3 ms·
The thing people forget about Antarctica is that it's not a wild frontier. It's dangerous, it's cold, but it's also governed by a lot of very important internat
by XorNot 14y ago
The thing people forget about Antarctica is that it's not a wild frontier. It's dangerous, it's cold, but it's also governed by a lot of very important international treaties about what you can and can't do there - and it's a major part of the global ocean ecosystem.
Basically: it's a terrible idea for us to go mining, drilling or terraforming in the Antarctic, and if we did, it would probably rapidly turn into a warzone.
Space on the other hand - other planets, or asteroids or whatever - are not like this at all. They are literally owned by no one, and barring some event where you crash something into the Earth, nothing you do on them will ever effect the livability of our planet. You really can go there and do whatever you want, on whatever scale you want.
Economically asteroid mining makes more sense, but if we acknowledge that scientific research is important then the old truism of our off-world rovers is still - afaik - full in force: impressive as they are, they take weeks to accomplish what a geologist with a shovel could do in an hour.
- voidlogic 14y agoAll true and valid, but I still want to know the economic value of building a colony on Mars- is there anything worth mining there, and not only worth mining for Mars use but worth commerce with Earth over?
- mburns 14y agoThis is a well-studied topic, of course. The primary economic value is tourism/novelty. There are not large amounts of helium-3, like on the Moon, but there is ice. If you can get there (SpaceX in particular is working on that, for $500,000 a ticket), you could potentially live in a spacious, bomb shelter-like structure with relative comfort, and even venture outside (with a spacesuit) if you felt up for it. Mars could become a retirement locale for the sufficiently-successfully, not unlike of Florida but without the gators. It is not particularly likely, even with reusable rockets, that ore would be worth the price of shipping back to Earth in bulk. More efficient to use it for cheaper spacecraft (launch from Mars is less demanding on fuel) or Mars building structures directly, to house more residents.