7 ms·
Why I'm Furious with Silicon Valley (2011)
- barretts 14y agoI don't know the details here but this missive reads like that of someone who failed and turned to the litigation system for revenge.
- josephagoss 14y agoThe government was forcing him to shut down his company, I would turn to litigation if this happened to me.
- ISL 14y agoNote date of 2011.
- redthrowaway 14y agoYes, the mods should probably edit the title lest people mistakenly think it's part of his lawsuit.
- michaelochurch 14y agoI don't know about his past with Zuckerberg, but this guy's basically a hero for calling VC-istan out for what it is: a rigged, corrupt mess where one's personal level of power determines which laws one must actually follow and which ones can be ignored. Consider all the co-funding and note-sharing that goes on among supposedly competing investors. That's clearly anti-competitive activity, but it's never enforced because of the power of the people who do it. It sounds like his particular lawsuit is without legal ground and will fail, but he deserves major props for bringing public attention to VC-istan's collusion problem. As I wrote, he's already morally entitled to an EIR position (at the very least, if not a real VC job) from VC-istan for his courage, intellect, and ethical above-board-ness, which are well into the top 5% by VC-istan standards (although that's not saying much).
- ryguytilidie 14y agoLike most things, we simply hold the rich and the powerful to a different standard. Steve Cohen can rob the American economy blind and even if the multiple teams of FBI agents surveiling him actually catch him and prosecute him, he will be in jail for a few years at most, only to slink back to his billions of dollars in wealth right after that will enrich his family for generations. Meanwhile the homeless guy who did some crack on the corner? 15 years. I really wonder sometimes if it is actually possible to fail in some of these situations. If you don't have to follow the same laws as everyone else and know there won't be consequences, you're going to crush your competition of not rich people who actually applied for permits and stuff. Because your competition knew if they didn't get them, they would pretty much be shut down, while these other companies basically said "lol laws" and like most companies who do, reaped massive rewards.
- michaelochurch 14y agoI think Aaron Greenspan is (as I am, to a lesser extent) a moral mysophobe. Most people know the world is run by scumbags and human garbage, but they adapt. It just becomes another landscape feature to them, like bad weather or dogshit on the sidewalk. Then there are other people who see unethical behavior and, for whatever reason, can't "just get over it" like normal people. They end up taking some immensely energy-consuming moral stands that often aren't in their individual interests. Such people are immensely beneficial to society, but it's not fun to be one.
- brianbreslin 14y agoWhere did he get a million bucks?
- alan_cx 14y agoForgive my ignorance, but he talks about "necessary capital", and fails to explain why and what it is for. Is this something the regulators demand in order to protect his customers? Isn't that desirable? Further, if he has put $1m in to the project, should he not have checked that laws and regulation first? Perhaps the writer assumes a lot of knowledge on the part of the reader.
- McGlockenshire 14y ago> should he not have checked that laws and regulation first? The regulations came into existence after his project did. After the regulations went into effect, he was unable to get his project certified under the regulations.
- 7Figures2Commas 14y agoThis is called regulatory risk. This story seems like a good example of why anyone starting a business in an industry that is already highly-regulated, such as finance, must assume that future regulations could increase the cost of doing business, or threaten the viability of the business outright.
- coffeemug 14y agoRather than invest in a productive, useful and frankly unprecedented product such as FaceCash, venture capital and angel investors have focused their time and billions of dollars of their money in companies and entrepreneurs that have, in serial fashion, deceived co-founders, deceived employees, and deceived customers. Rather than hiring a brilliant, hard working, and frankly outstanding engineer such as myself, technology companies have focused their time and billions of dollars of their money on engineers that have demonstrated, in a consistent fashion, lack of talent, skills, and integrity.
- flexxaeon 14y agoyeah it does come off a bit narcissistic
- angersock 14y agoThat's very cute and all, but do you care to skim TechCrunch or something and say, with a straight face, that primarily worthwhile endeavors are getting funded? Tell me about social, mobile, or the like.
- nemothekid 14y agoI don't think that is very honest considering FaceCash (not entirely sure) didn't beat Square to market, and I don't believe his idea was very "wild and unprecedented" as he claimed. Yes, seemingly dumb start up ideas get funded, but at the same time a lot of dumb and smart ideas don't get any attention, and there are still a good number of smart ideas that do get funded. If he couldn't get anyone to back his mobile payments idea, I think it says more about him and his character more than his idea. It's my belief that the reason someone funds/works for you can be attributed to less than half to how good your idea was, especially something that is really early stage.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- feniv 14y agoThe copyright reads 2001-2013, so I assume the code has evolved over time in design, but kept the old-school table layouts. If you look at the (admirably short) CSS file, most of it has to do with fonts and colors (and one block for drop shadows). All of the positioning is being handled by the table layout. It's "bad" code by today's web standards, but was once considered normal so I'm going to have to side with the developer here since the site functions well and displays beautifully.
- politician 14y agoIs this a federal law or a state law? The content of the article seems to imply state law, but the "gloom and doom" tone implies that FaceCash can't just move out of CA.
