8 ms·
I don’t understand American healthcare – doesn’t mean I shouldn’t provide it
- jaibot 14y agoOne important takeaway from this piece is that putting employers in charge of providing health insurance is a terrible idea. Paul Carr shouldn't need to _make an effort_ to make sure his employees have basic health protections - that should be a solved problem.
- walshemj 14y agoyes unfortunately back in the 50's the big auto companies did a deal to include healthcare as part of wage negotiations. Which derailed the USA's progression to a German style model of healthcare. If you talk to Alan Mulally and any on the AFL-CIO off the record they would agree - that in hind sight it was a bad deal both for the workers and the employers.
- claudius 14y ago> German style model of healthcare. Which has the curious drawback that those most able to contribute to it (i.e. those earning more than X €/month) are allowed to opt-out of it. I never quite understood why this would have to be the case, and the various attempts to introduce an actual public health insurance system failed so far.
- jgrahamc 14y agoMaybe it’s because I’m a Brit, and we have the national health service. Every man, woman and child in the UK is entitled to free healthcare from cradle to grave. [...] America is a bigger country so free healthcare is off the table. I get that. I don't understand this argument at all. The NHS in the UK doesn't appear magically free from the sky because we've only got 60 million people. We pay for it through general taxation. This year it will cost about £110B. Is it really the case that there's an argument that this can't work in the US because there are more people?
- TruthElixirX 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem The federal government can't control healthcare because of this. It would probably work better on a state level (See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_health_care_reform http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_health_care_refor...). On top of that I don't think the U.S. economy can handle another massive government program on top of existing ones. I am mostly referring to the wars over seas. No other country spends so much on military. The U.S. spends a ton of money on military (and locking people up for drugs). If the U.S. stopped those two things I think healthcare will be fine, but it won't. So more shit is just being added to an already inefficient and corrupt government. Then there is the problem of people deciding that since they pay for your healthcare, they should be telling you how to live. There will be more bands on sugary drinks like in New York (though that was struck down). Or what extreme sports you can play, etc. That really bothers me because it will mean more shit that people aren't allowed to do that only harms themselves.
- m0th87 14y agoWe can discuss Austrian economics until the cows come home, but in the mean time, the US spends nearly twice as much as the UK on healthcare (as a percent of GDP) [1] and 45,000 Americans die every year due to lack of coverage [2]. I'm glad reform is happening. I wish it were more aggressive. 1: http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/2012/10/health-costs-how-the-us-compares-with-other-countries.html http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/2012/10/health-costs-how... 2: http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2009/09/new-study-finds-45000-deaths-annually-linked-to-lack-of-health-coverage/ http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2009/09/new-study-find...
- dantheman 14y agoI'd prefer reform that removed the current structural inefficiencies instead of piling more on. Reform doesn't necessarily mean more government involvement.
- TruthElixirX 14y ago
- yoster 14y agoThe problem with the states on health insurance is that unless you are part of the 1%, you need it. Healthcare industries are huge corporations that are in it for the almighty dollar. If you go to the emergency room and do not have health insurance, you can bet you will have a bill that will run a couple grand minimum. I wish we were like other countries where we can have a national healthcare system. This is one of the most basic human needs that should be available to everyone. I am very thankful that my company offers an excellent healthcare plan, and I think everyone should have access to a healthcare plan.
- m0th87 14y agoI don't understand why he's playing himself up so much for providing healthcare to employees. Of the 3 startups I've worked at, 2 provided healthcare and 1 provided a healthy allowance toward private coverage. All of them I suspect were smaller than NSFWCORP. I thought this was the default, even for startups. If it's not, it should be.
- kenjackson 14y agoI don't think he's playing himself up so much as he is presenting a struggle of whether or not to provide it and the realization that he must (not from a legal, but from a moral perspective). And while it may be common in the tech industry (where VC money can make it easier -- and frankly its hard to recruit w/o it), it's less common outside of the tech industry. I still think it is odd to tie health insurance to employment, but given that this is the case today, I do think that I'd do the same as a small business owner. If I couldn't afford it (at least by the medium-term), I think I'd have to question the feasibility of my business.
- kmfrk 14y agoJust as soon as yesterday, I read about a guy on Something Awful who had a stroke and no employer-provided healthcare. Maybe if you only assume the audience to be a very narrow demographic, you could be right statistically, but this is an issue that extends far beyond just the Valley, Alley, etc.
