4 ms·
I really don't get this attitude some Americans have that any kind of public service designed to make the lives of your less fortunate peers just that little bi
by laumars 14y ago
I really don't get this attitude some Americans have that any kind of public service designed to make the lives of your less fortunate peers just that little bit easier is some how a bad thing. It's as if 70 years of brainwashing that all "commies" are evil has irreparably warped their brains and now any piece of legislation that doesn't propose proverbially kicking struggling families in the "nuts" is seen as socialism and, by extension, wrong.
Capitalism is all well and good so long as peoples lives are not put in danger; and I'm not talking about luxuries here, I'm talking about whether people live or die. But what we have happening instead is a closed market dominated by a small number of monopolistic drug companies who abuse patent systems and extort their customers just because they can. Surely at some point, even the right-wings have to appreciate that neither closed markets nor putting peoples lives put in danger because of the greed of the few is neither in the spirit of capitalism nor the Christian thing to do (and I only reference the last part because of the emphasis that many right-wings place on religion).
- TheCowboy 14y agoOne 'good' thing about the Cold War was that it 'put the fear of Communism' in the heart of every Commie-fearing capitalist. We had a moral obligation to be seen as and actually provide a better life than that experienced by those behind the Iron Curtain. We had to pay attention to the negative aspects of market-based economics and at least attempt to mitigate these problems. It also showed people what 'real' communism looked like. It's big joke that people think we're measurably closer to anything resembling socialism. The idea that capitalism itself is a moral end to achieve in and of itself, regardless of the reality, seems to have taken root. People who are left worse off are dismissed as stupid and lazy. As someone with an economics background I'm strongly in favor of markets and capitalism, but it's worrying when people forget that the strength of this way is based upon the health of the economic institutions that enable it to function.
- sageikosa 14y ago> it's worrying when people forget that the strength of this way is based upon the health of the economic institutions that enable it to function. ...which would be markets, correct? There is no free market for welfare.
- TheCowboy 14y agoRight, markets are an institution but not the only one. It's a problem that people forget and think it is only one we need. Economic institutions encompass everything that allow it to function including basic ideas like private property rights, rules and regulations that enforce contracts, and functions that account for the welfare of people.
- sageikosa 14y agoMarkets are what people with diverse motivations and rights to dispose of their property "do" when they wish to dispose of their property (or deliver services) or when they wish to acquire new property or have services performed. The market as a concept isn't something handed down by the gods, nor instituted by decree. I agree that there are other concepts that dispose of people's "property" and require them to seek or deliver services; in the past we called them things like theft, war, and slavery.
- sageikosa 14y ago> I really don't get this attitude some Americans have that any kind of public service designed to make the lives of your less fortunate peers just that little bit easier is some how a bad thing. I think the problem is we like to have the freedom to select our charities (and charitable giving amount) rather than have them forced upon us by statute.
- laumars 14y agoIt's not a charity though. It's about providing a minimum service for people. Even with "free" health care in the UK, it's not free (it's paid for via National Insurance taxes and many facets still have additional costs (prescriptions, regular dressings, dentistry, etc) albeit often highly subsidised. Surely it's better to have a subsidised minimum service than to rely on charities? And more over, if your objection is purely because you don't want to be told that you should look after your fellow Americans, then that's either a really sad representation of how little respect Americans have for their kin, or the facet of a childish mentality where kids deliberately disobey their parents because they like to test their boundaries. Either way, it's just a terrible attitude to have.
- HarryHirsch 14y ago> Surely it's better to have a subsidised minimum service than to rely on charities? See, it depends on who you are. If you are a well-connected member of the political class you prever to give charity because it's you who directs the flow of money. If you are part of the unwashed masses you prefer a subsidy, because there is the democratic process involved, and experts in public policy and the general public might have influence what is done with the funds.
- sageikosa 14y ago> Surely it's better to have a subsidised minimum service than to rely on charities? No. Charities have to maintain efficiency because they are not subsidized, if they want to continue to operate they need to prove to contributors that their contribution is going to the cause to the extent that a market critical mass of contributors cares to know. > if your objection is purely because you don't want to be told that you should look after your fellow Americans, then that's either a really sad representation of how little respect Americans have for their kin, or the facet of a childish mentality where kids deliberately disobey their parents because they like to test their boundaries. Either way, it's just a terrible attitude to have. Effigies should only be burned in street protests when there are teeming masses to rile up. They are less effective in print.
- MetaCosm 14y agoThe lack of consistency is what gets me. - You have the RIGHT to education in the United States. - You do NOT have the RIGHT to be alive to be educated. * Additionally, you MUST treat someone in the ER if they are dying, but if they will be dying a week from now, send them on their way. That is one thing I give to hardcore libertarians, they seem monstrous at times (no public schools, let sick people without insurance die, can't afford food then starve, etc) --- but at least they are consistent and honest. Also, they will claim that private companies / charities will stop this horrible stuff from happening.
- cookiecaper 14y ago>(no public schools, let sick people without insurance die, can't afford food then starve, etc) Just want to emphasize (I see your little tacked-on afterthought there) that just because a libertarian doesn't believe the money to do these things should be forcibly extracted from the taxpayer's pocket doesn't mean that they believe people should be left to die. They simply trust non-governmental entities to capably care for their fellow men. It's about the proper role of government, not Darwinism. As an example, consider Social Security. The government told us that they needed to save our money for us, since we were too stupid to do it ourselves. And now they've spent it all. lol?