3 ms·
Yes, I read what you wrote and disagree with it. I have seen no evidence that the USA can execute on massive projects when it has shown no ability to do it in
by protomyth 14y ago
Yes, I read what you wrote and disagree with it. I have seen no evidence that the USA can execute on massive projects when it has shown no ability to do it in pilot programs. If the VA and IHS don't represent the pilots for this bill then what does? That is one reason there is a fair history in the USA of pilot programs. In the US, small projects are fair predictor of larger success because of a pilot first culture.
No, the cut in Medicare is justified by the saving from fraud detection. Perhaps you are thinking Medicaid?
- knowtheory 14y agoThat is a different argument from your initial assertion. The IHS's failure is not an indication that the us government can't execute on healthcare. Additionally there are plenty of regulatory agencies in the US that do a phenomenal job at what they do even in the face of dire circumstances, the FDIC being a really good example. Literally hundreds of banks went out of business between 2008 and 2010 (see: http://www.fdic.gov/bank/individual/failed/banklist.html http://www.fdic.gov/bank/individual/failed/banklist.html ), and the FDIC unrolled those institutions, found other banks to take over depositor accounts, without any substantial problems. The government can and does work, even if it doesn't always. The question is how can we ensure that government's interface with the healthcare system is one of the systems that does work.
- protomyth 14y ago> That is a different argument from your initial assertion. No, it is the same - the government failed with less people and now is attempting something with almost all. I then added information about how the US government generally goes about social programs (pilot -> nationwide). > The IHS's failure is not an indication that the us government can't execute on healthcare. Yes, it is. As to the rest of your post, I did not and have not argued that the government doesn't do some decent things in other fields. The FDIC unrolls have happened before 2008 and they have a plan for it that worked in the past. Once again, they are attempting a lot of stuff with no previous experience, uncertain regulations (even now), and failure in their two previous large scale programs (IHS and VA). Add to this resistance from states and even doubt casting by Senators and Representatives that voted for it, it has very little hope of working.
- rquantz 14y agoIf the VA and IHS don't represent the pilots for this bill then what does? Medicare? It's hugely popular and keeps prices down despite serving a population that over-utilizes health care.
- protomyth 14y agoIt would have been a good start. Figure out how to get the fraud down and fix the payment / paperwork. Pilot a few different schemes and look at some of the state programs. Cutting the funding was not the most brilliant part of the bill.
- rquantz 14y agoIf you're looking for a specific pilot program for the affordable care act, how about the Massachusetts law? It's not quite as popular as medicare, and it looks like MA residents don't think the law is perfect, but they also seem to prefer it to not having it at all[1]. I don't think anyone who is serious is saying it is a failure. [1] http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2011/may/16/laura-ingraham/laura-ingraham-says-massachusetts-health-plan-wild/ http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2011/may/...
- protomyth 14y agoIt wasn't run by the Federal government and really doesn't have most of the characteristics of the final law. Its a different beast. [edit: can we stop treating PolitiFact as if its not bias - there math handling is spotty at best and their half-truths are also biased]