- mgkimsal 14y agoEmployer-provided health insurance is one of the worst things to emerge from the US in the past... what? 70 years? It gives far too much power in the marketplace to employers and very little to the actual users of the insurance - the insured. Why don't employers provide auto insurance too? They'd get a much better deal via group rates, and we'd be 'better off' because we'd all 'pay less' for auto insurance, right? The idea of 'benefits' in general being 'expected' from employers is, in itself, a bit crazy - just pay people well, and let them make their own decisions. I'd have thought 'free market' supporters would be all over that concept. Company 401K plans? Generally limit you to high-fee and substandard mutual fund options. Company health insurance plans? One or two options, not something which always fit people very well. Employer funds in to an employee-controlled HSA was/is a decent middle ground, but HSAs in general seem like they're going to be going away or more limited in availability in the next few years under the Affordable Care Act, which is a real shame.
- jmspring 14y agoWhile I agree that benefits tied to employment, rather than the individual, is a very big problem, it is also the only economical path currently for medical insurance. Scale and contracts that a company can negotiate aren't there for individuals. Every year for the last decade, you hear about insurance companies raising individual and small business rates. For profit companies managing what ostensibly a shared risk pool is another bone of contention for me. I can't find the actual reference at the moment (typing on iPhone) but legislation has been put in place requiring minimum percentages of premiums that must be spent on coverage rather than "overhead". Also, a minor nit, not all companies offer up bad 401k plans. As an early employee at a couple of startups, I've helped hr pick the better options given rather than the first one peddled.
- mgkimsal 14y agoThis is a social and financial engineering problem - change the tax structure to encourage people to get private insurance. Make the cost of private insurance 150% deductible for one year, then 140% deductible the second year, etc. for 5 years to encourage more people to do it. As more people have private insurance vs employer provided, the market economics would shift. Sure, not all companies offer bad 401k plans. Enough do that it's not something that we should continue to encourage though - pay people more and let them make their own decisions. That money for 'benefits' isn't freely coming from nowhere - it's the cost of employing you, and it could just as easily go in to your pocket vs the pockets of plan administrators that you didn't get to choose.
- antidaily 14y agoIve done a bit of research on the subject, and it seems like if you do want to offer your employees insurance and you're a biz or startup of less than 25 people, it's going to be cheaper and better incentivized than it used to be.
- bmelton 14y agoColor me critical, but it seems like, basically, the point of this article was to show off exactly how informed in her 'hard-nosed' critiques, and how that is proffered as justification for the obvious bias present in the article. I also find it interesting that despite the apparent mountains of reading, the author cannot determine any good reason why one might oppose the Affordable Care Act, which tells me that either her bias refused to allow her to accept posed oppositions as valid, or that she simply doesn't care that other people do object. I think there are plenty of valid reasons for opposing it, just as there are plenty of reasons to support it, and frankly, I think all of major justifications on either side of the argument fall into the category of fairly obvious. That said, kudos on choosing to provide health care immediately. It is a tough decision, and it will affect the company's bottom line, but despite that, if you're an employer who believes that everybody should have affordable health care, it is the obviously correct choice.
- onli 14y agoThat was one of his points: There are no good reasons to be against the Act. I can't really judge if that is true, but basically, the idea that it is absolutely right to try to get as many people as possible insured is pretty powerful. And most of the opposition one noted was on the level of "that is socialism!" (which it isnt, and socialism isn't bad).
- niggler 14y agoThere are many americans working at medical device companies that will be affected by the 2.3% medical device tax. Zimmer, for example, cited the medical device tax as the reason for firing a thousand workers a few years ago.
- onli 14y agoI don't know that case. Normally, such claims are a lie (using an opportunity to reorganise the company to exploit the workers more) and it seems highly unlikely that 2,3% on anything could lead to that. So the margin before was that thin that the tax lead to thousand workers being more expensive than productive? That is highly unlikey, especially with medical device companies. And besides, it doesn't invalidate the ethical point that it is right to privide medical insurance, even if true.
- mgkimsal 14y agoGiven the US Constitution's "general welfare" clause, I'm not sure why nation health care options are such a hard thing to get passed and put in to place. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Welfare_clause#United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Welfare_clause#United_S...
