4 ms·
This is why the ACA is such a boon for people that thonk health care should be a free market. It takes the free market ideals and embraces them; the accusations
by epistasis 14y ago
This is why the ACA is such a boon for people that thonk health care should be a free market. It takes the free market ideals and embraces them; the accusations of socialism are more telling of the accuser than the accused. That's not to say that I think health care should be a free market, just that its the goal of the ACA, and the current situation in the US is much less free a market, and due to employer provided insurance, barely a market at all. No price information is communicated to consumers, and the ACA will start to do that.
- Jayschwa 14y agoOne good aspect doesn't make it a boon. In my personal experience, the law has made insurance less affordable. I'm in between jobs and bought an inexpensive short-term, high-deductible plan. However, the plan has been deprecated (no renewals after a certain date) because it does not meet all provisions of the ACA.
- rdl 14y agoMy long-term HDHP went from $80/mo to $118/mo, which is high in percentage terms, but still not a big deal IMO. In the process they gave me unlimited lifetime coverage, added free preventive care, etc. -- which IMO seems actuarially impossible, but I'm on the buy side of this transaction.
- gojomo 14y agoCan you share the name of your provider (or their peer set)?
- rdl 14y agoIt really varies by state. I went to an online insurance comparison app (I should promote Leaky or SimplyInsured here, but at the time in 2010, I used ehealthinsurance), searched for HDHPs, then picked based on reputation. I picked a Blue Shield provider with no lifetime cap (or a $6mm lifetime cap, I forget). The only states I know are WA and CA. In WA, I like Regence Blue Shield; plans seem to be in the $100-150/mo range now. In CA, there are also a lot of HDHPs in the $100-150/mo range. I'd specifically avoid Kaiser as an employer giving coverage, as some people really dislike Kaiser since you must use a Kaiser doctor, hospital, or other facility, but if you're an individual and like a Kaiser doctor, it might be a good choice. Otherwise a lot of people I know use Health Net, Anthem, etc. I'm not a lawyer nor am I a licensed insurance agent so I'm hesitant to recommend specific plans. I think these rates are low due to being HDHPs and the "best" patient group; 26-35 year old single male. Those are exactly the people who don't get individual insurance unless they're cautious people who join AAA, change oil on time, buy fire extinguishers, look both ways before crossing the street, etc. (and thus exceptionally good risks), and even then seek to minimize contact with doctors. I suspect the unhealthy ones are particularly likely to take jobs with insurance, or be on medicaid/prison/etc., in that bracket, or are so irresponsible as to have no insurance (because hey, even $120/mo is better spent on beer). Rates don't seem that much worse for women (which is weird, since I'd assume most women get enough extra covered services covered now by an HSA to destroy the actuarial model for a $100/mo plan). The rates 4x once you add children, though. I tried also plugging in numbers for people born in 1969, 1959, 1950, and rates do go up, but only maybe 4x, too. So the prices are generally within a 10x range per insured, at least for healthy people or in places where there is no medical underwriting, tops, and under ACA, that will converge to 4x (although I'm sure by raising the low end by 50-150% and only lowering the top end by a trivial amount.) I always assumed all insurance was $500+/mo/insured, since that's what the group rates for small businesses seem to be, but that's due to adverse selection and inefficiency I think. The real problem seems to be if you're unhealthy when looking for insurance, or have children (particularly with high medical costs), or have an acute high-cost event, or are poor enough that $100-200/mo is a hardship (even though I think $100-200/mo for health insurance, whether paid by the individual or the government, is pretty reasonable), or are, worst case, so unhealthy that you're also poor and thus doubly screwed.
- rdl 14y agoWow, this is insanity: I priced some NY (10024) and MA (02139) zip codes on ehealthinsurance and the coverage looked approximately 5x CA or WA rates. I'm not sure if that's specific to the site and their mix of carriers, or if insurance really is that much more expensive on the East Coast.
- gojomo 14y agoThanks for all your pointers and observations! I will likely be in the market for an HDHP soon and these will give my own search a running start.
- 300bps 14y ago>In my personal experience, the law has made insurance less affordable. Last year I had a PPO insurance plan at work that cost $216 per month for a family plan and had very tiny out of pocket expenses. This year my employer dropped the PPO as being unaffordable and switched to a HDHP that costs the same $216 per month for my family plan. Now the plan pays literally nothing for the first $3,000. And then 80/20 up to the first $7,000. The ACA benefited a lot of people. If you're an older student living at home. If you have a pre-existing condition. If you develop a catastrophic illness. But if you're not in one of those benefited groups then you are paying for those benefited groups.
- jws 14y ago$216 sounds like only your part of the payment. Do you know how your employer's contribution (the bulk of the total cost) changed? Sounds like they saved a lot of money.
- MrUnknown 14y agoThis is exactly it. The company I work for is fairly open, and I know how much they pay every pay period for my health insurance, and it is about 3x as much as I pay for the plan. This guy's company sounds like they changed providers, pushed almost all the cost to the employee (under the mask that it costs the employee the same), is saving a ton of money, but tells the employees to blame the ACA. While I work for a decent company, they even tried to blame some crap on the ACA trying to explain why the premiums went up this year. Except, they went up the same amount the year before, and the one before that also.
- LekkoscPiwa 14y agoyeah, and that's called inflation and is the direct result of the Government actions and not your employers fault.
- humanrebar 14y agoThe sickest among us are by far the most expensive to provide healthcare to: the dying, the elderly, the disabled, the chronically ill. The ACA does a lot to limit costs for those age groups through mandating coverage for pre-existing conditions, introducing caps on premiums, and removing dollar limits on how much coverage an individual is entitled to (both annually and over a lifetime). You can argue that those are beneficial steps, but they certainly distort the economics of making healthcare decisions.
- DanBC 14y agoThe other distortion is that there's not much in the way of preventative health care. Diabetes is expensive and has a bunch of complications, yet obesity and excess sugar consumption is a serious problem that doesn't get much help. Some mental health problems respond much better to early intervention. Leaving them means the person drifts along, not thriving, sometimes leaving work or staying at minimum wage. (Or, in England, on disability benefits). Getting treatment early (which can be as little as 14 sessions of 1 hour per week of talking therapy) can effectively cure some people, and provides remission and resilience for others. But, again, this kind of stuff isn't as widespread as it needs to be. Note this isn't any kind of human rights argument for better healthcare. It's firmly financial benefit.