3 ms·
Ugh, this article again? It crops up every quarter without fail. If one of these could actually provide some sort of analysis or evidence for their conclusions
by mikeyouse 14y ago
Ugh, this article again? It crops up every quarter without fail.
If one of these could actually provide some sort of analysis or evidence for their conclusions, that'd be pretty great. Each time it's published, they relay a few anecdotes about 1 or 2 mildly famous people renouncing citizenship. They then give a trend in absolute numbers without addressing population changes, and finally go on to blame taxes or whatever else for the trend that they assure is happening.
Is expatriation increasing? Maybe? Who knows with this quality of reporting.
The question of how to treat international taxation is almost entirely separate from expatriation. If people aren't taking the easy step and relocating to different states due to tax differences[1][2][3], I doubt it's the main reason they're renouncing citizenship.
[1] - http://www.stanford.edu/group/scspi/_media/working_papers/Varner-Young_Millionaire_Migration_in_CA.pdf http://www.stanford.edu/group/scspi/_media/working_papers/Va...
[2] - http://www.cbpp.org/cms/?fa=view&id=3556 http://www.cbpp.org/cms/?fa=view&id=3556
[3] - http://publicassets.org/press/press-releases/new-study-jobs-not-taxes-stimulate-migration/ http://publicassets.org/press/press-releases/new-study-jobs-...
- mech4bg 14y agoGood points, but regarding moving states - that doesn't address large federal taxes, or taxes on things that aren't taxed in other countries (death tax, gift tax).
- mikeyouse 14y agoTrue, but if tax regime had a significant impact on migration, it should have an incremental impact at all scales, offset by the expense / difficulty of actually migrating. If one lives in California and earns enough to be in the top bracket (>$1mm/year), they could save a marginal 10% by relocating to Nevada. It's only a four hour drive to Tahoe, so you would expect to see a fair portion of people doing so. However, there is almost no evidence that this actually occurs. Expatriation is just migration on a larger scale. The expense and complexity are obviously higher, but the basic incentives are identical. I have no doubt that at some very-high net worth, it makes sense to renounce and move abroad, but is it worth wasting energy on the few people a year who will do so?
- dalke 14y ago"Is expatriation increasing? Maybe? Who knows with this quality of reporting." It certainly is. With this reporting it was very easy to find the actual list, which is at https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2013/05/08/2013-10852/quarterly-publication-of-individuals-who-have-chosen-to-expatriate https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2013/05/08/2013-108... . (Though "LOCKE-TECKEMEIER LORETTA ULLRICH" and "LOCKE-TECKMEIER LORETTA U." are likely the same person, so the count won't be perfect.) With a bit of work, you can easily verify if the number is increasing. "If people aren't taking the easy step and relocating to different states due to tax differences..." A different logic is much more likely. There are Americans who have already relocated overseas and some decades later renounce their citizenship. Consider Corine Mauch, the Iowa born mayor of Zurich. “My relationship with the U.S. is limited to my very early youth,”. "[S]he regards Switzerland as her home and doesn’t want to deal with Internal Revenue Service paperwork, according to an e- mailed statement from her office today." http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-04-18/zurich-mayor-renounces-u-s-citizenship-amid-tighter-tax-rules.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-04-18/zurich-mayor-renoun... . You're right; it's hard to tell if someone renounced citizenship in order to avoid paying US taxes. Indeed, there are other reasons for doing so. Someone running for the legislature of another country may be required to renounce all other citizenships. But given the rather rapid rise in renunciations, correlated with the increase in tax reporting and compliance policies, it's a pretty reasonable conclusion. In any case, the US policies both real (the Reed amendment) and proposed (the Ex-Patriot Act) are rather harsh on people who renounce for tax reasons, so it will be hard to carry out a study where you ask people if that's the basis for their decision. (You'll see that Mauch carefully did not say that she left because of taxation reasons.) "Expatriation is just migration on a larger scale." Your example, with two US states, isn't the same comparison. Better would be to think of a California resident who moves to Nevada, never goes back to California, but still has to pay California taxes. "is it worth wasting energy on the few people a year who will do so" No. Absolutely not. But there's a few other issues at play. For example, the reason for the heightened tax reporting policies is to crack down on US residents with overseas bank accounts, who use those accounts to avoid paying US taxes. Ex-pats (who have no strong representation in Congress), are caught in the cross-fire.
- 14y ago
- goodcanadian 14y agoThis isn't talking about average Americans, it is talking about dual citizens who are living in and have significant assets and income in foreign countries. It is saying that more and more people are deciding that the many benefits of American citizenship are being outweighed by the onerous tax laws placed on American citizens . . . rules that no other country places on their citizens. While it would improve the article to have better reporting, it is not a controversial idea. And, it is not limited to Americans. A famous French example is Gérard Depardieu who recently renounced his French citizenship in exchange for Russian citizenship explicitly for tax reasons (and he had no prior connection to Russia).