6 ms·
The drama around words like this is between people who don't actually use the concepts they represent. The words "disrupt", "synergy", and "cloud" are useful wo
by erikpukinskis 14y ago
The drama around words like this is between people who don't actually use the concepts they represent. The words "disrupt", "synergy", and "cloud" are useful words ONLY if:
- You care about the high level strategies a startup might implement in order to take on an entrenched player who is playing a game no one can beat them at.
- You are seeking mutually beneficial intra-business relationships.
- You would like to provision machines without managing them yourself.
Journalists and non-practitioners fight back and forth about words like this because they have no skin in the game. I will continue happily using the word "disrupt" because I read the Innovator's Dilemma and I think Christensen highlighted a powerful concept that needed a label. And I will continue using the word "cloud" because I remember what it was like to have to buy a dedicated server every time I wanted to spin up a new service.
And I could give a rat's ass if some journalist thinks that's hokem.
- danmaz74 14y ago> Journalists and non-practitioners fight back and forth about words like this because they have no skin in the game Actually I think that the real problem is with unscrupulous marketing from practitioners than with journalists and non-practitioners. When a word becomes a trend, everybody wants in, so the word is stretched so much that it loses its original usefulness. Take cloud for example - what does it really mean today? Even the usual old VPS today is marketed as a "cloud" solution...
- venomsnake 14y agoCloud has never had meaning. I always thought that fog was the much more appropriate weather event for the vague concept that all the different people tried to push.
- bcoates 14y agoCloud is a VPS plus a decently real-time API for provisioning and configuration, so I can treat servers as an abstract software component. Pre-cloud era VPSes often required humans in the loop for simple administrative tasks.
- vacri 14y agoMy pet hate is 'impact'. There was a perfectly usable word before: affect. No-one uses it anymore, because everything has to have IMPACT! Not enough toilet paper in the loo today? How will that impact employee morale? Different brand batteries in your wireless keyboard? What IMPACT will that have on performance? But sadly the horse has bolted on that one, its jig is up, and gone the way of the dodo... literally.
- ezequiel-garzon 14y agoI believe you mean "effect", right?
- mcav 14y agoI don't think so: "how will that impact X" vs "how will that affect X"
- bjterry 14y agoIt depends on the specific case, since impact is used as both a noun and verb, while affect and effect in this sense are typically used as a verb and a noun respectively. In his two examples, one would be replaced with affect and one would be replaced with effect.
- vacri 14y agoBoth of them :)
- derefr 14y agoCloud mostly means "you don't pay your sysadmin; the colo does."
- dlitz 14y ago"Cloud" just means "outsourcing your infrastructure". Or, in some contexts, "I don't care how it works, as long as it does X, Y, and Z" (like the cloud in a network diagram).
- wisty 14y ago> Take cloud for example - what does it really mean today? I think it's a fancy word for "on the net".
- danmaz74 14y agoIt's what it has become - but originally it meant what now has become SaaS (eg gmail)
- aaronblohowiak 14y agoIf the VPS is automatically provisioned and billed by the hour, it is "cloudy"
- michaelochurch 14y agoGreat post. I really hate how the MBA douches have ruined "synergy" because there really is no good synonym when the word is appropriate.
- LanceH 14y agoThere is probably something good in German, but it will be 18 letters long.
- megrimlock 14y agoEvolutionary pressures on spoken language drive common concepts to claim shorter symbols, so it seems fine to pay 18 letters (plus an escape to an alternate language) for this more-rarified meaning of synergy, leaving "synergy" and "disrupt" as depleted membership tokens of the crunchosphere.
- rhizome 14y agoYeah, let me know when I should start taking business advice from Slate.
- sutterbomb 14y agoThe author also clearly stated that "disruptive" is indeed a powerful concept that needed a label. And he clearly stated that it should still be used in cases where it actually fits the model that Christensen intended. The whole premise of the article is that most people are using the term in cases where the concept doesn't match up at all, and I don't see how you're refuting that.