6 ms·
Difference Engine: Luddite legacy
- cinquemb 14y agoIt's interesting to see articles like these and the comments to them focusing entirely on the "software eating the world" and never discuss in as much detail that people make the machines/software. Reminds me of the debate between Thiel and Andreessen posted on here recently…
- irickt 14y agoIn Tech We Trust? A Debate with Peter Thiel and Marc Andreessen [video] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5641799 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5641799
- irickt 14y agoDirect link: http://www.economist.com/blogs/babbage/2011/11/artificial-intelligence http://www.economist.com/blogs/babbage/2011/11/artificial-in...
- Vivtek 14y agoHey, I do believe there's an elephant in this room!
- mark_l_watson 14y agoI posted this article because it touches on a subject that my friends and I were talking about on a hike last week: how does society handle a world where production is so very efficient that relatively few people need to work to meet the basic necessities of the world's population. Some of my hiking friends didn't like my solution: a broad socialist style safety net to cover only basic needs with (probably) stiff competition for the fewer jobs, assuming that most people would want as good of a lifestyle as possible for their families. A good job == money for travel and richer experiences. I see such a future world as an exciting place!
- marknutter 14y agoThe system you propose does not account for shifting expectations. Try getting everybody to agree on what "basic needs" are and you are going to pull your hair out in the process. Once people get used to receiving wealth for free, they will look at those who have more and demand that they be brought up to the same level; slowly but surely. For instance, who are you to say that basic needs don't include travel and rich experiences? There will always have to be some percentage of the population that works in order to keep all these machines programmed and maintained, and you don't want those people to be enslaved by the masses. Everyone should be required to work for what they need, but thanks to automation the amount of time people need to spend working to afford the stuff they need is a lot lower than it used to be.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y ago>Once people get used to receiving wealth for free, they will look at those who have more and demand that they be brought up to the same level Or so you assume. >Everyone should be required to work for what they need, Why? And how would you enforce that if the production of everyone's needs (at some level => subsistence) was so mechanized that there just wasn't enough actual work to go around?
- AYBABTME 14y agoWhen I think about those kind of things, I see a future à la Star Trek, where there is no need for money, where humanity is only driven by it's curiosity and thirst for knowledge.
- illuminate 14y agoI'd love that (and even some far-end conservative/capitalist relatives agree) but I always see greed and power as motives where curiosity and thirst are not present.
- varjag 14y agoExcept there would be no practical need for human intervention for space exploration either.. it was automated long before many other industries down on the Earth.
- gte910h 14y agoBasic income does seem to work as a solution to this; also gets rid of the need for minimum wage statutes. Any other schemes?
- Eyght 14y agoI'd be very surprised if we didn't start to hear calls for a tax on the robots.
- tg3 14y agoproperty tax would be reasonable - income tax would be ludicrous.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y ago>income tax would be ludicrous. But why? Income tax is supposed to support the infrastructure needed to maintain and protect all of our great stuff. The fact that robots did all the work doesn't negate the need for roads and wars and bank bailouts. I wonder, if we still had slavery, would slave owners be required to pay income tax for the income generated by their slaves?
- gte910h 14y agoHigh national property taxes may be the key trick to handle the concentrations of wealth
- marshray 14y agoThe government is way ahead of you. Capital equipment is already taxed for businesses. I believe this can count for pure software systems as well.
- gte910h 14y agoThat would just drive the goods out of country, no?
- marknutter 14y agoWho determines what the basic income should be and how exactly do they do it?
- eksith 14y agoIs it just me, or does that robot in the graphic look very similar to the ones in the Björk video "All is Full of Love"?