- oellegaard 14y agoIn Denmark we have completely free medical treatment - I used to live in Switzerland where they have a system where you have to get a health insurance. I had to visit the doctor once to remove some stitches I got from an accident while travelling. The first thing they asked for when I arrived at my doctor was for me to fill out an insurance form - before that they didn't even ask what kind of medical treatment I would need. I have never felt more offended. I consider it a human right to have access to health care. Why would the state not provide this? Everyone needs it, you can't live without it.
- ryguytilidie 14y agoIts pretty hilarious in America. I was in the ER a few months back and I was literally laying on a gurney wincing in pain while the attending nurse gave me an insurance form to fill out. Can someone come up with another example of an industry where such absolute rock bottom service is tolerated as healthcare?
- johnnyb9 14y agoIf you are really interested in learning why some people think universal health care is not a "right" I encourage you to read this article: http://www.aynrand.org/site/News2?id=13873 http://www.aynrand.org/site/News2?id=13873
- arethuza 14y ago"The American rights impose no obligations on other people" What about the right to a fair trial by a jury?
- summerdown2 14y agoClearly this is nonsense: > Your right to anything at others' expense means that they become rightless. So let me understand this argument ... my right to anything at all removes all other rights from others? Because the UK has universal healthcare, its people have no rights? I suggest that the truth is not that exercise of one right diminishes all others 100%, but by some fractional percent. And that life, liberty and happiness are best served by a mixture of rights and liberty, not an extreme in one direction.
- wsc981 14y agoI think an important consideration could be freedom of the employee to spend the money he thinks is best. I think that point of view is part of US culture, but not very much of culture in Western Europe. I understand the writer of the article is from the UK and as such might not understand this point of view. The so-called social healthcare as pushed by the government will inherently waste a lot of money because government is always wasteful with it's resources. Governments are wasteful because whenever they run out of money they have the option to tax people more. On the other hand companies that waste a lot of money will eventually be removed from the marketplace, as they are unhealthy. This is one reason why healthcare as a government responsibility might be a bad idea, because whenever money is badly used in healthcare, instead of fixing the actual issue the government is more likely to just tax people more. I think many opponents of social healthcare feel it should be an employees responsibility to spend the money as they think is best. If they want to spend a bigger part of their earnings on healthcare, they should be able to and if they want to spend nothing at all they should be able to as well. Proponents of social healthcare will argue that some people don't know how to spend their money wisely and as such they will find it's a task of the government to make sure a part of the earnings will be forcibly spend on healthcare. It should be understood that this will inherently remove some (financial) freedom of the employees and perhaps from the employers as well. Here in the Netherlands social healthcare is financially becoming more and more expensive. One big issue is that people who are forced to spend part of the earnings right now won't be sure they will actually see any of it back in 30+ years when they grow old enough to need healthcare themselves due to our society having more and more ageing population and less young people to support the healthcare for this ageing population. We've pretty much got the same issue with our socialised pension plans. If young people would be able to save some earnings for their own healthcare, they could have a better guarantee being actually able to use it when they grow older. The book "The Road to Serfdom" by F.A. Hayek explains why many socialist measures (even with the best of intentions) often risk pushing government into the same dangerous direction that Russia and Germany went in the past: http://www.tiptopwebsite.com/custommusic2/mrsilber2.pdf http://www.tiptopwebsite.com/custommusic2/mrsilber2.pdf
- drusenko 14y agoThe real issue is that uninsured people are an externality to society. If we actually let people choose to not buy insurance and deal with those consequences, that would be fine. But as a civilized society, we don't find it acceptable to let people die for preventable reasons, so society ends up footing the bill for that person. Either we need to let those who can afford it and choose not to purchase insurance die of pneumonia if they can't afford the treatment, or everyone needs to buy health insurance if they expect to be treated for life-threatening conditions. It's not a matter of "spend your money how you see fit". It's "you choose not to buy health insurance and we pay for it anyway", which is patently unfair on the rest of us.
- michaelpinto 14y agoI think I've lost count of the number of time on Hacker News (and else where) that I read about a founder that got sick and didn't have health insurance. So on top of a life threatening illness one has to worry about paying for it all. And as one who does pay for health insurance it now costs me the sum of a very good used used car every year. Given this situation I'm frankly amazed that every business leader in this country isn't calling for socialized medicine at this point in time. At this point I see the insurance companies and the surrounding ecosystem as something that hurts us in a global economy.
