3 ms·
The effect sizes that you're talking about are the result of hidden correlations causing the random variation to be larger than the statistical model thought po
by btilly 14y ago
The effect sizes that you're talking about are the result of hidden correlations causing the random variation to be larger than the statistical model thought possible. On the one hand you can always argue that this is a sign you did statistics wrong. On the other hand the internal correlations caused by ethnicity, diet, environmental pollution, etc truly are hard to estimate.
Another common cause of finding significant p-values when you shouldn't is looking at many metrics (or the same metric at many points of time). Eventually you get (un)lucky.
However if you do the stats correctly, and the statistical model (which usually assumes independence) is accurate, then a p-value of under 5% will only happen 5% of the time. No matter how big the sample size is.
- glaugh 14y agoYeah, my point isn't that the statistical significance is erroneous or that the difference shouldn't have been significant. In my totally made up example, there's really a .1mm difference. And maybe to someone that's meaningful, so it's worth reporting. But it's not a big enough effect to say "When I see someone on the street I can look at their height and know which of these two cities they're from." And my peeve is that people will see a statistically significant difference and think that that alone makes it an important finding, versus a very real finding that might not actually matter that much. Or, related, it's bad to see something with a p-value of .15 and a large effect size and decide that since it's not significant at .05 it's not interesting. Since that combination typically means that you have a too-small sample size, the best interpretation is probably more like "This might be interesting. Looks like we don't have enough data to tell if there's a relationship here, but it probably deserves another look." (Edited to add that last thought, and clarify the previous one)