- dangrossman 14y agoIt's state law, but virtually every state licenses money transmitters, and you need a license from each state you want to transmit money into (where your customers are). No matter where you start, you need the licenses, and CA is particularly important since that's where the early adopters and investors are. Here's the list of 50 state licenses PayPal needs to operate: https://www.paypal-media.com/state_licenses.cfm https://www.paypal-media.com/state_licenses.cfm
- beachstartup 14y agoi'm not going to go into specifics because i'm scared of retaliation/retribution. there, i said it. i'm scared like a little bitch. especially now that i've got plenty to lose (read on...) imagine the following scenario. CEO (not me) of self-funded startup hires prestigious silicon valley law firm to incorporate and represent his new company. recruits 4 cofounders including big-name software company engineers and big-name b-school MBAs. however, nobody is 'connected' per se. ostensibly law firm does its job, and helps coordinate meetings with the TOP valley and seattle VCs. like top 3 in each area. like 'holy shit' what am i doing in this board room right now. like 'wow i can't believe i actually delivered my pitch without tripping over my own tongue'. during the fund raising process it's discovered the name of the company may be a copyright/trademark infringement on another company also represented by the law firm. founders are assured by law firms and VCs it's no big deal. it happens all the time. this sort of thing is very common! law firm could stand to charge 10 thousand in fees for a name change, so it seems like an honest opinion. during the fund raising process it's also discovered that the core business model of startup is in sort-of competition with another startup, already funded, represented by both the law firm, and a VC firm that lawfirm set startup up with to pitch. (of course no NDA's were signed). however, the business models are not identical, only similar. assurances all around, of course. fast forward 2 months. startup is getting traction. 10,000 users, some high profile sites are using startup's technology. fast forward another month. threats of lawsuit from represented company whose trademark claim is now becoming serious. fast forward another month. sort-of competitor is now full-on competitor. exact same concept is now implemented and deployed. no need to fast forward anymore. funding is never realized, company is under legal threat from multiple parties. other mistakes are made, but greatly exacerbated by a name change, which effectively kills the product. company implodes. kaput. the conclusion of whether this was purely due to founder incompetence or naiveté (which there is certainly a component) or there was a large component of malicious VC/lawyer/funded collusion is left as an exercise for the reader. however, i posit that the startup would have done FAR BETTER to not even get involved with the SV ecosystem IN THE FIRST PLACE. once you get involved, they will enforce their iron rule of SINK OR SWIM. and they WILL sink you. my current startup is making $millions/year in revenue WITHOUT ANY OUTSIDE HELP. cofounders own 100% because we said FUCK IT over 2 glasses of scotch whisky and dumped $250k of our own money into it. we get multiple emails and calls per month from VC and PE firms inquiring. lollerskates. fuck off assholes. i would rather go bankrupt and steal loaves of stale bread from my local bagel shop than work for those people. so that's just one data point for you. it's a jungle out there. keep your wits about you.
- greenlander 14y agoThink Computer Corporation has documented their dispute with the State of California in great detail, including scans of all the physical correspondence. https://www.facecash.com/legal/brown.html https://www.facecash.com/legal/brown.html If you read through the history, it's pretty clear that Think Computer Corporation got screwed by California. California classified him as a money transmitter, but refused to clearly define the bar needed for him to become one. It's obviously a case of favoring the big guy for now reason. Facebook and BoA can be money transmitters, because they're big. You're not big, you're a scrub, now go to get job at Facebook like the other scrubs. Obviously, this latest lawsuit makes him look like an obnoxious dickhead. I can nevertheless sympathize with his action here, which is to lash out at an obviously unfair system.
- wmf 14y agoAnd yet somehow their competitors are still in business.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- lisper 14y agoIn large part because they chose to flout the law, and California chose not to prosecute them (yet). Be careful before you celebrate people who succeed because they choose to break the law. It's a very slippery slope.
- 7Figures2Commas 14y agoI don't think this is necessarily a fair assessment. In my brief reading the documents at the link referenced above, it appears that the author originally contacted the state of California, believing that he may be subject to the Money Transmission Act (MTA) based on his reading of the law. In his initial correspondence, he asks for clarification: is he actually engaged in operating a money transmission service, or is he an exempt payment processor? That seems like a simple question but the bureaucrats he's dealing with don't provide an answer. Instead, they appear to latch on to his correspondence and treat it as a representation that he is engaged in money transmission and therefore subject to the MTA. That's not exactly surprising: if he is subject to the MTA, there's a license involved, which generates revenue for the state. This leaves an interesting unanswered question: was the author ever subject to the law in the first place? Perhaps the competitors who you suggest are flouting the law brought the matter to their legal counsel, who concluded that they were exempt. That doesn't mean that they aren't, but the lack of prosecutions hints that this isn't an unreasonable possibility. One final comment about breaking the law: financial services are highly regulated and given the number of laws and regulations at the federal and state levels, I don't think any company in this space can ever be certain that it is not breaking some law. One thing is for sure however: if you're running a financial services company and have questions about a law, allowing legal counsel to research the matter and handle any correspondence with regulators is the best approach.