9 ms·
The Whole Problem Is That There Is No Housing Boom In Silicon Valley
- SurfScore 14y agoCould this have anything to do with the fact that abundant displays of wealth (I.e. a mansion) are frowned upon by some in the Valley? I honestly have no idea, but you hear stories about tech millionaires living modest lives in SV all the time. Nothing wrong with that at all, but if they aren't spending the money they have then its not helping the economy (at least in this respect).
- svachalek 14y agoNo. There are plenty of mansions too. But the prices here are all about the fact that demand keeps increasing while supply is not allowed to.
- astrodust 14y agoEvery time I've visited the Valley area I can't help but notice the enormous difference in density between San Francisco and the Valley in general. Where parts of San Francisco are jammed with houses, every nook occupied, not unlike parts of Manhattan or Boston, there are large swaths of the Valley with nothing but parking lots. Any time I've asked a local why the densities aren't higher, why a ten story apartment building is such an anomaly, I get some vague grumbling about earthquakes. San Francisco has a number very tall buildings with a few even built on the side of a literal mountain, and all of these have survived several significant quakes, so I doubt this is the actual reason. It's absolutely surreal the amount of under-utilized real-estate one must drive past or around simply to get where they're going.
- jseliger 14y agoAny time I've asked a local why the densities aren't higher, why a ten story apartment building is such an anomaly, I get some vague grumbling about earthquakes. For whatever reason, very few people make the connection between supply, demand, and prices in metro areas, which is a point I wrote a lot more about here: http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2013/04/08/connecting-the-dots-between-beliefs-an-example-from-density-and-housing-policy http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2013/04/08/connecting-the-dots... .
- rdouble 14y agoWhere parts of San Francisco are jammed with houses, every nook occupied, not unlike parts of Manhattan or Boston, there are large swaths of the Valley with nothing but parking lots. San Francisco is not unique in this regard. Every urban area in America is like this, including Boston and NYC. San Francisco has a number very tall buildings with a few even built on the side of a literal mountain, and all of these have survived several significant quakes, so I doubt this is the actual reason. The buildings on the hills are the ones that survive the quake. The buildings built on sand, like in the Marina or Mission Bay, are the ones that are vulnerable to earthquakes.
- jjtheblunt 14y agoWhy is that (sand vs hill)?
- rdouble 14y agoThe hills in SF are made of rock.
- symmetric 14y agoIt's not that hills don't shake, it's just that your house has a better chance of staying up if the foundations are laid in bedrock, and most hills in SF are close to the bedrock.
- Steve_Baker 14y agoLiquefaction: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soil_liquefaction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soil_liquefaction
- jfb 14y agoI cannot pimp John McPhee's Assembling California [1] highly enough. It is fantastic, and contains a wonderful section about the '89 quake. Really, anything John McPhee writes is worth stopping whatever one is doing and getting started. He's a national treasure. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Assembling-California-John-McPhee/dp/0374523932 http://www.amazon.com/Assembling-California-John-McPhee/dp/0...
- masklinn 14y ago> San Francisco has a number very tall buildings with a few even built on the side of a literal mountain, and all of these have survived several significant quakes Also, Japan (after they set up seismic building codes, which was a decade or 2 before the Great Hanshin Earthquake, the number of older non-code buildings explaining the differences in destruction and life loss between the fairly similar Great Hanshin and Northridge quakes)
- jjtheblunt 14y agoThey don't mention ubiquitous EPA superfund sites?
- nostromo 14y agoIt has nothing to do with earthquakes and everything to do with zoning laws, HOAs and general NIMBYism. Here's a fun example: http://www.mercurynews.com/breaking-news/ci_13512735 http://www.mercurynews.com/breaking-news/ci_13512735. Palo Alto city council members falling all over themselves to stop LA to SF high-speed rail. They argued that the train should terminate in San Jose, no joke.
- hapless 14y agoSan Francisco actually has the same problem as the valley. Housing prices are going through the roof because the city REFUSES to re-zone for higher density. The last time there was significant re-zoning, there was a great deal of whining about "Manhattanization." Manhattan has incredible population density, and residents have some of the lowest environmental impacts in america. What's bad about that? The same slate columnist wrote about SFO real estate earlier: http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/04/11/san_francisco_zoning_needs_more_density_and_tall_buildings.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/04/11/san_francisco...
