> "What's the points of this? I've been doing the same thing since the 80s by piping four shell commands together?!?" - is not really constructive. > I think u

> "What's the points of this? I've been doing the same thing since the 80s by piping four shell commands together?!?" - is not really constructive. > I think using the slightly formulaic "What I liked: X; What could be improved: Y" has a high chance of being constructive feedback. I think you're confusing critique with mentorship. What you're expecting is something wise to be said, or at least something useful to you. Critique is not necessarily like that. Critique is encompassing pretty much everything that others answer you freely, like it or not.