6 ms·
Maybe it’s because I’m a Brit, and we have the national health service. Every man, woman and child in the UK is entitled to free healthcare from cradle to grave
by jgrahamc 14y ago
Maybe it’s because I’m a Brit, and we have the national health service. Every man, woman and child in the UK is entitled to free healthcare from cradle to grave. [...] America is a bigger country so free healthcare is off the table. I get that.
I don't understand this argument at all. The NHS in the UK doesn't appear magically free from the sky because we've only got 60 million people. We pay for it through general taxation. This year it will cost about £110B.
Is it really the case that there's an argument that this can't work in the US because there are more people?
- TruthElixirX 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem The federal government can't control healthcare because of this. It would probably work better on a state level (See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_health_care_reform http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_health_care_refor...). On top of that I don't think the U.S. economy can handle another massive government program on top of existing ones. I am mostly referring to the wars over seas. No other country spends so much on military. The U.S. spends a ton of money on military (and locking people up for drugs). If the U.S. stopped those two things I think healthcare will be fine, but it won't. So more shit is just being added to an already inefficient and corrupt government. Then there is the problem of people deciding that since they pay for your healthcare, they should be telling you how to live. There will be more bands on sugary drinks like in New York (though that was struck down). Or what extreme sports you can play, etc. That really bothers me because it will mean more shit that people aren't allowed to do that only harms themselves.
- m0th87 14y agoWe can discuss Austrian economics until the cows come home, but in the mean time, the US spends nearly twice as much as the UK on healthcare (as a percent of GDP) [1] and 45,000 Americans die every year due to lack of coverage [2]. I'm glad reform is happening. I wish it were more aggressive. 1: http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/2012/10/health-costs-how-the-us-compares-with-other-countries.html http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/2012/10/health-costs-how... 2: http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2009/09/new-study-finds-45000-deaths-annually-linked-to-lack-of-health-coverage/ http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2009/09/new-study-find...
- dantheman 14y agoI'd prefer reform that removed the current structural inefficiencies instead of piling more on. Reform doesn't necessarily mean more government involvement.
- TruthElixirX 14y agoThe U.S. government also spends more on healthcare per capita than Canada [1]. Seems pretty socialized to me already. The U.S. government is a corrupt piece of shit. Passing laws mandating health insurance for everyone isn't going to fix things. [1] http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/01/23/chart_us_government_spends_more_on_health_care_than_the_canadian_government.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/01/23/chart_us_gove... EDIT:: Furthermore, diseconomies of scale are not just Austrian Economics voodoo.[2] [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diseconomies_of_scale http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diseconomies_of_scale
- m0th87 14y agoThat chart is admittedly pretty terrifying. But the article itself argues the big reason is because Canada's nationalized healthcare plan has more leverage and price control capabilities than US Medicare. That seems more reasonable than simply attributing it to corruption.
- glenra 14y ago> 45,000 Americans die every year due to lack of coverage Sorry, no. That claim is often made, but it's just nonsense. Every time we've had a BETTER sort of study - had the chance to examine a situation in which people are randomly assigned to either have low-deductible health coverage or not have it - there has been no significant health benefit to having the "better" health coverage. The first such study was the RAND study in the 1970s. The most recent one was the Oregon study described here: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/05/01/shocker-oregon-health-study-shows-no-significant-health-impacts-from-joining-medicaid.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/05/01/shocker-ore... Quote: "a large-scale randomized controlled trial (RCT) of what happens to people when they gain Medicaid eligibility shows no impact on objective measures of health. Utilization went up, out-of-pocket expenditure went down, and the freqency of depression diagnoses was lower. But on the three important health measures they checked that we can measure objectively--glycated hemoglobin, a measure of blood sugar levels; blood pressure; and cholesterol levels--there was no significant improvement." Good followup analysis here: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/05/03/how-the-oregon-study-should-change-our-thinking.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/05/03/how-the-ore...
- ryguytilidie 14y agoI'd actually be quite interested to see polling data on this. I wonder if, given the choice, most Americans would choose to continue funding wars/national security or fund healthcare for all. I would actually imagine wars would win in a landslide unfortunately.
- Vivtek 14y agoNo. Of course not. We have one person here per capita, just like the UK. If anything we'd get more economies of scale. But it would be socialism, and therefore inherently antithetical to the desires of every right-thinking American.
