3 ms·
Self-defence (encryption) is the only real protection from government snooping on communications. You can't rely on policy. It moves too slowly and there are a
by dmix 14y ago
Self-defence (encryption) is the only real protection from government snooping on communications.
You can't rely on policy. It moves too slowly and there are always loopholes.
It's a shame there's no mainstream or accessible solutions to encrypt email while using services like gmail. Although they exist for IM.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- KMag 14y agoShameless plug for my old room mate's startup, [http://penango.com http://penango.com Penango]. Penango uses a browser plugin to implement S/MIME for GMail and several other popular webmail providers. Your private keys stay on your local machine.
- eric_bullington 14y agoAwesome, thanks for the tip! I've just opened up the page and if the technology looks at all workable, I'll sign-up/purchase. EDIT: Ah no, no Chrome plugin! I may have to go back to Firefox. I've been using it lately for development and it's come a long way in 2-3 years. EDIT II: I found a very interesting open-source Chrome OpenPGP plugin built by a research team. http://gpg4browsers.recurity.com/ http://gpg4browsers.recurity.com/ (Turns out project was merged to mymail-crypt project here: http://www.openpgpjs.org/ http://www.openpgpjs.org/) But I'll be sure to check back with Penango since they have said that a Chrome plugin in coming mid-2013.
- declan 14y agoYep. SSL is now viewed as a good best practice for data in transit, to the point that Apple was criticized for not enabling it for the App Store (http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-57573334-37/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-57573334-37/). But the real issue, as you indicate, is stored data. Full Gmail encryption would presumably be done in conjunction with the client via the browser. Because the server wouldn't have access to the plaintext, search becomes tricky and contextual ads problematic. One solution would be for Google to make fully encrypted Gmail a paid service.
- duaneb 14y agoGoogle would never add encryption to gmail. As a business decision it's pretty atrocious.
- EthanHeilman 14y agoThey could still do targeted advertising and client side encryption. You just have some of the words hashed and sent to a third party web service that compares hashed words against ad words. With the right level of noise you could preserve both the security of the communications and offer targeted advertising. Or google could offer ad free encrypted gmail that costs money. There are plenty of business solutions to this problem and we will see many of them tried.
- declan 14y agoDon't you mean: "Google would never add encryption for stored messages to unpaid Gmail accounts." Why would it necessarily be an "atrocious" business decision to charge extra for encrypted accounts? Google's happy to charge when the market demand exists for a paid service (GAE and GAB come to mind). It's true that the market demand may be insufficient here to make it worthwhile, but on the other hand privacy-sensitive companies and agencies might be more willing to switch to paid Gmail if their email were seen as more private than it is today.
- superuser2 14y agoIt's also unlikely that Google could do government-proof mail any better than Husmail. They were compelled to fake the Java client in order to obtain a user's keys; why couldn't Google be pressured to do the same?
- sixothree 14y agoCompelled by a warrant? I think that would be acceptable to most people.
- 14y ago
- mtgx 14y agoTechnical solutions might seem "faster" but only for the people at the head of the movement - usually the more technical people. You won't see the majority of the people start adopting those solutions anytime soon.