3 ms·
Direct payments on this scale don't solve the problem of rentiers that are able to extort the poor. Someone still has the power to directly hand out the cash, a
by notahacker 14y ago
Direct payments on this scale don't solve the problem of rentiers that are able to extort the poor. Someone still has the power to directly hand out the cash, and record who has and hasn't received it. Someone still has the ability to dupe villagers into believing the cash payments are contingent upon his goodwill. And somebody still wields enough economic or social power over the villagers to direct most of the returns into his own pocket.
The article itself pointed out the real problem with the villagers was that the local landlord owned their land and their debts - a local landlord with the ability to raise everyone's ground rent, increase the work requirements for debt service and appropriate most of the direct cash payment for himself.
A compulsory purchase order served on the landlord, and/or some kind of rent control might well be a more effective long term solution to these villagers' long term needs - even though such schemes have obvious potential for bureaucratic abuse.