4 ms·
I have to admit I was against ACA for a variety of reasons, but if the first step is increased price transparency and exposing that data, it will do a lot of go
by rdl 14y ago
I have to admit I was against ACA for a variety of reasons, but if the first step is increased price transparency and exposing that data, it will do a lot of good.
The best reform I can think of would be a combination of individually purchased (vs. employer) HSAs, where poor people get grants of up to the the full deductible per year in some kind of special account IFF they sign up for HSAs, and price transparency. Employers who currency pay for your entire insurance could give you an equivalent amount (plus deductible) which goes into your Health Savings Account.
You're then effectively paying an army of 300 million to constantly search for the best prices (or rather, to find third party organizations to search for the best prices for them). $3-5k/person is actually not that unreasonable for the poorest 30mm people and those covered by medicare/va/medicare-for-kids/etc.
I'm confident this could drop the prices of procedures by >10x, comparable to other countries. Americans are really good at driving down costs when they know the costs and are paying them out of pocket; look at how much cheaper it is to buy an iPhone in the USA vs. where it's made.
- humanrebar 14y agoThat's not a political reality. Since healthcare bought by an employer counts as an tax-deductible expense and healthcare bought by an individual gets no such breaks, there is a huge incentive (equal to the marginal tax rate) for individuals to have someone else write the checks for the bulk of their healthcare costs. Before market-based healthcare will work, either 1) employer-provided health insurance benefits must be taxed as income or 2) individual healthcare purchases must be tax-free. 1) is an obvious political non-starter. 2) is a huge new loophole in the tax code and an accounting nightmare.
- greedo 14y agoIndividual healthcare purchases (not insurance) can be deducted from your taxes, either explicitly if you're filing a long form, or implicitly if you're claiming the standard deduction. I don't see why it would be a huge burden to make individual health insurance tax deductible.
- humanrebar 14y agoOnly healthcare expenses over 7.5% of adjusted gross income are tax deductible. Plus, the poor and lower-middle class don't tend to much in income taxes (if any), so they wouldn't qualify for the discount. In contrast, corporations always write off employee healthcare premiums on their taxes. The issue isn't just the fairness of who pay taxes when, it's also about the distortions in healthcare markets caused by these policies.
- rdl 14y ago#2 is solved by HSAs. HSA purchases are tax-free.
- humanrebar 14y agoSee my reply to greedo above.
- rdl 14y agoHSAs are not deductions. HSAs are pre-tax money which is essentially tax exempt when saved/invested (including gains) or when spent on a medical purchase. So you can still use one fully even if you take the standard deduction.
- humanrebar 14y agoYou cannot pay insurance premiums from an HSA. HSAs have annual caps. Small business owners still have to pay some taxes on HSA contributions. The poor have no use for tax deductions because they don't pay income taxes. HSAs are a partial answer at best. All that being said, I think my original point about employer-provided insurance incentives distorting the healthcare market stands empirically. It just costs more if you buy your own health insurance. If taxes aren't the reason, what is? And what should be done about that, if anything?
- rdl 14y agoYes, your out of pocket is premium + out of pocket maximum. No, HSAs no longer have caps (at least policies signed after a certain date, or in some states; I think pretty soon they'll have no annual or lifetime maximums at all); they're essentially "you're at risk based on your deductible for non-preventive services up to the out of pocket maximum, but excellent essentially-free care for the rest of the year once you hit that cap"). (there are some weird edge cases, like Rx drugs outside the hospital, potentially non-covered services, etc., but essentially a $500k hospital bill for some serious trauma would all be covered after you've paid the $5-7k out of pocket maximum (probably met on the way to the hospital or within seconds of entering the ER, if it's a serious trauma) You can solve the "poor have no use for tax deductions" by giving them the out of pocket maximum into the HSA; it's free money in a personal allocated account. Or by making some deductions refundable or credits (similar to the EIC, which is most of why Puerto Rico wants to become a state now...most citizens would earn a federal tax rebate!) The quick fix is probably to make personal purchases of health insurance also deductible, rather than removing employer health insurance deductibility. And push people into HSAs, with some people getting HSA account filling by the government. No one should be against this (except I guess "any tax decreases are bad, since we're already operating at a deficit")