4 ms·
The "real" solution is to retrain society from top to bottom to break the conflation between what a law is and the outcome a law is intended to produce. As that
by jerf 14y ago
The "real" solution is to retrain society from top to bottom to break the conflation between what a law is and the outcome a law is intended to produce. As that phrasing implies, I don't think this is going to be an easy process.
The purpose of a speed limit is not to make people not go more than 55 miles per hour. The purpose of a speed limit is to make driving safe, and particularly to make driving safe for society, even moreso than for the individual. If everybody is driving at 65 in the 55 zone, but everybody is safe, the higher purpose of the law is being met, and citations for speeding are just punitive for no gain. When conditions make 55 unsafe, people need to slow down enough to be safe, regardless of what the local speed limit is.
Because we've never been able to rigidly enforce laws, it was very easy to conflate the two concepts. Now we are starting to develop some tech that does let us rigidly enforce laws. The solution is, don't do that. The laws we have on the books today were not designed for rigid enforcement. They were designed to be tools for creating public safety that could be used by the legal system, they are not themselves the specification of public safety. No such specification can really be created, and people are going to have to learn that.
Hopefully we learn that before we really box ourselves in with even better tech. Either way we do seem very determined to learn this the hard way.
This idea has applications to all sorts of modern day issues popular on HN; copyright law isn't really to prevent you from sharing a copy of a song with a friend, it's to prevent massive pirating enterprises that impact the market. Patent law isn't intended to provide mechanisms to sue end-user consumers of scanners that violate patents, it's intended to protect innovators from having their ideas taken without compensation by large engineering firms. Regulations in general are intended to produce certain results, usually some sort of social safety, they are not intended to becomes gods in and of themselves. But the actions of pretty much everybody in the system from top to bottom proves this idea is poorly understood.
- igouy 14y agoDistractions -- >>The purpose of a speed limit is to make driving safe...<< "I hoped that the national 55-mile per-hour speed limit--already in force--would help reduce gasoline consumption" http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=8017 http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=8017 >>When conditions make 55 unsafe, people need to slow down enough to be safe...<< "California has a 'Basic Speed Law.' This law means that you may never drive faster than is safe for current conditions" http://www.dmv.ca.gov/pubs/hdbk/speed_limits.htm http://www.dmv.ca.gov/pubs/hdbk/speed_limits.htm
- jerf 14y ago"I hoped that the national 55-mile per-hour speed limit--already in force--would help reduce gasoline consumption" That's clearly not the current reason. And more than just California has a law like that. I know Michigan does, I imagine most states do. It does show that somebody at some point understood the purpose. By no means am I saying all laws or bad, or that laws are bad, or even in a way that any particular law is bad; I'm saying people all to frequently conflate the letter of the law with its purpose.
- tptacek 14y agoHigher-speed drivers use more fuel and produce more pollution. That's not a controversial argument. Whether or not it's the "current" reason for the 60-75mph speed limits we have now doesn't seem relevant. The question is, "should we raise the speed limit". If raising it increases the speed at which people drive, then raising it will increase pollution, and thus morbidity.
- tomkarlo 14y agoThe solution isn't "lossy" enforcement, at least in the case of speed limits. It's to revise the speed limit to a higher, more realistic figure and then enforce that limit as rigorously as practical. This is what the UK and other countries are doing with average speed cameras. It's been shown that in some cases US speed limits make roads less safe and are lower than the speed limits recommended by the engineers who designed the roadway. "The design speed for the project was 110 km/h (68 mph). The design speed is like a warranty: nothing in the road design requires a driver to go slower than 68 mph, not even on a wet road at night (the design conditions). The average speed is not far from the design speed. The 85th percentile speed, which is supposed to be used for setting speed limits, is around 75 mph. A little over by my measurement, which found 1% compliance with the speed limit." http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2011/09/be-safe-break-the-law.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2011/09/be-... Having speed limits where a large percentage of drivers regularly violate them teaches people to break the law casually. (Similarly, COPPA basically teaches kids to lie about their age online.)
- Vivtek 14y agoYou appear to be suffering from the notion that there is a single defined value at which the speed limit will be optimum at all times. But I entirely agree with your larger point that violation of arbitrary speed limits because of obvious engineering considerations does train people to break the law casually.
- tomkarlo 14y agoThe quote I posted explicitly points out that the speed limit is based on worst-case road conditions. Obviously a single-value speed limit can't be optimal in all conditions, for all drivers, in all vehicles. It has to be based on what's safe for most vehicles in most conditions, but there is a single optimal value for those constraints on a particular road. I'd have no problem with variable speed limits on roads - I think it would make a lot of sense to have speed limit displays that change based on time of day, weather conditions, etc. But until that's practical, speed limits will be set based on worst-case, with a proviso that drivers ALSO have to exercise discretion and further reduce speed in exceptional conditions like fog or snow.
- orangethirty 14y agoYou are wrong about this part: The purpose of a speed limit is not to make people not go more than 55 miles per hour. The purpose of a speed limit is to make driving safe, and particularly to make driving safe for society, even moreso than for the individual. If everybody is driving at 65 in the 55 zone, but everybody is safe, the higher purpose of the law is being met, and citations for speeding are just punitive for no gain. When conditions make 55 unsafe, people need to slow down enough to be safe, regardless of what the local speed limit is. The 55 MPH speed limit was enforced by congress to reduce the consumption of fuel (gasoline). It has nothing to do with safety.
- schiffern 14y ago>The 55 MPH speed limit was enforced by congress to reduce the consumption of fuel (gasoline). It has nothing to do with safety. The second sentence doesn't follow from the first. I guarantee there were congress-critters for whom the safety justification tipped their vote.
- tptacek 14y agoYou write that like it's crazy. But the data shows that when people drive faster on average, accidents increase.
- orangethirty 14y agoAll I'm stating is that the double dime speed limit was enforced as a measure to reduce fuel consumption. Read this: http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/nixon-signs-national-speed-limit-into-law http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/nixon-signs-natio...
- krichman 14y agoWhat's worse are laws that are basically enacted in reaction to some specific situation but shouldn't be applied or necessary in the general case. Sometimes it seems like the majority of the legal code is archaic if not completely corrupt. I wish there was a way for the public to revoke laws that were ridiculous. Jury nullification? If there is a way they should be teaching it in the schools.