- _delirium 14y agoSF's population density isn't Manhattan's, but it's quite high overall, one of the highest in the US. The city in total has a bit over 17,000 people per square mile; that's 3x the density of Seattle and 6x that of Austin, for example. The parts where demand is highest (the eastern half) are even higher, e.g. about 25,000/sq. mi in the Mission. Compare that to, say, Palo Alto, where housing is in strong demand (due to Stanford and startups) and yet they've only allowed density to reach a paltry 2,500/sq.mi. If they allowed high-density housing near downtown Palo Alto and Stanford, it'd not only improve things on the peninsula, but also reduce some of the pressure on SF housing from people who currently reverse-commute.
- akjj 14y ago> SF's population density isn't Manhattan's, but it's quite high overall San Francisco has half the population density of Brooklyn and less than Queens or the Bronx. It's also less than Somerville, Massachuetts or West Hollywood in LA county. People talk about having more people in San Francisco and they think of Manhattan, but there's actually a lot of room for increased density without looking like Manhattan.
- _delirium 14y agoThat's true, Manhattan-style skycrapers aren't the only option. The transit-reachable parts of SF are already denser than some of what you mention as comparable, though: the Mission has 50% higher population density than West Hollywood. One problem is that density is much lower in places like the Outer Sunset, in part because there's no cross-town subway. Total SF population could be increased significantly if the western half's population density could be brought up to what's already the case in the eastern half.
- pfarrell 14y agoBut what is San Francisco jammed with? 2 and 3 story buildings. The land may be maxed out in coverage, but it's still totally underutilized. SF has 17k/sq mi as opposed to Manhattan's almost 70k/sq mi. It's a town that has decided it won't be any bigger (ymmv).
- dyno12345 14y agoSan Francisco is actually still extremely conservative in terms of doing new building - not at all like Manhattan.
- wiredfool 14y ago6-10 stories is kind of the worst height for earthquake resistance, since the fundamental frequency of the building (tends) to be 10/stories, and there's a lot of energy in the 1hz area for earthquakes. Shorter buildings tend to move along with the earthquake, and taller ones just sway. It's 10x worse if it's unreinforced masonry, but that's not been to code in California since forever. (But it's what happens in less developed locations) (That's of course, if they're built to code and don't have things like a weak wall, like buildings with one open wall on the ground floor for parking. ) That's not to say that it can't be done, but 4 stories and below can be just plain old code compliant architecture, but once you get up into 10 stories, you're talking about structural engineering and all that goes with it.
- 13b9f227ecf0 14y agoSilicon Valley firms need young men to find their socialization at work and put in long hours. In a properly functioning urban society people have many strong local relationships outside work. In a normal place you leave work at 5:00 or 6:00 and connect with folks who will be around in 20 years, unlike the institution where you punched out. The monied interests arguably have incentive to perpetuate sprawl & anomie.
- dyno12345 14y agoThey have no problem getting people to work 9am to 9pm in Manhattan, yet there are still plenty of things to do after work
- Apocryphon 14y agoAn excellent comment on a compelling article from January: "As a lifelong resident of Silicon Valley, I can only laugh. Our patented brand of NIMBY liberalism married to Asperger's-induced libertarianism makes this plan an utter pipedream." http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/13/01/a-grand-plan-to-make-silicon-valley-into-an-urban-paradise/266998/#comment-761592824 http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/13/01/a-grand-... Previous discussion of article here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5032555 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5032555
- guelo 14y agoWeird to call NIMBY a liberal thing when many conservatives hate any kind of density planning or mass transit.
- modarts 14y agoI think the juxtaposition of the terms was intended by the commenter.
- jacoblyles 14y agoHow many conservatives live in San Francisco? 12?
- moocow01 14y agoMany actually - they just don't realize they are in most ways conservatives.
- jacoblyles 14y agoI do think pro-regulation liberalism is fundamentally "conservative" in many ways, in that it is risk-averse.
- dyno12345 14y ago"A conservative is someone who stands athwart history, yelling Stop" When it comes to building things, yes, they are conservative.
