4 ms·
> If there's a trade-off between having more parasites at the bottom of society who don't work vs. having more parasites at the top who ruin others' wor Nonono
by jjoonathan 14y ago
> If there's a trade-off between having more parasites at the bottom of society who don't work vs. having more parasites at the top who ruin others' wor
Nonono, you have it backwards. We NEED more parasites! The supply of labor exceeds demand right now which sends the price to 0 (minimum wage paints the problem a different color but doesn't fix anything). We need to decrease the supply of labor so that the market can start pricing it rationally again.
If everybody stops working, the price of services skyrockets. But the problem (soaring cost of services) and the solution (soaring reward for labor) are one and the same. This is how the free market is supposed to work. In fact, I'd go so far to say that BI presents a closer approximation to a free market than the system we have now (where the government price-controls labor).
- michaelochurch 14y agoYes, we basically agree. I don't consider it abstractly good for someone to live on society, while able to work, and not working. However, the cost of that is pennies compared to what we pay by having terrible leadership (parasites at the top).
- Houshalter 14y ago>The supply of labor exceeds demand right now which sends the price to 0 That's not quite how prices work. There is always a demand for labor. If the price of labor fell low enough there would be plenty of jobs. Though no one would want to work at those wages, it's even illegal to do so. The point is just that the price will never really fall to zero, even if it gets low. >If everybody stops working, the price of services skyrockets. But the problem (soaring cost of services) and the solution (soaring reward for labor) are one and the same. This is how the free market is supposed to work. In fact, I'd go so far to say that BI presents a closer approximation to a free market than the system we have now (where the government price-controls labor). That's not the intention of guaranteed minimum income at all, and not a good thing either. You are just cutting off one place (higher prices) to feed the other (higher wages). At least if I understand what you mean correctly, which I'm not sure. But the idea of the system is that it will balance out wealth disparities over time, but not too unfairly on people who do succeed. As well as provide a safety net. And get rid of all the bad incentives and complications created by other systems which attempt to do the same.
- johnnyg 14y ago> Nonono, you have it backwards. We NEED more parasites! The supply of labor exceeds demand right now which sends the price to 0 (minimum wage paints the problem a different color but doesn't fix anything). We need to decrease the supply of labor so that the market can start pricing it rationally again. We need to fix the market in a new way, so that the market can be free? What the what?! A free market is one where price accurately reflects the mix of supply and demand. A free market is NOT and NEVER one where supply and demand are manipulated to produce a "better" result. You are arguing supply side good, demand side bad but consider zooming out and asking first if manipulation of either variable will really produce a predictable, desirable result. I've heard lot of arguments that say "but this is GOOD market manipulation" but it always ends in tears. Supply and demand will always win out in the end. The market is faster, smarter and stronger than you. The winners are the ones that can ride the waves, see what the result of manipulation this way to that will be, and position themselves accordingly. Increasing the ability of the participants in the system to react in these ways makes the system more rational, and in turn more stable. Juicing one variable or the other makes people build knowledge/lives/decisions on a pseudo foundation that will eventually be undercut by market forces. It teaches people the wrong things and makes the system less rational and therefore more bubble prone.
- nitrogen 14y agoI think the argument you quoted (and it looks like your reply somehow got attached to the wrong post) was implying that the supply of labor is unnaturally inflated by requiring people to work to eat. Basic income, the argument proceeds, would allow unwilling suppliers of labor (the "wage slaves") to drop out of the market, as they naturally would if they weren't forced to participate. There would no longer be a need for a minimum wage at that point (since all wages earned go on top of a basic income), so the supply, demand, and price of labor could reach their true equilibrium.
- nitrogen 14y agoThat's not the intention of guaranteed minimum income at all Aside: there's a difference between "guaranteed minimum income" and "basic income", at least as I've seen them discussed here on HN. As I understand it, an $X guaranteed minimum income encourages laziness because the first $X worth of one's labor is essentially wasted. Basic income, on the other hand, is added to whatever a person earns from labor, so there's no disincentive to work.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThe supply of labor exceeds demand right now which sends the price to 0... The price of labor has not decreased since 2001 (the beginning of the data series). Wages have not decreased either. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/ECICOM http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/ECICOM http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/ECIWAG http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/ECIWAG