- ChuckMcM 14y agoSo this is from 2011 and this is the thesis paragraph: "But here is the question: if the pace of technological progress is accelerating faster than ever, as all the evidence indicates it is, why has unemployment remained so stubbornly high—despite the rebound in business profits to record levels? Two-and-a-half years after the Great Recession officially ended, unemployment has remained above 9% in America. That is only one percentage point better than the country's joblessness three years ago at the depths of the recession." Unemployment has dropped a couple of points since then, but the answer to the question was this, "Is it over or isn't it?" And by "it" we mean the Recession. As far as I can tell the American economy has run in an unsustainable over utilized state for the last few years. People who had jobs so afraid of losing them that they do anything to keep them, employers so burned by the Great Recession they operate understaffed rather than risk putting precious capital at risk. That is an unsustainable point, workers burn out and businesses leave money on the table because they aren't at full production. What we've seen is that as the job market started opening up there has been a lot of movement, and relaxation on the part of workers such that business is required to hire to keep productivity high. Much more along more 'normal' patterns than we've had over the last 5 years. The lesson for me was that great spasms in the economy result in a lot of irrational behavior (from a market perspective not an individual perspective) which takes a while to work out. The next interesting lesson will be see what the US government learns from these forced budget cuts. Which, if you recall, had everyone gnashing their teeth about how it was going to put the economy back on the skids. All in all it points out why economics is a great source of questions and a lousy source of answers :-)
- danbruc 14y agoI don't follow the argumentation that the Luddite Fallacy was wrong and is becoming true - I would say it was always true but the effect was just overcompensated by other effects now declining in importance. Further I think the negative tone is not justified; I think a world without labor is a desirable world. That's also why I think all statements along the line »we have to create more jobs (in the sense of more work)« are ridiculous - why on earth would we desire to have more work to do? The final state - a world without labor where everything is produced by machines - poses no direct problems; all goods are free and everybody is free to do what ever he desires. (There will probably be some indirect problems when billions of people are on holiday everyday, resource constraints, one must probably ensure that no one starts to hoard all kinds of goods reducing the supply for others and surly a thousand things I don't think about but this is probably all manageable.) The real challenge is the change from status quo. The first jobs ceasing to exist or beginning to be unprofitable are naturally the ones comprising of mostly unskilled work and than expanding towards higher and higher required skills. This in turn split the society in two groups - one group still working and one group no longer working or doing unprofitable work. This on its own is not a problem but it is a major problem in connection with the way our society currently works. The economy does not only produce goods to satisfy the demand of the population but although permits laborers to consume these goods by paying them. Consequently we have to either find a way to detangle these both responsibilities of the economy or ensure that all people are able to do a fair share of the remaining work (this is more jobs in the sense of splitting work fairly). The later option is probably the one that is harder to implement because the remaining work will require higher and higher skills and therefore more and more people will not able to do any of this work successfully.
- schiffern 14y ago>all goods are free Making all goods very inexpensive (necessities for pennies/day) solves the problems of "free". Of course it's also a very dangerous idea, because it's so similar to the present system that it invites one to change it. Here's a small exercise: 1. Choose a product (potatos, t-shirts, rockets, diamonds, *anything*). 2. Imagine you pay modern prices for it, but made in a totally automated factory. 3. Using your knowledge of business, ask yourself: When that money eventually reaches a person, who is it? Who ultimately gets your consumer dollar? The person who installed the solar panels? Mined the ore? Ponied up the capital? Built the building? Ran the company? 4. You haven't fully thought out the implications of the AI economy. Automate that person's job and repeat. Every iteration of this loop is a business opportunity. Contrast this with the "free" economy (à la Roddenberry's 'Star Trek'), which is non-threatening because there's no clear plan of action from here to there.
- skylan_q 14y agoThe original Henry Ford, committed to raising productivity and lowering prices remorselessly, appreciated this profoundly—and insisted on paying his workers twice the going rate, so they could afford to buy his cars. When will this myth die? He paid double so that he could retain employees because turnover was costing him too much. It's mathematically impossible to pay your employees and expect them to be the the purchasers of your product while remaining profitable.
- danbruc 14y agoIt is only impossible if only your employees are your customers - this was obviously never the case.
- skylan_q 14y agoI'd hope that most people could see through this. My issue is that the Ford myth is often postulated this way. People fear going through the simple arithmetic demonstrating the impossibility of the proposition. It's easier to spread a rumor than it is to correct it... :(
- anthuswilliams 14y agoWhat are you talking about? If other people are buying his cars, he will still make less money paying his employees to buy his cars than he would have otherwise.
- davidf18 14y agoKurt Vonnegut wrote about this in his 1952 novel, "Player Piano" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Player_Piano_(novel) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Player_Piano_(novel) which I read as a child. GB Shaw: "All professions are conspiracies against the laity." The examples given, lawyer and radiologist, achieve high income largely through artificially induced market scarcity by limiting entrants into these professions. Abraham Lincoln, one of the nation's greatest lawyers, never went to undergrad school, never went to law school. Today, in the US, to be a lawyer one has to attend 7 years of post-high school education (in Europe and Israel it is 3 years) at a cost of about $500,000 if attending private schools. For doing image recognition on mammograms, one has to attend 4 years of difficult pre-med, 4 years of difficult med school, 5 years of a hard to get into (eg artificial scarcity) radiology residency, and perhaps 2 years mammogram fellowship. Does it really take 13 or 15 years of post-high school education and training to be able to do image recognition of mammograms? In addition, there is a great deal of variation in results of radiology readings which machines will help to make more uniform.
- willholloway 14y agoA basic minimum income might be better understood and accepted if thought of as a dividend payment on the publicly owned or taxed capital of society. We need only look at the wealthy to see what life is like when you don't have to work for a living. The change need not be scary. When the threshold from scarcity to abundance is crossed by the automated AI economy it will be as if every human was suddenly independently wealthy.