4 ms·
Hmm, actually I think we still disagree about the reason for the fall of the USSR (I hesitate to say "disagree" because I don't hold my opinion strongly, I was
by jjoonathan 14y ago
Hmm, actually I think we still disagree about the reason for the fall of the USSR (I hesitate to say "disagree" because I don't hold my opinion strongly, I was tossing it out to solicit opposing opinions). What you described sounds very much like falling due to communism. I have heard a quote "They pretend to pay us, we pretend to work," and I suppose my question is which side caused the ohter. My opinion was that "they pretend to pay us" came first (the domestic economy collapsed under military spending) and "we pretend to work" followed. Do you think this is true or do you think it happened the other way around?
I cannot believe that starvation and apathy could coexist, so at some point the USSR's system must have prevented people from working for additional income, yes? In this case, the distinction between BI and communism becomes apparent: if the supply of labor falls below demand in BI, wages rise until people go back to work. Companies function as usual and are free to fire lazy workers. If food becomes more expensive, wages effectively fall until farmers can hire enough help (human or otherwise) to crank production back up again.
- pandaman 14y agoThis is a quote from a stand up comedian, Michail Zhvanetskiy I believe. I don't think it describes the economy in the USSR very well even though it's catchy and funny. People considered working as some out of ordinary experience. For instance there were so-called "student construction squads" (строительные отряды, ССО) that consisted of young people, usually students, who toured the countryside and doing whatever construction work they could find (and there was a lot). This was a very well paid job and you could make a year of normal salary in a few months. People joined those to make enough money to buy new furniture or car etc. and after that returned to slacking off at their government job/study. There had been many more outlets like this so there were ways of getting reward for hard work. However very few entertained the idea of doing this full time.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoThere have been a number of BI experiments and the results have so far been universal, initial growth followed by stagnation. The challenge is to create productive work for these people so that they can earn an income. Some of the Chinese 'make work' projects have been interesting in that regard but they are not a final solution. What might be a more durable system would be to create a manufacturing plant that these folks could work in. It doesn't have to be complex, could be as simple as making cinder block for building construction. It has to be run as a business in the sense that standards are set and checked and people are paid based on their production. You have to be rigidly scrupulous about keeping corruption out of it, this is a lot harder than you estimate. Ideally the production is consumed in other projects. (like building buildings or railroads or other factories).
- seoguru 14y agoDo you have any references to these experiments that were followed by stagnation? I only found a few experiments listed here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income_guarantee http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income_guarantee and all appeared to have positive outcomes with no mention of stagnation.
- omegant 14y agoIn Spain something similar has been used for decades now. It's called PER , rural employment plan, it's not exctly BI, as people Is supposed to earn the pay with days recolecting fruits or olives. But there is a lot of fraud and most people avoids doing them but they still receive the paycheck. Initially it was done to improve the poverty of that country zones, and it certainly has improved, but people has become adicted to the free money and that region is perpetually low growth figures. Peole just works the necesary to live, you must add tha the climate is pretty good and is easy to be at a terrace all day having a coffe or some beers. This system also is prone to ballot buys by local policians. Every time someone wants to reduce the payments she looses lots of votes. I think that on it's own BI will improve the living conditions of people dramatically, but on the long run will need to be substituted and complemented by other system.
- pfortuny 14y agoYes, OTOH, economists need to realise that "there is indeed a free lunch" at lots of places, especially in sunny and humid areas. If you can eat with almost zero effort, you will probably not put any more effort in anything. Tropical countries are very much influenced by this.
- scarmig 14y agoBy "it's not exactly BI," you mean "it's not at all BI." The core premise and compelling logic of BI comes from the fact that it is simple, not-gameable, and, most importantly, doesn't have huge disincentive effects at the margin as benefits phase out. PER sounds like it runs headlong into all of those issues. By the standard you're using to critique BI using PER, I could just as well point to PER to critique markets as a whole.