3 ms·
Elsewhere on the website, they discuss a few reasons why they think they are more likely to complete their mission than others who have attempted. Sadly, a coup
by whatshisface 14y ago
Elsewhere on the website, they discuss a few reasons why they think they are more likely to complete their mission than others who have attempted. Sadly, a couple of their points seem a bit iffy:
- Simple rovers – Through the use of relatively simple rovers, designed to conduct basic settlement construction prior to human astronaut arrival, saving both time and cost.
I'm not a professional aerospace engineer, but construction robots seem just a bit more complicated than picture-taking robots. (oversimplification, but you get my point.) If it's so much easier, how come robots aren't building houses here on earth?
- No new developments – The entire plan revolves around the use of existing, validated technology
The falcon heavy hasn't even been built yet, I don't know how they can say this.
- kiba 14y agoBy their settlement date, a falcon heavy or a variant of it, should be ready.
- shmageggy 14y agoSo it doesn't exist, and is therefore unvalidated...
- tempestn 14y agoFrom their site: "While most of the components required are not immediately available with the exact specifications required, at this time, there is no need for radical modifications to the current component designs. All suppliers have confirmed their ability to build what is required--and they can do so now." So their meaning is that, while the specific stuff they need doesn't yet exist, the technology to create it exists. In other words, if the components were needed today, they could be built today, with existing ("validated") technology. Agreed that there's a non-trivial stretch from there to say the components themselves are validated.
- TeMPOraL 14y agoIn defense, it's being built right now. AFAIR SpaceX tested engines for it recently. It's engineering. When you have a design validated "on paper" you're likely already 80% done - the rest is to actually assemble and fix problems simulations didn't catch.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]