- protomyth 14y agoSince we cannot even fund IHS for a full year at a time with significantly less people than the entire US population, I think you might want to look at what the actual funding versus cost would be. http://richheape.com/american-indian-healthcare.htm http://richheape.com/american-indian-healthcare.htm
- knowtheory 14y agoSeems like a non-sequitur? The problem with the way that Native Americans are treated in the US is a lack of political will and the totally fucked power dynamic between the political institutions that have (or have not really) developed in the shadow of Western dominance of the continent. Canada has universal healthcare and health outcomes for the First Nations are poorer there too. It's really not an apples to apples comparison, since there's so much other fraught bullshit involved.
- protomyth 14y agoSo, who exactly is going to protect the small business owner or the poor soul who now has to work two jobs each under 20 hours? The point stands, if we in the USA cannot get it right for IHS or VA, then we won't get it right for the majority. If you cannot do the little things, don't expect to do the big things. The act (which I am sure the author has not read) has already cost people insurance and failed at reducing costs for everyone else. It cut medicare money (read the act), and reduced the effectiveness of the non-employer health saving funds. We are more dependent on employers, not less. It bungled the wording of the exchanges to screw up the tax benefits (perhaps public review would have helped this point). I await the report that the fraud prevention in the act hasn't resulted in the required savings.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- dasil003 14y agoThere's no real argument, but he had to say that in order to not be sidelined as an extremist. I know it sounds insane, but the average American's idea of nationalized healthcare is something akin to waiting in Soviet Union breadlines just to get an aspirin. There's a whole cadre of talking heads employed full-time to make the rounds on Fox News et al promoting this sort of willfully ignorant line of thought.
- dantheman 14y agoThere are lots of reasons to be against nationalized healthcare. Some for practical reasons, others for legal reasons -- just because you want something doesn't mean it can skip the legal process which is what obamacare tries to do in a lot of places. One simple reason to be against it is that the current implementation is crazy bad and has no way of dealing with costs and is anti-democratic. It creates outside bodies that don't answer to congress, etc.
- m0th87 14y agoCitations needed. The primary argument used against ACA's constitutionality was struck down by the supreme court [1]. And there already exists at least 50 government agencies that reserve the right to pass regulations without congressional approval [2]. 1: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/06/28/supreme-court-affordable-care-act_n_1623122.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/06/28/supreme-court-affor... 2: http://usgovinfo.about.com/od/uscongress/a/fedregulations.htm http://usgovinfo.about.com/od/uscongress/a/fedregulations.ht...
- dantheman 14y agoUnfortunately I couldn't find a great text example but here are two sources on: IPAB More recent: http://www.cato.org/multimedia/media-highlights-tv/cato-institute-event-evaluating-dodd-franks-cfpb-ola-provisions http://www.cato.org/multimedia/media-highlights-tv/cato-inst... From one year ago (shorter ~ 7 minutes): http://www.cato.org/multimedia/daily-podcast/ipab-obamacareas-next-constitutional-hurdle http://www.cato.org/multimedia/daily-podcast/ipab-obamacarea...
- eterm 14y agoHealth costs per capita are actually lower in the uk than the us, even after paying for all the treatment. The problem is that pur current government are privatising the actual provision of care away from the NHS. Large chunks are already privatised and much more will follow. We're heading to a situation where the NHS will be more like an insurer picking up the tab.
- glenra 14y ago> Is it really the case that there's an argument that this can't work in the US because there are more people? The simplest such argument would be that there are diseconomies of scale - it's conceivable that the bigger you make a bureaucracy the less responsive/effective/efficient it gets. That certainly could be true - whether it actually is is an empirical question. Another possibility is that our federal system is ill-suited to the task. There's nothing really preventing individual US states from providing such services. And if most states haven't done so thus far - and in the few that have tried, it hasn't worked out very well - there might be reasons for that which we should try to understand.
- nijk 14y agoInterstate immigration guarantees is a factor against single-statd healthcare.
- glenra 14y agoMany individual US states are larger than individual European countries. People can immigrate within the EU, can they not? So why defend the UK or Denmark having its own system? On the other hand, it could easily be argued that interstate commerce restrictions are a big part of the problem in the US. Suppose some company in Delaware comes up with a really cheap health insurance plan that meets my exact needs - I can't sign up for it, because I don't live in Delaware. For a company to offer health insurance or health care nationwide it has to have offices in 50 states and navigate regulatory restrictions in 50 states. If McDonald's wants to expand to serve people in other states, they can just DO it, but Kaiser or Blue Cross can't do the same. That situation is ridiculous and needs to be fixed somehow, but I don't hold out much hope for it changing any time soon.