5 ms·
> The very fact that it can be transferred like property, even "accidentally," means it is essentially meaningless. In what respect? If I create a work and so
by Angostura 14y ago
> The very fact that it can be transferred like property, even "accidentally," means it is essentially meaningless.
In what respect? If I create a work and someone would like to buy the rights from me, why shouldn't I be allowed to sell the rights?
- mistercow 14y agoI think most people agree you should be able to "sell the rights" in the sense of licensing them to someone, and to allow others to sublicense, and to enter contracts that grant exclusivity for sublicensing. What's somewhat bizarre is that you can permanently transfer ownership of the work, making it legally as if the other person was the original creator.
- MarkMc 14y agoI don't think it's bizarre. If I'm a tailor and create a new suit, I can transfer ownership to someone else. If I create music then I should have a similar right to permanently transfer copyright ownership. To me that seems 'natural', and moreover it makes the copyright more valuable, providing a greater incentive to produce the music.
- mistercow 14y agoIt's useless to try to compare physical goods to creative works. A tailor can't retain a suit while allowing me to have it. A musician can give you a song, but still have that song. These concepts of ownership just aren't compatible.
- Aqueous 14y agoBecause the law is recognizing something that didn't happen. If I transfer my copyright to someone else, the law then views that person as the originator, owner and creator of that work, legally speaking. But it is not true. I created the work, not the person to whom I transferred the copyright, and no legal formality can change that fact. The law is saying something that isn't true. I suppose all ownership is this way. My answer, then, is that creating something is fundamentally different than owning it. Your creation of something isn't property that can be transferred.