6 ms·
Every time I've visited the Valley area I can't help but notice the enormous difference in density between San Francisco and the Valley in general. Where parts
by astrodust 14y ago
Every time I've visited the Valley area I can't help but notice the enormous difference in density between San Francisco and the Valley in general.
Where parts of San Francisco are jammed with houses, every nook occupied, not unlike parts of Manhattan or Boston, there are large swaths of the Valley with nothing but parking lots.
Any time I've asked a local why the densities aren't higher, why a ten story apartment building is such an anomaly, I get some vague grumbling about earthquakes. San Francisco has a number very tall buildings with a few even built on the side of a literal mountain, and all of these have survived several significant quakes, so I doubt this is the actual reason.
It's absolutely surreal the amount of under-utilized real-estate one must drive past or around simply to get where they're going.
- jseliger 14y agoAny time I've asked a local why the densities aren't higher, why a ten story apartment building is such an anomaly, I get some vague grumbling about earthquakes. For whatever reason, very few people make the connection between supply, demand, and prices in metro areas, which is a point I wrote a lot more about here: http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2013/04/08/connecting-the-dots-between-beliefs-an-example-from-density-and-housing-policy http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2013/04/08/connecting-the-dots... .
- rdouble 14y agoWhere parts of San Francisco are jammed with houses, every nook occupied, not unlike parts of Manhattan or Boston, there are large swaths of the Valley with nothing but parking lots. San Francisco is not unique in this regard. Every urban area in America is like this, including Boston and NYC. San Francisco has a number very tall buildings with a few even built on the side of a literal mountain, and all of these have survived several significant quakes, so I doubt this is the actual reason. The buildings on the hills are the ones that survive the quake. The buildings built on sand, like in the Marina or Mission Bay, are the ones that are vulnerable to earthquakes.
- jjtheblunt 14y agoWhy is that (sand vs hill)?
- rdouble 14y agoThe hills in SF are made of rock.
- symmetric 14y agoIt's not that hills don't shake, it's just that your house has a better chance of staying up if the foundations are laid in bedrock, and most hills in SF are close to the bedrock.
- Steve_Baker 14y agoLiquefaction: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soil_liquefaction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soil_liquefaction
- jfb 14y agoI cannot pimp John McPhee's Assembling California [1] highly enough. It is fantastic, and contains a wonderful section about the '89 quake. Really, anything John McPhee writes is worth stopping whatever one is doing and getting started. He's a national treasure. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Assembling-California-John-McPhee/dp/0374523932 http://www.amazon.com/Assembling-California-John-McPhee/dp/0...
- astrodust 14y agoYou say "every" urban area, but I've been to enough American cities to know this isn't true. Phoenix? Cleveland? Kansas City? Denver? They're parking lots with buildings sprinkled here and there. Density isn't even a priority. Land values are too low to promote higher density. A lot of this has to do with the fact that Boston, Manhattan, and San Francisco are geographically constrained, they're hemmed in by water. Chicago is like this to a degree, but has sprawled enough that it's irrelevant for the most-part. It is shocking how many cities view their landscape as worthless, paving it over instead of constructing something that contributes to the betterment of the city. Though when cars rule, concessions must be made. Nobody seems to care about the people who live and work in a city.
- masklinn 14y ago> San Francisco has a number very tall buildings with a few even built on the side of a literal mountain, and all of these have survived several significant quakes Also, Japan (after they set up seismic building codes, which was a decade or 2 before the Great Hanshin Earthquake, the number of older non-code buildings explaining the differences in destruction and life loss between the fairly similar Great Hanshin and Northridge quakes)
- jjtheblunt 14y agoThey don't mention ubiquitous EPA superfund sites?
- nostromo 14y agoIt has nothing to do with earthquakes and everything to do with zoning laws, HOAs and general NIMBYism. Here's a fun example: http://www.mercurynews.com/breaking-news/ci_13512735 http://www.mercurynews.com/breaking-news/ci_13512735. Palo Alto city council members falling all over themselves to stop LA to SF high-speed rail. They argued that the train should terminate in San Jose, no joke.
- hapless 14y agoSan Francisco actually has the same problem as the valley. Housing prices are going through the roof because the city REFUSES to re-zone for higher density. The last time there was significant re-zoning, there was a great deal of whining about "Manhattanization." Manhattan has incredible population density, and residents have some of the lowest environmental impacts in america. What's bad about that? The same slate columnist wrote about SFO real estate earlier: http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/04/11/san_francisco_zoning_needs_more_density_and_tall_buildings.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/04/11/san_francisco...
- _delirium 14y agoSF's population density isn't Manhattan's, but it's quite high overall, one of the highest in the US. The city in total has a bit over 17,000 people per square mile; that's 3x the density of Seattle and 6x that of Austin, for example. The parts where demand is highest (the eastern half) are even higher, e.g. about 25,000/sq. mi in the Mission. Compare that to, say, Palo Alto, where housing is in strong demand (due to Stanford and startups) and yet they've only allowed density to reach a paltry 2,500/sq.mi. If they allowed high-density housing near downtown Palo Alto and Stanford, it'd not only improve things on the peninsula, but also reduce some of the pressure on SF housing from people who currently reverse-commute.
- akjj 14y ago> SF's population density isn't Manhattan's, but it's quite high overall San Francisco has half the population density of Brooklyn and less than Queens or the Bronx. It's also less than Somerville, Massachuetts or West Hollywood in LA county. People talk about having more people in San Francisco and they think of Manhattan, but there's actually a lot of room for increased density without looking like Manhattan.
- _delirium 14y agoThat's true, Manhattan-style skycrapers aren't the only option. The transit-reachable parts of SF are already denser than some of what you mention as comparable, though: the Mission has 50% higher population density than West Hollywood. One problem is that density is much lower in places like the Outer Sunset, in part because there's no cross-town subway. Total SF population could be increased significantly if the western half's population density could be brought up to what's already the case in the eastern half.
- pfarrell 14y agoBut what is San Francisco jammed with? 2 and 3 story buildings. The land may be maxed out in coverage, but it's still totally underutilized. SF has 17k/sq mi as opposed to Manhattan's almost 70k/sq mi. It's a town that has decided it won't be any bigger (ymmv).
- dyno12345 14y agoSan Francisco is actually still extremely conservative in terms of doing new building - not at all like Manhattan.
- wiredfool 14y ago6-10 stories is kind of the worst height for earthquake resistance, since the fundamental frequency of the building (tends) to be 10/stories, and there's a lot of energy in the 1hz area for earthquakes. Shorter buildings tend to move along with the earthquake, and taller ones just sway. It's 10x worse if it's unreinforced masonry, but that's not been to code in California since forever. (But it's what happens in less developed locations) (That's of course, if they're built to code and don't have things like a weak wall, like buildings with one open wall on the ground floor for parking. ) That's not to say that it can't be done, but 4 stories and below can be just plain old code compliant architecture, but once you get up into 10 stories, you're talking about structural engineering and all that goes with it.
- 13b9f227ecf0 14y agoSilicon Valley firms need young men to find their socialization at work and put in long hours. In a properly functioning urban society people have many strong local relationships outside work. In a normal place you leave work at 5:00 or 6:00 and connect with folks who will be around in 20 years, unlike the institution where you punched out. The monied interests arguably have incentive to perpetuate sprawl & anomie.
- dyno12345 14y agoThey have no problem getting people to work 9am to 9pm in Manhattan, yet there are still plenty of things to do after work