24 ms·
For some companies, for some types of work, for some contexts, fine. But I'm getting really tired of people assuming that their limited experience in their lim
by ColinWright 14y ago
For some companies, for some types of work, for some contexts, fine. But I'm getting really tired of people assuming that their limited experience in their limited world applies universally.
More importantly - be intelligent about your policies. Consider what the work is, and how people work best. Give them the power and the responsibility to get things done. Allow them to take control, and make sure they are well informed about what you're trying to accomplish, and what the various external forces might be.
But don't tell me not to set hours for my employees. I've consulted with them, we've worked together, and for our context, with our customers, with our work, and in our marketplace, we, together, have concluded that regular hours in the office are the best way to work as a team and get the job done.
Your context will be different - be intelligent about your choices.
- jfb 14y agoHey, man, the OP is almost 30 years old. He's figured it all out.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoThat's a really low effort reply that adds nothing to the topic. Plus the OP's age is irrelevant. Even if he was 70 his point would be no more or less valid, and would still likely have the same issues. We can do better than this!
- jrabone 14y agoI read that as the original article OP, not the person posting on HN; whose point are you defending here? OT: wouldn't it be great if software like HN made it trivially easy to indicate WHO was being talked about? OP is apparently confusing - perhaps colour coding, or some other visual cue rather than "the post two posts above the reply to the previous post" or the mangled cut'n'paste of someone's barely readable grey handle that we have now.
- ColinWright 14y agoI thought it was pretty clear that "OP" in this case referred to "Original Poster", by which s/he means the person who wrote the article. It can't really refer to groundCode, because there's no way to work out his/her age. "OP" stands for "Original Poster." Your point is valid, but it's usually easily deduced, or the person who wrote the ambiguous comment should simply have been clearer.
- StavrosK 14y agoHe's also talking about the article OP, and he's saying that the HN poster's reply about age is very low-effort and doesn't contribute much, apart from an ad hominem.
- jpwagner 14y agoMaybe it wasn't so eloquently stated, but it's a valid point. The article is written by someone who is not yet 30 and started his company, a small web design company, 14 years ago. He has likely worked with young, small teams and has no other experience. The article itself comes off as naive and doesn't even say who the advice is intended for. It's reminiscent of a bad assignment for an undergraduate management course.
- gwright 14y agoAge is hardly irrelevant, especially when the point being made is of the form "In my experience …"
- gz5 14y agoGreat points. Similar to work from home memes - WFH productive or not productive? Neither...depends on each individual, team and environment.
- ownagefool 14y agoI would be highly suprised if you had consulted all your staff on such issues, generally such a thing may be discussed early on when policy is set, but it's unlikely to be reviewed after some staff churn but I'll take your word on it. Regardless, he's aruging for something that's going against the grain, so he doesn't need to actually give a balanced approach. We already know the advantages and hopefully the disadvantages or working set hours, so we don't need to hear it, we just need a strong argument for his point of view. You don't generally route for the other side in a debate, so the complaints are misplaced. Also it's not surprising as an employer you feel set hours are the right approach for you. I'm not making a judgment on you, but it's very common for employers to make leaving at 5 O'clock very awkward and they never seem to have a problem asking employees to do work out of hours, while generally being very quiet about policy to get that time back. Over the short term, abusing your employees in such a way comes with no disadvantages, so the employers love it. Long term, the same employees will probably become disheartened, but we live in a society where we'd rather replace those employees and charge on ahead. If you do any of these things, you're the type of employer the article is arguing against, if not, then your morale is probably fine which is the real undertone of such articles.
- ColinWright 14y agoWe did consult all our staff, with only 25 it wasn't hard. There were differences of opinion, but a balance was found. Further, we have no churn - as I write this, no one has left in the last 11 years. We are explicit about out-of-hours work, because sometimes we have engineers in the field working in very different time zones. In those cases the staff decide among themselves who will be providing support, and the company policies about recompense are clear. The compensation policies were agreed by all affected staff, and they seem genuinely content. We take this seriously, not least because it would be possible to abuse our position.
- ownagefool 14y agoWell I'm not super suprised if you actually treat your employees right that you don't have a lot of staff churn. Removing abusing your employees, pay them resonably well, and give them something to do, and you've probably removed 90% of the reasons people move company, especially considering most employees know it probably won't be the case if they move elsewhere. Truly well done if that's the case, it's a shame that such a thing seems to be the exception from my experience. :)