3 ms·
This is an unsexy directive that could be a profound game-changer for civic society. If you've ever tried to get data from a public entity and had to argue abou
by danso 14y ago
This is an unsexy directive that could be a profound game-changer for civic society. If you've ever tried to get data from a public entity and had to argue about the particulars of PDF over Excel, this kind of statement is at least a good precedent to work from...some information will still be unparsable, just as much information, period, is still withheld despite transparency laws...but this is a pretty strong statement nonetheless.
Edit: I do think there's a large risk of an unintended chilling effect, as well-intentioned as this initiative. The blog post that was linked to later in this discussion talks about how defaulting to machine data will "ensure privacy"...which can only mean that there will be some process to decide which data should be machine data and which shouldn't...and, I think this will inevitably cause some datasets to just not be released at all, if there are large technical concerns in making sure the data doesn't "violate privacy"
As an example, a couple years ago the Obama administration took down a public database after a doctor complained that a newspaper was able to use it to track evidence against him in a story:
http://www.propublica.org/article/how-complaints-from-a-doctor-caused-the-govt-to-take-down-a-public-database http://www.propublica.org/article/how-complaints-from-a-doct...
The database contained anonymized data about doctor malpractice records...but of course, if you have a doctor with a particularly long history of malpractice in a s single zip code, it's not hard to connect those anonymous records to an identity. So I think there will be some cases where an agency will decide not to put up data because of the fear that computerized analysis of it will reveal things that they don't want revealed.
- edavis 14y ago> If you've ever tried to get data from a public entity and had to argue about the particulars of PDF over Excel ... Or my favorite, the entities that send a PDF export of an Excel spreadsheet.
- dmd 14y agoLucky. PennDOT sent me screenshots of a spreadsheet, pasted into a doc.
- ErikAugust 14y agoOh man. That is a winner.
- tlrobinson 14y agohttp://thedailywtf.com/Articles/Web_0_0x2e_1.aspx http://thedailywtf.com/Articles/Web_0_0x2e_1.aspx
- rayiner 14y agoThey probably have a standing rule that documents go out in PDF, for the simple reason that more people can view PDF files than can view Excel files.
- ErikAugust 14y agoHow about a Flash site that exports CSV. That's my favorite.
- aptwebapps 14y agoIsn't that sort of the opposite as the parent, in terms of machine readability?