y agoDefinitely agree. But I wonder what happens when your parent(s) do both those things but in different ways for different things? Kinda what I could say happened to me, my father being extremely authoritative(making me work at very young age for his business), but at the same time not being around to not set very much boundaries.
- rdtsc 14y agoYes. And I think those are rather orthogonal concepts. One can be permissive and cold. Permissive and warm. Authoritative and cold and authoritative and warm. Authoritative and warm sounds odd, but it think I kind of describes my parents. Some issues like respecting elders, saying thank you, making sure to help friends in needs, sharing were non-negotiable, others like what major to choose, or how late early and when to do homework or what extra curricular activities to take or not take was up to me. Otherwise I never lacked loved, attention or time spent with any of my parents. One of them even quit a much better paying job just to make spend more time with me after school and in the evening.
- wvenable 14y agoNobody treats adults that way. I think kids benefit from really being treated like adults.
- hackinthebochs 14y agoThis only works if kids are also given adult responsibilities along with their consequences. Giving kids the choice to choose their own path doesn't work when they know that they are not truly responsible for their actions. Contrast kids today with kids decades ago when it was typical for a kid of 13 to get a job to support the family. If you want to treat kids like adults you can't half-ass it.
- cafard 14y agoWithin the last half century in the US, kids were not contributing to the household support with whatever jobs they had, unless their families were squarely at the bottom of the economy, migrant farm workers for example. Minimum wage x 40 hours x 10 weeks went surprisingly far toward state college tuition, but not toward the expenses of a middle class household. Forty plus years ago, high school friends of mine were busing tables before 16, and we mostly held down summer jobs once 16. I don't know that we were that much different from kids today.