- babesh 14y agoPeople live in the Peninsula partly for the house with a yard. People live in SF for the city life etc... Its been self selecting for a long time. You will get a lot of opposition to high rise apartments in those areas especially since the existing residents don't 'need' or even want these developments. You don't even have BART in middle to lower parts of the Peninsula. Where you do see Bart, you see a little bit of the developments that you speak of (Millbrae, South San Francisco, etc...) There is increased demand. It translates into higher prices for the Peninsula and increasing development and somewhat higher prices in the outskirts (East Bay, South Bay, etc...). Also, see a bit more in fill in the Peninsula. Previously, subpar empty lots are being bought and built on.
- gojomo 14y agoEvery lot within 500m of a rail station should automatically be zoned to allow for 6-story buildings and ground-level retail. And, building to the max height should earn lots a lower property tax rate. Manifest density!
- roc 14y agoThat would just see the NIMBYs shift to blocking the rail stations entirely.
- simcop2387 14y agoIf they're like any other city I've been in, they're already trying to block them because it ostensibly leads to lowered property values since the cheaper transportation lets more people come in to the area.
- modarts 14y agoThat's a complete myth. Housing values are actually helped by having nearby public transit: http://www.houselogic.com/home-advice/green-living/public-transportation-adds-value-home/ http://www.houselogic.com/home-advice/green-living/public-tr... http://www.realtor.org/news-releases/2013/03/home-values-performed-42-percent-better-when-located-near-public-transportation-during-last http://www.realtor.org/news-releases/2013/03/home-values-per...
- jeffasinger 14y agoYes, but logic and statistics tend to do very little to dissuade the anti-transit NIMBY types. They're fueled by things like this: http://www.glennbeck.com/agenda21/ http://www.glennbeck.com/agenda21/
- solistice 14y agoThat reminds me of Stuttgart 21, a project that blocked by Nimbys took too much money to complete, and I think was abandoned. But honestly, it's not as bad as what the Frankfurt Int. Airport has to deal with. Want a new runway to accomodate increases in flight volume? Sorry, can't build that here. You might be Germanys major Airport, but backyards are more important than you.
- ttrreeww 14y agoI hope more startups move to Texas...
- steve-howard 14y ago> Some people might get dispaced out of the individual house they live in, [...] Exactly. Who is going to have a voice in community matters, particularly when it comes to eminent domain: local homeowners, or hordes of hypothetical people that don't live there yet?
- cpursley 14y agoAs a commercial real estate appraiser with a pretty good understanding of land economics, I completely agree. When land is pricy, there is no other logical option than to go up. The only thing zoning serves is the uberwealthy and those with political influence. There should be no zoning at all. None. Just look at the best cities in the world including pre-zoning America - their growth was dictated by pure economic need, not by nimyism. To use startup jargon, zoning makes it difficult and costly to iterate real estate to the 'highest and best use'. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=43Egm0j_p1A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=43Egm0j_p1A
- salgernon 14y ago"There should be no zoning at all. None." Yea, that worked out great in West, Texas: http://news.yahoo.com/why-did-west-texas-build-homes-school-next-134119153.html http://news.yahoo.com/why-did-west-texas-build-homes-school-...
- cpursley 14y agoRare. The market typically sorts this stuff out. You'd be surprised by the amount of due diligence is required for a bank to lend on a property or an insurer to insure it.
- balloot 14y agoTotally. The market, and a dozen or two dead people, typically sorts this stuff out. So what's the problem?
- prostoalex 14y agoFor short-term yes. For long-term, how do you deal with overbuilding and/or large groups of people moving away to the next up-and-coming city, leaving behind a ghost town of empty high rises? Some overbuilt cities in China or Eastern Europe have that issue.
- acgourley 14y ago
- davidw 14y agoHe wrote an entire book on this subject: http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0078XGJXO/?tag=dedasys-20 http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0078XGJXO/?tag=dedasys-20 Which wasn't bad. Pay the ratings no mind - when it came out, he'd just written something that pissed off a lot of folks for some reason and so they got it into their heads to try and trash his book.
- patmcguire 14y agoYeah, said the taboo on speaking I'll of the dead was stupid and the world was a better place without Brietbart.
