5 ms·
You can't say that all government regulation of healthcare is a bad thing. It literally saves lives. If healthcare was left as a completely free market I dread
by untog 14y ago
You can't say that all government regulation of healthcare is a bad thing. It literally saves lives.
If healthcare was left as a completely free market I dread to think how many people would die as a result of cut corners and rushed diagnoses.
- curt 14y agoYou can still sue a doctor or hospital for malpractice. EDIT (answering the responses): - Overseas you can buy a cheap insurance policy to cover the cost of a lawsuit. The underwriter determines your likelihood of success and charges accordingly. - You really think regulations stop that from happening now? People still get the wrong limbs operated on and amputated.
- untog 14y agoIf you're still alive, yes. And even then, if you were paralysed from the neck down (for example), would you really be able to enjoy the millions you got in court? Financial compensation for crippling illness always struck me as quite strange.
- mseebach 14y agoThe point of financial compensation isn't really to compensate the victim (or their family), it's to push the cost of the externality created back onto the provider, giving an incentive to act sensibly.
- kmfrk 14y agoLawsuits aren't free.
- wyager 14y agoThere are shitloads of lawyers who pick up malpractice lawsuits on contract, saying that they'll do the case for free if they get x% of the winnings.
- fancyketchup 14y agoJust thinking out loud, not making a judgement: I wonder if the overhead from lawyer's fees would turn out to be any less than the overhead from government regulations.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- gte910h 14y agoCase law is still law. Libertarians who think "SUE SUE SUE" is the answer really frustrate me: It's random judges picking the law instead of elected reps
- burntsushi 14y agoPeople who think "throw more politicians at the problem" really frustrate me: they are a bunch of random people seeking more power for themselves.
- rayiner 14y agoI've always found it a bit strange that libertarians' solution to everything is always "sue!"
- dreamdu5t 14y agoI would rather have judges, in a court case where parties get to represent themselves, applying common law, with a jury of my peers deciding the verdict... than random idiots elected by a bunch of other random idiots I don't know make laws without my input.
- gte910h 14y agoJudges create case law, over and over. Common law was created that way, and tons more is created that way every day. I don't know why you assume this is better that popularly chosen law.
- dreamdu5t 14y agoCommon law is popularly chosen law created by the people. Statutory law (almost entirely with the exception of a few states and their referendums) isn't. Statutory laws applying to 350+ million people are crafted by 435 people.
- gte910h 14y ago>Common law is popularly chosen law created by the people No it's not. It's case law from England. It's created by judges.
- untog 14y agoYou really think regulations stop that from happening now? Should we stop sterilising surfaces because it only protects you from infection 98% of the time? Regulations are far from 100% successful, but yes, I do believe they reduce the number of accidents.
- bane 14y agoGood, the the incentive moves to kill the patient rather then try to save them from an accidental complication. Dead patients can't sue.
- wyager 14y ago>It literally saves lives. Authoritarianism does tend to save lives. That doesn't make it a good thing. >If healthcare was left as a completely free market I dread to think how many people would die as a result of cut corners and rushed diagnoses. As if that isn't the case in the most heavily bureaucratized healthcare systems today... The free market doesn't result in "cut corners;" it results in optimal middle grounds between cost-saving and quality of service, tailored to individual market groups.