3 ms·
They state that it's impossible to secretly listen in (because that would involve tampering with the data), but then also state that the hub works by converting
by jstanley 14y ago
They state that it's impossible to secretly listen in (because that would involve tampering with the data), but then also state that the hub works by converting to classical bits and then retransmitting.
What prevents an attacker from inserting a device that converts to classical bits before retransmitting?
- RollAHardSix 14y agoExactly. The hub itself must be secure and trustworthy for an entirely 'secure' communication route, this won't work across any plain-jane network due to that weakness.
- ams6110 14y agoThe hub is where the NSA grabs their copy of the key.
- jterce 14y agoI believe the retransmitted quantum packet would be necessarily different from the original. So the receiving node notices that the packet has been modified, but because it expects the (secure) hub to modify the original, all is well.
- jstanley 14y agoBut how can it tell the difference between the hub's modifications and an attacker's modifications?
- querulous 14y agoit can't, that's why you need a trusted hub clients can only tell that the message they received from the hub was actually from the hub and was not observed by anyone but the hub. there's no way to tell a message from client A to client B wasn't tampered with or observed before the hub delivered it
- r00fus 14y agoSo if you're supposed to trust all hops on your message, quantum cryptography has no real appreciable improvement over standard digital communications (where the same problem exists).
- tjoff 14y agoWell, you don't have to worry about anyone hijacking a cable. Rather big improvement there. Although not without cost...