3 ms·
Minor nit: I agree 110% with the article's point about the need to "Prominently feature a '[noun] is' paragraph", but the example they give isn't that great: "
by smacktoward 14y ago
Minor nit: I agree 110% with the article's point about the need to "Prominently feature a '[noun] is' paragraph", but the example they give isn't that great:
"An excellent example of this in action is on libcinder.org where it states right up front: 'Cinder is a community-developed, free and open source library for professional-quality creative coding in C++.' Perfect!"
I'd push back on the assertion that this is perfect. "Library for professional-quality creative coding in C++" is actually a pretty fuzzy, non-descriptive way to describe your project. The only real thing you've learned after reading it is that it's for C++; you don't know anything specific about what it does, just that it's "professional" and "creative."
The Cinder developers actually have a much better one-sentence description at the top of their About page (http://libcinder.org/about/ http://libcinder.org/about/):
"Cinder provides a powerful, intuitive toolbox for programming graphics, audio, video, networking, image processing and computational geometry."
There's still some fluffy words in there ("powerful," "intuitive"), but overall it gives you a much better answer to the question "What is this?" than the tagline cited in the article does.
- petercooper 14y agoThis is a very fair nit to pick! I think the bold presentation of the definition on their homepage (not a particularly common thing to see, alas) may have caused me to give it more favor than it deserves. It's not bad but the other one is certainly better.
- andrewflnr 14y agoMy understanding is that "creative coding" is actually a fairly well-specified term for those "in the know". I had almost exactly the same question and someone straightened me out. I'll try to find the thread. Edit: Ah yes, on an HN post about the very same framework: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3208552 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3208552
- bnferguson 14y agoIn the case of Cinder "creative coding" is in reference to a very specific thing and using that term tells me exactly what sort of library it is. Namely being familiar with other "Creative Coding" frameworks such as OpenFrameworks, Processing, etc I generally know what Cinder is offering and how it's going to approach the problems. The about page description doesn't tell me its approach, just its content and approach is very, very important in these (they almost always follow the same structure). That said, using the "Creative Coding" term makes it all very inside baseball and I totally agree it could be better. openFrameworks falls into the same trap with: "openFrameworks is an open source C++ toolkit for creative coding." Signaling to those who know without telling those who don't. I do feel like Processing does much better with "Processing is an open source programming language and environment for people who want to create images, animations, and interactions" even if it isn't prominent. Then again Processing is the one that pretty much coined this whole "Creative Coding" thing. :)
- mhaymo 14y agoIt's just as well the first sentence was followed by a link to the second. As someone who didn't recognise the term "Creative Coding", I was just one click away from understanding.
- smacktoward 14y agoHmm, interesting. I'm not a C++ jockey myself so I will cheerfully admit the significance of the "creative coding" term flew right over my head.