6 ms·
Don't forget that it comes out of the excess of those who do decide to work. I'm not confident that if this was rolled out globally, there would be enough peopl
by andrewflnr 14y ago
Don't forget that it comes out of the excess of those who do decide to work. I'm not confident that if this was rolled out globally, there would be enough people who really decide to "make something of their lives" to support the system. Sure, a lot of them will hate themselves if they don't, but, honestly now, how often does that stop laziness? Don't look at yourself to answer, look at the culture.
- EGreg 14y agoStudies show welfare spending has reduced poverty dramatically and measurably in ALL countries studied. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfares_effect_on_poverty http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfares_effect_on_poverty Other studies show, however, that it has diminishing returns, especially as it leads to poverty/ghetto culture. However this is changing with technology, internet and mobile phones. People are more docile than in the 90s with the gangsta rap craze.
- Retric 14y agoBad link, try: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare%27s_effect_on_poverty http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare%27s_effect_on_poverty
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- batemanesque 14y ago"ghetto culture"? "the gangsta rape craze"? seriously?
- EGreg 14y agoRap, not rape. Well I could share statistics which clearly show a major rise in violent crime by urban youth in the 90s, with a major decline afterwards, and there could be several explanations for that. As for "ghetto culture" - I am referring to the statistics on single mothers / teen mothers in urban ghetto neighborhoods, and the amount of violence, drug use and drug dealing and done by chronically unemployed males who are feeling disenfranchised and without a purpose. Note that poverty by itself is not the main factor - the same neighborhoods before welfare (50-60 years ago) which retained similar demographics in terms of race saw far leas of either one of these phenomena. The culture was certainly different, with a greater emphasis on productive labor, two parent households, and responsibility. And I say all this to show the diminishing returns from welfare, because the welfare class will be expanding to include more and more people as automation takes over. But on a more positive note: http://www.ted.com/talks/steven_pinker_on_the_myth_of_violence.html http://www.ted.com/talks/steven_pinker_on_the_myth_of_violen...
- err_badprocrast 14y agoFirst of all, gangster rap is still extremely popular among youth. > Well I could share statistics which clearly show a major rise in violent crime by urban youth in the 90s, with a major decline afterwards, and there could be several explanations for that. Several easy to spot deterrents of youth crime implemented in the 90s: - Zero Tolerance in schools (automatic expulsion if you have anything that even looks like a weapon) - If you commit a violent crime as a juvenile these days you're likely to get tried and sentenced as an adult (specifics depending on state) As for teen mothers, I can't contribute much to that discussion - but the CDC's data on 15-19 year olds shows a marked and consistent drop in birth rates from 1990 to 2010. [1] > violence, drug use and drug dealing... done by chronically unemployed males who are feeling disenfranchised and without a purpose. Although not socially accepted, it is often treated as a job; I'd also advise caution in trying to limit drug use and dealing to specific demographics. On the topic of welfare, you'd probably be surprised how many college students make use of food stamps these days. 1. http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6118a8.htm?s_cid=mm6118a8_e%0d%0a http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6118a8.htm?s_cid=...
- EGreg 14y agoYes, as far as the assaults among urban youth, perhaps active policies are able to provide good explanations for the decline in violence. I for one believe that culture usually plays a larger role than is commonly admitted in politics, where the emphasis is often on punishment (e.g. for drug dealing) when the same money could, in my opinion, have been spent more productively on prevention / education / culture change in various communities. The recent Obama administration move to treat drugs as a public health issue seems to be going in this direction. As far as teen mothers -- yes, overall it's been a drop, but that just underscores the disconnect with what's happening with poor urban youth: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2871086/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2871086/ "Teen pregnancy rates in New York City (NYC) are consistently higher than in the United States (US) overall, particularly among blacks and Hispanics and within poor neighborhoods." I think the teen pregnancy phenomenon is part of a larger phenomenon of people having children out of wedlock, and then the mothers raising them as single parents. When it's the norm to have the state provide funds to help raise the children, it creates a moral hazard and affects the culture in communities which are highly dependent on welfare. As far as actual drug use and drug dealing, I'm not knowledgeable enough to get into details, except to note that the War on Drugs seems to have produced some pretty sad results. 20% of the inmates are in prison for recreational drug related offenses, and the amount of youths from poor neighborhoods is alarmingly high. I would say that this War on Drugs has, among other things, been affected by the negative side effects of the welfare state and minimum wage laws. I agree with Thomas Sowell that minimum wage has held many back who would otherwise have found employment somewhere. However if you're going to abolish minimum wage, you should definitely offer the unconditional safety net in the article. Welfare is a complicated issue, the most I have been able to understand overall is that it definitely lowers poverty, but its long-term effect on culture in poor communities has been to create a culture of dependence, disenfranchisement, and out-of-wedlock parenthood. The last one seems to perpetuate the first two. This may rapidly change with the internet disrupting education and other sectors, and I hope it does. I lean more left/progressive but I have to agree that this is unsettling: http://thf_media.s3.amazonaws.com/2010/pdf/wm2934_bythenumbers.pdf http://thf_media.s3.amazonaws.com/2010/pdf/wm2934_bythenumbe... And what's most unsettling is that the welfare state in the USA will have to expand as jobs are eliminated.