- jusben1369 14y agoRunning a startup I've gone through this exact same thought process. My high level bullet points are: 1) It's insane that any business should spend so many cycles on managing this. I would have thought Republicans (pro business) might be more open to a state role in healthcare precisely so business's don't have to manage this burden. 2) Somebody who is 35 or 40 with children fully burdened is around $1200 a month or $14,000 per year. Someone who is 25 and single is $200. You think that differential never goes through our minds when assessing candidate and how much we'll pay them? That totally sucks but is a reality. 3) The wealthiest and most likely to vote Americans get their health insurance via their company. So they're entirely immune to the dysfunctional system. If ALL Americans were procuring health insurance in the private marketplace there'd be a much better system. Much less abuse. If the government (like EU/AUS) was the sole customer there would be a much better system. It's this mixture of employers, too small in aggregate to manage the demand side, + smaller individuals buying it on their own, that drives the spiraling costs here. 4) Having a startup provide your health insurance is really dumb. Startups have a much higher % chance of closing their doors. So one day you get laid off because your startup doesn't make it. Guess what, now you have to go and find a new job AND work out what you're COBRA options are. In the broader context, most people who get laid off in the US lose their job AND now have a $1000 or more (if they're family provider) costs layered on as they now have to start paying for healthcare. Like losing a war you didn't start then being forced to pay repatriation costs when your economy is at its weakest. Politically, I think we're more likely to get universal healthcare via the state through than to ever get all employers to stop offering it and put everyone into the marketplace. So I support these efforts because the current blend is the worst. (PS right now we're paying full costs because we lean toward hiring more mature people (read families) who understand what it would cost them in the marketplace to get it so they can balance it against their overall lowered financial compensation.)
- wnight 14y agoThrow in on-site daycare and you'll have a very attractive deal. Did you find insurance that the employees can keep at the same rate even if the company folds or they're terminated? I heard someone talking about your problem #4 and how they'd helped a bit by at least keeping anyone from having ballooning costs.
- sultezdukes 14y agoWhat I don’t get is why anyone would oppose a bill that makes affordable healthcare accessible to more people. Ignoring the philosophical debate for the time being (something as a non-American, he at least tries to understand), his premise seems to be that Obamacare makes affordable healthcare accessible to more people. That (along with the philosophical debate) is the argument.
- guylhem 14y ago"This level of diligence is why when I state something on the record, I’m always — always — right." Warning sign #1 "If there’s anything I can do to protect the health of my employees and their families, shouldn’t I just close the fucking spreadsheet and do it?" Asking to use emotion instead of reason - check "And — fuck you, Papa John" Insult or ad-hominem - check "I’m going to have to work even harder to raise more money" Call for self sacrifice. We're done there. This is at best a populist opinion, and NOT a reasonable analysis, as per the author own suggestion to use emotions instead of reason. Also, when someone tells you about 100% accuracy, think about Dunning–Kruger cognitive biais. "If I made the wrong business decision, I’m an idiot but fewer people will get sick. If I made the right decision, I’m a genius and fewer people will get sick" Hey genius - that's assuming the medical care paid for will have a significant effect. Modern medicine treat all kind of things, but for some we've just not found the right answer yet. And I sleep quite well.
- cpdean 14y agoBut... don't you wanna buy like eighteen subscriptions to his startup so he can feed is surrogate family of employees?
- hype7 14y agoThank god someone else pointed that out. I stopped reading at your first warning sign — any doubt I had about Nicholas Carr being a complete dick just went up in a puff of smoke
- mcculley 14y agoIt's only a debate for organizations that are trying to minimize costs where quality does not matter. See the concurrent discussions about full-time employment becoming rarer for service industry jobs. If your organization is trying to get and keep the best people and keep them productive, there is no debate. Provide health care and health insurance. I don't understand how a venture capital backed organization could be confused about this, as they should be going after huge value adds with fewer employees instead of grinding out low margin labor.
- cpdean 14y agohttp://www.reasonwell.com/:06d4d5/The_Patient_Protection_and_Affordable_Care_Act_is_good_for_the_people_of_the_USA http://www.reasonwell.com/:06d4d5/The_Patient_Protection_and... I have no idea.