- newnewnew 14y agoI can't defend all of Breitbart's actions, but he did commit some acts of serious original journalism. A recent New York Times expose on $4 billion in waste in the Department of Agriculture due to fraudulent civil rights claims was based on original reporting on Breitbart.com[1]. By itself the traditional media doesn't report on these kinds of stories because they are afraid of being called racist. [1]http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/26/us/farm-loan-bias-claims-often-unsupported-cost-us-millions.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/26/us/farm-loan-bias-claims-o...
- illuminate 14y ago"By itself the traditional media doesn't report on these kinds of stories because they are afraid of being called racist." His racist obsessions (Sherrod comes to mind) are why people didn't take his "original reporting" seriously.
- illuminate 14y agoAnd by "his racist", I mean his pandering to a particular demographic.
- webjprgm 14y agoUgh, please no. The real problem is that startups can't decide to open up shop somewhere else, like Pleasanton or Napa. Somewhere that's just as accessible to all the VCs and conferences but not so short on housing. I don't want mega city. I'm sure a lot of people who have made the Silicon Valley their home for many years agree. It's just the young crowd who has to live in apartments anyway that think more mega Apartment buildings would be great. I completely refuse to live in SF because of the density and turn down any job based in SF automatically.
- icebraining 14y agoBut does anyone want to live in Pleasanton or Napa? (I wouldn't know, just curious)
- steve-howard 14y agoI grew up in San Ramon (10 mins from Pleasanton), and I can assure you that -- mind-numbingly boring as I found the place -- many people want to live there.
- steven2012 14y agoIt's easy to give objective evaluations about what should be done, but the reality is that given how many people have spent inordinate amounts of money for their homes already, they will likely fight tooth and nail to ensure that their houses maintain their values. The last thing current home owners will be is charitable towards newcomers, who would pay less for homes than what they had to, and at the same time dragging down their own home prices. I think the low density housing in the Valley is just a situation that people will have to live with for the foreseeable future. The thing is, there are plenty of cheap housing in the outer-lying areas like Livermore, Tracy, Stockton, etc. They just need to invest in proper transportation options, like extending BART to those cities.
- taurath 14y agoWhen people have to pay $4000/mo to rent a 3bedroom condo that the person next door pays $1300 on their mortgage (as is probably the case in many areas currently), won't companies eventually think that they can offer far more than just location to potential employees if they go elsewhere? I moved to the bay in 2004, and I was able to comfortably afford a few decent apartments in mountain view/sunnyvale. Those apartments have gone up by 200% in their price because of proximity to FB, Google and other firms. Everything will continue to get more and more expensive as the cost of basic services goes up and up - eventually you'll start losing a lot of good creative people because nobody can afford to take an entry level job and work their way up. The bar for living "comfortably" in the bay area has been rising extremely fast, and those who have bought a home 20 years ago can live fine, but for young people especially it will be really difficult to catch up. I've had 7 or 8 friends in their 20s and 30s move to the Seattle area for purely economic reasons - a few to colorado and a few to Texas as well.
- steven2012 14y agoThis is just a function of the markets. If people can't afford to move here, and vacancy increases, then housing prices will naturally drop. I've seen this happen more than a couple of times in the last 15 years. I have no doubt that rent prices will drop sometime in the next couple of years, because the rate of growth is unsustainable. One of my friends moved out of her 2br2ba apartment at Avalon Mission Bay because her rent was increased to 5100/month.
- jameswilsterman 14y agoEveryone should read the author's e-book (it's a really short ~30 min. read). http://www.amazon.com/The-Rent-Damn-High-ebook/dp/B0078XGJXO http://www.amazon.com/The-Rent-Damn-High-ebook/dp/B0078XGJXO After reading his book, I am convinced that overpriced rent is a massively important problem that makes countless aspects of society worse. I've read that people spend roughly 1/3 of income on housing, 1/3 on food and 1/3 on everything else. The long term trend in the U.S. has been to greatly reduce the % of our income we spend on food (due to agricultural and tech innovation). We need to do the same for housing prices over the next 20 years. A small space to live for one person in NY or SF should simply not cost ~30% of your annual income! The materials are very cheap to build a square box! And there is lots of vertical room in our nicest cities to build square boxes. The issue is solely constrained supply due to building regulations (many at the local level). For tech leaders in SF, this seems like it should be the next big political fight (after immigration).
