3 ms·
To me, this sort of thing is common sense. All the austrian economics fans talking about better price signals as an argument for less regulation - all of them s
by EGreg 14y ago
To me, this sort of thing is common sense. All the austrian economics fans talking about better price signals as an argument for less regulation - all of them should consider using the same argument for giving an unconditional safety net to the poor.
When a poker player has a small stack at a table, he makes poorer choices. Similarly, poor people cannot optimally use their resources, but must avoid one potential crisis after another. If you free them from the rat race, you can even end minimum wage.
What I see in the USA for the past few years is really a class struggle manufactured by ideologues, people vilifying the rich, others vilifying the poor... but with increasing automation and outsourcing, more and more people will find themselves unemployed. If those people had money they'd spend it on basic necessities and the things they want the most. This in turn will empower those industries to produce more things people actually need, and innovate. Who knlows, maybe the poor will even be able to help fund solutions to their own challenges in their communities. Even Milton Friedman advocated for a negative tax.
- mjn 14y ago> All the austrian economics fans talking about better price signals as an argument for less regulation - all of them should consider using the same argument for giving an unconditional safety net to the poor. Interestingly, one of the founders of Austrian economics, F.A. Hayek, actually did argue for a minimum income: http://www.kmjn.org/snippets/hayek79_minimumincome.html http://www.kmjn.org/snippets/hayek79_minimumincome.html
- scarmig 14y agoLibertarians often are big pushers of a minimum income, actually. It's far more direct and efficient as a means of improving the welfare of the least productive, and it's the least prone to special interests pushing for tax cuts because of how much their good helps kids/the poor/whatever. With a sufficient basic income, you could effectively get rid of Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, food stamps, public subsidies in all types of places they're unnecessary or harmful. And you remove the disincentive effect on productivity that most welfare schemes have. Most academic libertarians, in my experience, aren't of the sort that thinks private property rights is the sole criterion and sole justification for everything; their opposition to government activities is based a lot more on how it distorts price signals, public choice issues, and issues of implementation. The basic guaranteed income sidesteps all of those.
- cinquemb 14y ago>With a sufficient basic income, you could effectively get rid of Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, food stamps, public subsidies in all types of places they're unnecessary or harmful. And you remove the disincentive effect on productivity that most welfare schemes have. This might be a stretch, but this could be seen as the part mentioned in the article: “The idea of unconditional income comes from the failure of conditional programmes. As soon as there are conditions, there is erosion. Conditionality means intermediaries, which means power, which means corruption.” But then again, what will all the companies that benefit handsomely from these conditional programes do (outside of lobbying with the money they are currently given by government)?
- eruditely 14y ago>When a poker player has a small stack he makes poorer choices This immediately shows you have not played poker seriously or have a working knowledge of poker knowledge. The framing of the question is wrong too,
- cynicalkane 14y agoInstead of jumping to conclusions, consider that the OP is probably talking about a typical person playing poker who is prone to making bad decisions for psychological reasons. Hey, that's just like most real-life people, which is what this article is about.
- EGreg 14y agoThank you. Exactly. I wanted to add one thing, which I have found to be a good general principle: To help someone (including yourself) achieve real success the best way is to make it safe to fail. That makes it safe to take risks - because there are no certainties in life. That poor kid with a talent for singing would have a better shot at helping the world if he was able to take a risk eg pursue his singing education instead of working at McDonalds 10 hours a day to pay his rent.
- pi18n 14y ago> To help someone (including yourself) achieve real success the best way is to make it safe to fail. Oh I was just thinking this same thing a while ago. If we want to reduce unemployment we have to empower people to employ themselves, since corporate spending appears to be trickling down in other countries. I was thinking of it in the context of free healthcare and free education.
- nhaehnle 14y agoI'm not sure if that's what you're saying, but keep in mind that targetting the unemployed for self-employment is usually not an effective strategy. Mass unemployment is a macro problem and not the individual fault of the unemployed, but despite that, the people who end up unemployed do tend to be on the lower end of the skill range. This means they are not the best candidates for self-employment to begin with. It's better to make it safe for those who are employed to give up their employment to create new businesses and thus create more jobs. Though in the end, it always comes down to aggregate demand. Even encouraging startups does not boost aggregate demand.
- lake99 14y ago> All the austrian economics fans ... Depends on why one is a fan of Austrian economics. There is this (strawman) group that Krugman loves calling "austerians". And then, there are others who subscribe to the idea of "Not Yours to Give". (http://www.fee.org/library/detail/not-your-to-give-2 http://www.fee.org/library/detail/not-your-to-give-2) Friedman was inconsistent. There is not much point ascribing an ideology to what he said. There is no scope for Austrian economics in India. I won't get into the "why" of that. Our politicians love spending our money on schemes that get them votes. This is another such scheme. But, if I can give away a portion of my income directly to people who are extremely poor, (after proving that they, indeed, are), and declare that as a 100% tax deduction, I'd support it! It won't happen. Our politicians will want to introduce a scheme that they can name after one of their dead party-members. They want to be seen as the direct benefactors. Come election time, they want to be able to tell the poor "now look, under the Narasimha Rao* scheme, we give you x hundred rupees each month. Vote for us, and we will double that amount." * As if that's going to happen!
- wisty 14y agoPublic choice theory, isn't it? If they give everyone the same cheque, then no-one will feel special. No-one will feel reliant on the politicians for giving them a special handout.
- jfoutz 14y agoHere's a negative tax talk from Friedman. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtpgkX588nM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtpgkX588nM I'm a big old lefty, but i found it pretty compelling.
- jjoonathan 14y agoBI has the advantage that it retains 100% of the marginal incentive to work at the low end of the spectrum. This comes at a marginal cost to the entire system, poor and rich alike, but arguably the poor need to be incentivized more than the rich.
- thatswrong0 14y agoThe negative income tax really isn't a left or right issue, despite the fact it was advocated for by a free-market proponent. The only problem I have with it is not the idea itself (I quite like it), but instead the income tax all together and the entire tax code. In the U.S. we waste a ton of money every year conforming to the tax code and there are many simpler ways that we could collect federal government revenue. I especially don't like the idea of taxing income. Something like the Fair Tax solves this but introduces a few problems as well. It would interesting if we could develop a system which functions like the negative income tax but has the efficacy of a sales tax.
- boboblong 14y agoWhat about plain old Georgism/"geolibertarianism" with the proceeds from the LVT going straight to a uniform citizen's dividend? In my view, this would be a near-perfect system, having only a couple of flaws: 1. The difficulty of disentangling improvements on land from the land itself/fairly valuing land 2. It doesn't address the issue of population growth
- jacoblyles 14y agoWhat would you think the odds are that we institute a minimum income policy and a large class of people still systematically make bad life decisions? Because I think it is quite large.