3 ms·
> It is for their benefit and against your benefit Because immigrants just "take jobs" and add no value to the world, right? You can't think of any Americans
by davidw 14y ago
> It is for their benefit and against your benefit
Because immigrants just "take jobs" and add no value to the world, right? You can't think of any Americans who have become wealthy thanks to companies founded by immigrants?
> This is a struggle over how the pie is divided up.
This is economically illiterate. The economy is not "a pie", because it's not a zero sum game. The pie can grow, leaving more for everyone.
- hackinthebochs 14y ago>The economy is not "a pie", because it's not a zero sum game. The pie can grow, leaving more for everyone. But in the short term (multiple years) the biggest swings will likely be in terms of allocation of wealth rather than increase in total wealth. The majority of immigrants aren't going to be the likes of Elon Musks or Sergey Brin. They're going to be the rank and file IT workers that absolutely will cause stagnant wages and increased unemployment.
- davidw 14y ago> The majority of immigrants aren't going to be the likes of Elon Musks or Sergey Brin. If you look at numbers, they will tell you that more immigrants than "natives" start businesses.
- davidw 14y agoAh, the downvote: for when the facts irritate you. Well, here they are, from an admittedly biased site, but from everything I can tell, they're accurate: * Immigrants started 28% of all new U.S. businesses in 2011, despite accounting for just 12.9% of the U.S. population * Over the last 15 years, immigrants have increased the rate by which they start businesses by more than 50 percent, while the native-born have seen their business generation rate decline by 10 percent * Immigrants are now more than twice as likely to start a business as the native-born * Immigrants start more than 25% of all businesses in seven of the eight sectors of the economy that the U.S. government expects to grow the fastest over the next decade. These include health care and social assistance (28.7%), construction (31.8%), retail trade (29.1%) and leisure and hospitality (23.9%), among others http://www.renewoureconomy.org/index.php?q=open-for-business http://www.renewoureconomy.org/index.php?q=open-for-business
- Goladus 14y ago> Ah, the downvote: for when the facts irritate you. For when the facts are absent and even if they were there fail to adequately address the point that was made. I did not feel like a tedious debate. But since you insist and were helpful enough to provide some data: > Immigrants are now more than twice as likely to start a business as the native-born The point was: most immigrants do not start companies. Based on your quoted fact: if native-born people have a x% chance to start a business, immigrants have a 2x% chance to start a business. That means 100%-2x% of immigrants are not likely to start businesses. If x is 5, that means 90% of immigrants will probably not start a business. To say it in plain English: your facts support the point that most immigrants to not start companies.
- davidw 14y ago> your facts support the point that most immigrants to not start companies. Neither do must "natives". That wasn't my point. The point was that immigrants tend to be a bit more entrepreneurial, and start more companies. Many of those companies are not 'startups' like we discuss here, but still, some of them grown and provide employment.
- Goladus 14y ago> The economy is not "a pie", because it's not a zero sum game. The pie can grow, leaving more for everyone. The interesting question is: what causes the pie to grow? There is really only one thing that can fundamentally increase the size of the pie and that is natural resource income. The other thing that increases the virtual size of the pie is improving the efficiency of converting natural resources to things people want (standard of living). It's also important to remember that after natural resource income (mainly energy) the next economic fundamental is food, housing, and basic utilities (heat/water/sanitation/electricity). Workers are required to convert natural resources to improved standard of living. But workers also have wants and needs.
- davidw 14y agoGenerally, productivity is a better match to a country's wealth than natural resources. Certainly, at some ultimate level, things depend on the latter, but what you make with what you've got seems to matter far more in practice. That's one of the reasons a country like the Netherlands is rich despite not having a great deal in the way of natural resources.
- Goladus 14y ago> Generally, productivity is a better match to a country's wealth than natural resources. It's not an either/or question. The natural resources are still the foundation of the economy, even if you don't gather them directly yourself. And in the Netherlands I suspect a very important natural resource for the local economy is land. I don't have time for research at the moment but I would guess that simply to live in the Netherlands is very expensive.