- jjoonathan 14y agoFree market principles still apply: if all plumbers retire when BI starts then the price people are willing to pay to hire a plumber will increase until somebody decides it's worth doing again. What if it becomes impossible for you to hire a plumber? Well, that would be the sound of opportunity knocking ;)
- michaelochurch 14y agoWith BI, there are going to be some people who use it as an excuse to slack off. They're not ambitious or energetic and, relieved of the need to make something of their lives, they probably won't do much. That's true. Here's a question: how much are they doing right now? My guess: not much. Given the high rate of unemployment that exists already, it seems like society's value for unskilled work is pretty low already. So I don't think the bulk loss to society in having the least ambitious ~10-20% slack off is that bad, especially if a large number of people are more engaged in their work. Parasites at the bottom of society are pretty harmless. Parasites at the top, on the other hand, are extremely damaging. We have a lot of the second kind. Because people have to work and most need a steady income that just barely meets expenses, that pretty much means they end up in a subordinate role, there's a class of useless people called "executives" who have total control over the economy (and mediocritize it, because it's best for their positional stability to do so) because people are terrified of losing the jobs and incomes. If there's a trade-off between having more parasites at the bottom of society who don't work vs. having more parasites at the top who ruin others' work, I'd take the former, hands down.
- jjoonathan 14y ago> If there's a trade-off between having more parasites at the bottom of society who don't work vs. having more parasites at the top who ruin others' wor Nonono, you have it backwards. We NEED more parasites! The supply of labor exceeds demand right now which sends the price to 0 (minimum wage paints the problem a different color but doesn't fix anything). We need to decrease the supply of labor so that the market can start pricing it rationally again. If everybody stops working, the price of services skyrockets. But the problem (soaring cost of services) and the solution (soaring reward for labor) are one and the same. This is how the free market is supposed to work. In fact, I'd go so far to say that BI presents a closer approximation to a free market than the system we have now (where the government price-controls labor).
- michaelochurch 14y agoYes, we basically agree. I don't consider it abstractly good for someone to live on society, while able to work, and not working. However, the cost of that is pennies compared to what we pay by having terrible leadership (parasites at the top).
- Retric 14y agoBI, does not remove the benefit from traditional employment. Rather it removes the bureaucracy and cutoffs around traditional government benefits. Currently, you get no benefits if your disabled for 5 months and a significant check if it's 6 months. With BI, you get the same money either way, and while it's probably less than the 6 month benefit the risk reduction is worth a lot. Better yet, get laid off and want to try making iOS apps? Just do it, your benefits are unaffected if you want to start a company. Now, the downside is currently upper middle class people get higher disability benefits/social security payments. With BI that goes away, society does not care how old you are or what you made you get the same basic income as everyone else. So you better have savings if you want keep living in a high cost of living area.
- rayiner 14y agoI'm convinced that you could give everyone exactly the same income, and people would work for artificial "prestige points."
- andrewflnr 14y agoWas that supposed to be encouraging? ;)
- rayiner 14y agoKind of... I don't think a basic income would be much of a de-motivator that large swaths of the population would stop working. The social status that came from having an important job would still motivate people, indeed even more so if money was removed as a way to differentiate people.
- nitrogen 14y ago"prestige points." AKA "Whuffie" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whuffie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whuffie, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Down_and_Out_in_the_Magic_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Down_and_Out_in_the_Magic_King..., http://www.gutenberg.org/files/8086/8086-h/8086-h.htm http://www.gutenberg.org/files/8086/8086-h/8086-h.htm)
- mempko 14y agoI would argue that the current institution of work is what causes laziness. When people day in and day out go to work for 8 or more hours a day to a job they hate. When they come home, there is nothing left but wanting to be "lazy". I suspect that this trait is learned in our current environment.