3 ms·
Yes, saying that "thou" is a word that has survived for hundreds of centuries is a bit odd to me. As far as I can tell, the only reason thou even exists as a wo
by freehunter 14y ago
Yes, saying that "thou" is a word that has survived for hundreds of centuries is a bit odd to me. As far as I can tell, the only reason thou even exists as a word in modern English (at least in the US) is because it's so heavily used in the Bible (not exactly a modern book). The only times I hear someone using thou is in context of the Bible or ye olde tyme joking.
- VLM 14y agoBible wasn't originally written in English of course. The more recent the translation, the less Thou you get. We didn't have much alternative for 2nd person singular pronouns until "You" wiped "Thou" off the map somewhat recently and attempts at turning "Thou" into a formal religious version of "You" seem to have flopped. Then again we did pretty well without a second person plural until y'all invented y'all, plus or minus some "ye" anyway. Theres some idioms that'll never die even if no one understands the history. "Holier than thou". Much like "Your name is Mudd" sometimes kinda horrifies people who don't know the story of Abe Lincoln and Dr Mudd. I've met people who claim to not know the history of "cotton pickin hands" or even acknowledge its racial background, which seems hard to believe, then again cotton hasn't been hand harvested in a couple generations locally so its possible the kids were telling the truth about not knowing what they're saying...
- muraiki 14y agoWell, "thou" also had a use for a period of time as an intimate form of "you." The intention behind the use of "Thou" to address God in the Bible is not to place distance between the speaker and God; on the contrary, it is to indicate closeness and intimacy. The Wikipedia article on thou explains this briefly in the introductory paragraphs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thou https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thou
- bcoates 14y agoLooking up "cotton pickin" in Google ngram viewer, it appears to be mostly a product of the 1960s-1970s ruralsploitation fad: The Beverly Hillbillies, Hee Haw and Foghorn Leghorn. It's probably just an intentionally quaint pseudo-folk saying invented by someone in Burbank.
- coldtea 14y agoI don't think the Google ngram viewer is an appropriate tool for something that mostly belongs to the spoken language, and even more that of pour illiterate blacks and southerners.
- VLM 14y ago"It's probably just an intentionally quaint pseudo-folk saying invented by someone in Burbank." LOL no, assuming you young folks pretending not to understand are serious. As a hint take a look at the skin color and local social hierarchy position of the people picking cotton back when that was still done by hand, by property or former property, as they used to say. It was basically used in place of the "N-word" when it was just barely not socially acceptable to use the "N-word" in that situation.
- joelmichael 14y agoShakespeare, among others.
- coldtea 14y ago>Yes, saying that "thou" is a word that has survived for hundreds of centuries is a bit odd to me. Well, for linguists "thou" and "you" is the same word. Not just in that they mean the same, but in the same sense that in evolution X1 is said to be an ancestor species to X2. "Thou" and "You", is the same word passed through a process of changes in pronunciation and spelling during the years. Linguists keep track of those kinds of things.
- stan_rogers 14y ago"Thou" is recently deceased, and while it hasn't been thoroughly documented, it's as likely as not due to a combination of the over-extension of the polite form of address and the use in early English typography of the "y" from Latinate typefaces for the thorn character. ("Ye" of "ye olde" is an alternate spelling of "the", and not related to the second person plural subject pronoun "ye".) The polite plural is common enough in European languages; there are French dialects (in Canada, at least) where a good rule of thumb is "don't use tu unless you're sleeping with that person or are their parent". With the second person singular restricted to intimate use, it's not hard to imagine it falling away.