3 ms·
This is a pretty good example of why asking people to write code in an interview is a pretty poor way to measure their fitness for the job...
by swombat 18y ago
This is a pretty good example of why asking people to write code in an interview is a pretty poor way to measure their fitness for the job...
- philwelch 18y agoI've always felt that writing code on a whiteboard is a crap way to interview people, and I feel that way every time I'm interviewed that way. At least give me a text editor so my mental associations come back to me quick enough.
- shrughes 18y agoI don't understand this. What do you mean by mental associations?
- biohacker42 18y agoThe brain is a funny thing. You can be both good at coding AND at speaking in front a white board, but at the same time suck at coding on a white board. I can tell you that from personal experience.
- philwelch 18y agoI write all of my code with a keyboard, in a text editor. If I have a keyboard and a text editor my brain remembers how to write code better than if I have a whiteboard and a marker, because I don't write code on whiteboards. The brain works this way, which is why you feel sleepy when you go to bed (unless you spend a lot of time in bed not sleeping). It's a type of compartmentalization, well known in psychology.
- biohacker42 18y agoIt is crap, and I say that as someone who's gotten hired after white board coding every time. I am a good public speaker, and I like to think I'm a good coder, but damn do I suck at coding on a white board. If you're a good coder/public speaker, you have to practice white board coding if you're looking for a job.
- paulgb 18y agoOddly enough, I prefer coding on paper or a whiteboard and transcribing the code if I'm working on a problem I find particularly hard. I think I'm unusual though, I haven't met many people who prefer coding on paper.
- gcv 18y agoI've seen candidates who screw up problems which boil down to trivial "if" or even just "return" statements on the whiteboard (like "write a function which determines if the argument is an even number"). The argument of mental associations makes sense, but having someone in front of a whiteboard with a trivial problem is a good way to tell if the candidate can program at all.
- philwelch 18y agoYeah, bozo test questions are simple enough to do on a whiteboard.
- tvon 18y agoIf you know how to do it, you should know how to do it on a whiteboard.
- anamax 18y ago> I've always felt that writing code on a whiteboard is a crap way to interview people I've never worked at an organization where folks didn't work through ideas together at a whiteboard. Some of said "work through" involves code snippets. So, while coding on a whiteboard may not be necessary/useful, communicating about code on a whiteboard is extremely important.
- shrughes 18y agoIt seems more like an example of why the interviewee should get a good night's sleep before the interview.
- sgk284 18y agoI'm the author of the post and if people take one thing away from it, I hope that's what they take.