3 ms·
So lets refine the arguments a bit. I could respond to the mudslinging, but that just get boring to read/write. If I understand you right, then the issues is n
by belorn 14y ago
So lets refine the arguments a bit. I could respond to the mudslinging, but that just get boring to read/write.
If I understand you right, then the issues is not with the service that MegaUpload offered, but with the way that they marketed their services and encouraged new users.
And marketing is important. Where I live (Sweden), we have quite strong laws regulating marketing activities. For one, marketing directed at kids (like games) are strictly unlawful, as it is deemed to have a negative impact on society. Same for advertisement regarding alcohol or tobacco. By the early 2000, they considered if they could enforce the same laws against international cable networks that sold and broadcasted inside Sweden, but decided that such enforcing of Swedish law could not be enforced outside the national border.
- mpyne 14y agoWhat he's saying (I think) is that MegaUpload wasn't simply a service provider. They got their hands dirty and actively participated in paying to "seed" their own service with popular copyright-protected movies, TV shows, etc. IIRC they also paid for data center services hosted within the U.S. to ensure Americans had quick access to those services (including the deliberately-seeded IP-regime media files). You'll note that the Feds aren't going after Google Drive, Youtube, Dropbox, iCloud, whatever Microsoft's cloud offering is called, etc., and yet those services are just as capable of uploading media and hosting it publically.
- forrestthewoods 14y agoMy issue is that I find MegaUpload and Kim Dotcom actions fundamentally immoral. Whether it is or should be illegal is a separate matter. I am continuously surprised by the number of internet users who are typically opposed to his type of behavior, but support his immorality because he helps them get free things.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y ago>support his immorality because he helps them get free things. What a terrible argument. I have to support government thuggery, or else I'm a freeloading terrorist? I've never had a MU account, and I definitely don't look to Kim Dotcom's actions for moral guidance; but, I reckon I support the notion that the DOJ ought to follow the law. If that means that Dotcom gets away with something, well then so be it. Fix the law, don't just ignore it or make it up as you go.
- tptacek 14y agoIt's not "mudslinging". It's spelled out in black-and-white in the company's own emails.
- subsystem 14y agoI would assume the "mudslinging" was in regards to the second paragraph.