3 ms·
I'm curious if anyone does it now for reasons entirely unrelated to taxes or inheritance or finance or the hassle of filing taxes/regulatory in general, but pur
by rdl 14y ago
I'm curious if anyone does it now for reasons entirely unrelated to taxes or inheritance or finance or the hassle of filing taxes/regulatory in general, but purely as a political protest or something like that.
I only know one person (who wasn't otherwise a criminal) who renounced for what seemed like totally non-financial, non-administrative reasons: Vince Cate, back in the 1990s, when he was my neighbor in Anguilla and wanted to work on crypto stuff during the ITAR ban days.
- jlgreco 14y agoOne of the cornerstones for Socrates' defense of the rule of law was that any adult who did not like the law was free to leave, without being taxed for doing so. I find it interesting that there are clearly so many in this country who have very deep disagreements with the law, but so few seem to leave. Of course I do not blame them; simply moving somewhere more agreeable to you is not as simple as Socrates may have you believe...
- rdl 14y agoI've "left" a few times (I think I've lived outside the US longer than I've lived in the US, at least after age 14), but as a US Citizen, the most egregious aspects still apply to me wherever I am. And renouncing one's citizenship is a far bigger step than leaving, or never having had it in the first place. Also, many of the problems with the US are actually global externalities and hurt non-citizens/non-residents abroad even more than they affect US citizens or those within the US. We essentially are responsible for the global war on drugs, for instance. It's hard to figure out what things would cause me to be so angry at the USG to renounce citizenship but not to remain in the US and use all means to try to fix the problem. e.g. if there were a genuine Hitler/Stalin/Mao-level takeover of the US, I wouldn't be content to just flee somewhere and try to avoid it; the only reason to leave would be temporarily to raise funds/forces to try to fix it. But I really don't see anything like that happening in the US -- much more likely just a long slide into comparative irrelevancy like the UK has done over the past 60-80 years.
- mprovost 14y agoKind of. "Mr Wilfred alleges he is a victim of a CIA conspiracy after he had acted as a whistleblower to expose alleged corruption in the agency." http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10877269 http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&obj...
- dragonwriter 14y ago> I'm curious if anyone does it now for reasons entirely unrelated to taxes or inheritance or finance or the hassle of filing taxes/regulatory in general, but purely as a political protest or something like that. Yes. Despite the HN headline and the lede paragraph of the linked article ascribing this to US taxes, the article's "poster boy" (I mean, literally, the example of the trend who they lead with a big photograph of, and the only one of the two named examples who is quoted actually discussing his motive in the article) -- Mahmood Karzai, who has lived in Afghanistan for 12 years and is the elder brother of Afghan President Hamid Karzai, cites his reason as "I might become politically active, therefore I decided to give up my [U.S.] passport." Nothing to do with taxes, there.
- dalke 14y agoThere's a partial list of people and reasons at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_former_United_States_citizens_who_relinquished_their_nationality http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_former_United_States_ci... . It includes Vince Cate. For example, Terry Gilliam (the director) "renounced his American citizenship, describing the George W. Bush administration as having created an environment "scarily similar to the Orwellian nightmare" of his 1985 film Brazil."
- rdl 14y agoWow, a few of those guys are awesome. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Ash_(writer) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Ash_(writer) who renounced because the US had a stance of neutrality vs. the Nazis for too long, so he renounced to become a Canadian military pilot. Awarded MBE. Apparently they used to be a lot more "automatic" about revoking citizenship for acts (like joining a foreign military as an officer) where there wasn't clear intent to renounce citizenship. It now requires a seriously affirmative act; essentially showing up at a consulate and making a declaration, demonstrating that it's intentional and informed, etc.