- lucaspiller 14y agoLooks good, but it's not available in the UK. Anything related?
- bradleyjg 14y agoThe author has been a prolific blogger for around five years now. While he's moved around a bunch, his name is about as google-able as it gets (yg arrow pass the Norse world tree thing).
- jseliger 14y agoSend me an e-mail, and you should have an e-mail address in your profile. Edward Glaeser's The Triumph of the City covers the same ground in a more academic tone and is available in the UK.
- Steko 14y agoIt's a great read. Don't be dissuaded by the low ratings at Amazon; they're from conservative trolls over comments he made after the death of Breitbart. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/06/andrew-breitbart-fans-matthew-yglesias-amazon_n_1324362.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/06/andrew-breitbart-fa...
- chipsy 14y agoI think the whole thing is another symptom of the local government's dysfunctional incentives. There's no unified agenda for the Bay Area, and it hurts everyone. It shows in the approach to housing and transportation, in business development, and in the nature of political campaigns. To some extent, I would venture to say that the region suffers from a form of Resource Curse - nice location and weather, and a tech ecosystem that, these days, spins money out of "nothing." Lots of wealth, lots of idealism, but nobody with both the privilege and the responsibility to organize it all in a way that would fix the issues.
- gcb0 14y ago1. get lots of land 2. bribe zoning people to not allow more people to grab land 3. instead of building/managing lots and lots of buildings, put the price of the few ones high up. it's basic pricing. if you can limit the demand and charge more, its much safer than lowering the price and trying to scale. you guys talk about that all the time here with digital goods and service. but now get impressed that people do that with real world goods since the dawn of time?!
- protomyth 14y agoI do wonder sometimes if standardized, truck haul-able modules of housing wouldn't be an interesting alternative to apartments. Build a building that you plug the modules. Want to move, haul the module to a new building. I guess I wonder more about what could change to lower the cost of housing.
- joonix 14y agoThat's called modular or pre-fab housing and it exists. The problem here is not building costs, by any means. It's artificial restrictions on the market by local councils who refuse to support higher density living.
- protomyth 14y agotrue on the politics of it. I am thinking something a little different than pre-fab, something more along the lines of plug-able module into building. More along the lines of cargo containers in a warehouse.
- messick 14y agoPeople with money (i.e. home owners) don't want an apartment on the 7th floor. They want a ranch style home with a front and back yard. Which is what they have right now in SV. This argument has been going on for as long as there has been a "Silicon Valley" to make housing expensive, so decades. Nothing will change, because the people who actually live there now like it the way it is.
- cmbaus 14y agoI don't agree. There are plenty of people with money who want an urban lifestyle.
- saosebastiao 14y agoThat is an incredibly bad generalization. Not only are the wants of wealthy people not absolute, but the general trend of housing for the last 20 years are the exact opposite.
- mixmastamyk 14y agoI'm generally pro-density, but after reading about the toxic waste there, I'm not excited about new development in the area.
- daniel-cussen 14y agoI feel like Santiago, Chile is what the valley would be like if it didn't have zoning. An intense, urban environment with nice neighborhoods and a downtown. A real downtown, with a real nightlife, high quality walking, good public transport, cheap taxis, low taxes, low crime, all without sacrificing fantastic weather. At the same time, Santiago, while vibrant, requires you speak Spanish, and is not the Valley.
- pconf 14y agoGood luck with that. Problem is the Valley has been a real estate developer's dream for 60+ years and it has not had the effect this (opinionated but poorly researched) article espouses. Rezoning alone is "dumb planning". Rail, transit, bike friendly streets, greenbelting and farmland preservation all must be in place first in order for density rezoning to work. Problem is Santa Clara County has been all about cars and freeways for as long as they have existed. Just last month they closed the San Thomas Creek bike trail for the convenience of the 49er stadium construction. Now cyclists at the Santa Clara Amtrak station are forced to ride on Tasman which has no bike lanes, Sharrows or shoulders. It's exactly this kind of dumb planning that allowed developers to demolish the downtown that Santa Clara once had and perpetuate the kind of auto-centric sprawl that characterizes Silicon Valley.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- snambi 14y agoThere is only one problem. "Land is limited". And people like to live in single-family homes.